Bates vs Haverford vs Hamilton vs Colby

No input on the other three, but cross Haverford off your list immediately.

https://quillette.com/2020/12/01/race-and-social-panic-at-haverford-a-case-study-in-educational-dysfunction/

Hamilton has a very strong alumni network and has a solid amount of people on the street especially compared to how small of a school it is. Mainly recruited by only a few BBs, but if you have a strong GPA/resume/etc., grinding on your own with a solid school name can get your foot in the door. There is a solid amount of alums at BCC, LEK, etc. Everyone with whom I have spoken in Consulting was very friendly and responsive. Recent grad, but just my two cents.

just go to hamilton, and if you don't like it, transfer

Currently go to another Nescac school, feel like I’ve seen way more Colby grads in banking than any of the other schools so that might be your best bet if you want to take that route (though I’ve also heard that Hamilton has a decent network)

definitely Hamilton. They have great placement the others not so much

These schools are literally all the same. Non-targets that recruit from prep schools and have a strong alumni network because of daddy connections. They are all the same to me. 

Judging by the list of school's OP applied to, I'm guessing you are a rich kid from the North East who likes to watch the Red SAWX OUT EN HAWVAD YAWD AND PLAY LACWOSSE