Nonaccrual Experience Method (NAE)
It is a tax accounting approach prescribed by the Internal Revenue Service (IRS) for addressing bad debts
What is the Nonaccrual Experience Method (NAE)?
The nonaccrual experience method (NAE) is a tax accounting approach prescribed by the Internal Revenue Service (IRS) for addressing bad debts.
This method specifically applies to bad debts arising from services rendered in certain designated sectors such as accounting, actuarial science, architecture, consulting, engineering, health, law, or the performing arts.
Furthermore, the eligibility for employing the NAE method is restricted to companies with an average annual gross receipts of less than $5 million in preceding tax years.
Under the accrual-based accounting approach, revenue is acknowledged upon earning it. For service-oriented entities like those within the NAE method's scope, revenue is recorded when services are delivered.
This approach may lead to outstanding amounts owed by customers for previously rendered services. Bad debts become possible when it is anticipated that customers may not fulfill payment for these services.
Key Takeaways
- The Nonaccrual Experience (NAE) Method is an accounting principle designed to address the handling of debts that are either in default or significantly overdue.
- Using this approach, companies are not required to recognize income that, according to historical data, is not anticipated to be received.
- Instead, debts deemed unlikely to be recovered can be recorded as losses.
- This approach is meant for handling unpaid debts related to services provided in specific sectors like accounting, actuarial science, architecture, consulting, engineering, health, law, or the performing arts.
Understanding the Nonaccrual Experience (NAE) Method
When a company is unable to recover money owed to it, it experiences a bad debt. The nonaccrual experience (NAE) method is specifically designed for tax return purposes; however, alternative methods, such as the charge-off method, may be considered if not applicable.
This method is widely adopted, enabling the company to project potential liabilities from unpaid debts based on its past dealings with customers and suppliers.
Unclaimed bad debts on a business's tax return through the NAE method can also be pursued through alternative charge-off methods, which are more commonly employed.
A charge-off is the removal of a debt from the balance sheet by a creditor when it is deemed unlikely to be recovered, and the lost funds are recorded as an expense on the income statement.
It allows specific service providers to exclude the accrual of revenue deemed unlikely to be collected, following formulas and experiences authorized by IRS regulations.
However, this exemption is exclusively applicable to companies within designated industries.
- Accounting
- Actuarial science
- Architecture
- Consulting
- Engineering
- Health
- Law
- The performing arts.
Under the specified guideline, a taxpayer can employ a Net Annual Earnings (NAE) accounting method if they utilize an accrual accounting method for service-related income, belong to the designated service sectors, and have generated less than $5 million in gross receipts in any of the preceding three tax years.
Note
The matching principle dictates that costs should align with the revenues generated within the corresponding accounting period. According to Generally Accepted Accounting Principles (GAAP), for tax purposes, the estimation of bad debt expenses must be conducted using the allowance method in the same period as the sale occurs.
NAE Book Safe-Harbor Method
In September 2011, the IRS introduced Rev. Proc. 2011-46, offering a straightforward approach for taxpayers using the NAE method to account for revenues.
This method, known as the book safe harbor, permits eligible taxpayers to calculate uncollectible revenues by applying a 95% factor to their allowance for doubtful accounts, determined based on their relevant financial statements.
A safe harbor is a legal provision that allows for avoiding or reducing legal or regulatory liability in specific circumstances, contingent upon fulfilling specified conditions.
The term "safe harbor" finds applications in various industries, including finance, real estate, and law. In finance, real estate, and legal contexts, the term denotes a defensive strategy companies employ to deter hostile takeovers.
In this context, safe harbors refer to accounting approaches that help circumvent legal or tax regulations. They can also pertain to methods that provide a more straightforward way of determining tax consequences than the precise language specified in the tax code.
Within regulatory liability, safe harbor provisions are present in various laws and contracts.
For instance, within the regulatory framework established by the Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC), these provisions shield management from legal responsibility when providing sincere and well-intentioned financial projections and forecasts.
Qualifications and Calculation Guidelines
The NAE book-safe harbor method is generally more accessible to qualify for than some other safe harbor methods. However, it is exclusive to companies in NAE-designated industries.
Certain safe harbor methods pose challenges due to the need for extensive historical information.
For instance, some methods mandate a six-year financial tracking requirement, making it challenging to locate all necessary information and meet the criteria for safe harbor qualification.
Taxpayers who meet the necessary qualifications can determine the excluded amount from their revenue according to Section 448(d)(5) by calculating 95% of the year-end allowance for doubtful accounts on their applicable financial statement.
This calculation should consider the portion associated with current-year accounts receivable that qualify for the net accounts eligible (NAE) designation.
However, the safe-harbor method cannot be utilized for estimating doubtful accounts linked to accounts receivable if the taxpayer is restricted from applying the NAE method.
This restriction may apply to receivables not generated through the provision of NAE-eligible services or receivables subject to interest or penalties for late payment. Only accounts receivable the taxpayer earns in the current tax year are eligible for this method.
The revenue procedure permits taxpayers to employ any reasonable approach for calculating the allowance for doubtful accounts related to current-year NAE-eligible accounts receivable. The methodology should consider pertinent information readily accessible to the taxpayer.
To determine the eligible allowance for doubtful accounts, taxpayers are required to utilize an applicable financial statement. Rev. Proc. 2011-46 outlines the applicable financial statements in descending order of priority:
- A financial statement mandated for submission to the SEC (such as Form 10-K or the Annual Statement to Shareholders).
- A certified audited financial statement accompanied by the report of an independent CPA. This statement is used for credit, reporting to shareholders, or other significant non-tax purposes.
- A financial statement (excluding tax returns) is required for submission to a federal or state government or any federal or state agency (excluding the SEC or IRS).
A taxpayer cannot utilize the NAE book safe-harbor method without an applicable financial statement to determine taxable income.
Complexities with the NAE Book Safe-Harbor Method
Despite the apparent simplicity of the NAE book safe-harbor method, taxpayers may encounter complexities during its application. Understanding these nuances is crucial for businesses seeking to leverage the benefits of the NAE Method while ensuring compliance with its criteria.
1. Assessing if a competent service leads to the generation of a receivable
The NAE method applies to taxpayers with annual gross receipts surpassing $5 million, but only if they engage in services within specified fields. Identifying whether a company falls under a qualifying service category can be challenging.
A major manufacturing firm may offer consulting services, the proceeds of which could qualify for the NAE (Net Advantage to Employer) method. Or a bank might offer financial advisory services, leading to the generation of eligible income.
However, the earnings from these businesses' services could be easily ignored as they are relatively minor compared to their other revenue streams.
Besides failing to consider the potential application of the NAE method, companies that are otherwise qualified to utilize it may have revenue streams that are not eligible.
Taxpayers need to be aware that earnings derived from fully owned finance, management, or rental entities may not meet the criteria for the NAE method.
2. Assessing the value of outstanding receivables associated with the revenue generated in the current fiscal year
The NAE book safe-harbor method applies to taxpayers' receivables generated within the current fiscal year.
If a calendar-year taxpayer establishes an allowance in June for a receivable generated in the preceding December, it will not meet the NAE book safe-harbor method criteria.
If a company has a lot of receivables, it's not practical to analyze each one individually. The revenue procedure lets taxpayers use a reasonable method based on readily available data, making the process more manageable.
3. Assessing if a taxpayer possesses a relevant financial statement
Many privately owned businesses typically don't release a Form 10-K and may not undergo an audit as outlined in the revenue procedure.
These corporations might have submitted documents to state or federal government entities, including the Internal Revenue Service (IRS) or the Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC).
Taxpayers should pay close attention to certain filings eligible for the NAE book safe-harbor method. Complex legal structures could lead to audits for some entities within a taxpayer's structure, while others may not be audited.
Addressing these complexities is crucial when figuring out the eligible accounts receivable amount.
Steps to switch to the NAE Book Safe-Harbor Method
The following are the step Steps to switch to the NAE Book Safe-Harbor Method:
- Review Eligibility Criteria and Consult Rev. Proc. 2011-46: Rev. Proc. 2011-46 outlines the steps that taxpayers must follow if they wish to switch to the NAE Book Safe-Harbor Method for accounting. Unless there are specific restrictions, making this change is considered an automatic change in the accounting method.
- Determine Current Methodology: Taxpayers who are not currently utilizing any NAE method or are employing a different safe harbor to switch their accounting methods to the NAE book safe-harbor method.
- Follow Revenue Procedure 2011-14 Guidelines: To switch their approach, taxpayers are required to follow the guidelines outlined in Revenue Procedure 2011-14.
- Include Form 3115 with Tax Returns: Consequently, individuals should include Form 3115, Application for Change in Accounting Method, with their tax returns filed on time and submit a duplicate to the IRS National Office.
- Monitor IRS Communications: If the IRS examines the taxpayer's Net Asset and Earnings method, whether in an IRS examination, before an IRS Appeals office, or in a federal court, the audit protection outlined in Section 7 of Revenue Procedure 2011-14 is not applicable.
Nonaccrual Experience Method (NAE) Examples
While the NAE is not always directly observable in real-world examples, we can consider hypothetical scenarios to illustrate its application:
1. Small Business Loan
In a situation where a neighborhood restaurant, supported by a local bank, struggles economically, leading to substantial payment delays, the bank may employ the NAE by discontinuing the accrual of interest until the restaurant makes payments.
2. Mortgage from a Housing Finance Company
When a homeowner facing unforeseen financial challenges falls significantly behind on mortgage payments from a housing finance company, the finance company may opt for the NAE.
It will refrain from recognizing unpaid interest as income until the homeowner makes the necessary payments.
3. Corporate Debt in Commercial Banks
Suppose a manufacturing firm, having received a substantial business loan from a commercial bank, undergoes financial challenges or faces bankruptcy.
When questioning the likelihood of loan repayment, the bank may invoke the NAE, no longer acknowledging additional interest income on that particular loan.
One should consider that when a lender marks a debt as nonaccrual, they are worried about the borrower's ability to repay. This has effects on both the lender's financial reports and meeting regulatory rules.
Nonaccrual Experience Method (NAE) FAQs
The Nonaccrual Experience Method (NAE) in accounting refers to a practice in the financial industry where interest income from a nonperforming loan is not recorded as revenue until it is received. This approach is adopted because of the uncertainty surrounding the actual receipt of such revenues.
According to the NAE, anticipated interest earnings should only be recognized as revenue once they are received. This may result in a temporary decrease in the lender's reported earnings.
Certainly, a loan can transition back to accrual status if specific conditions are satisfied. This typically involves ensuring that both principal and interest payments are up to date and that there is a reasonable expectation of timely future payments.
Accrual accounting records revenue upon its realization and expenses when they are invoiced. In contrast, the NAE adopts a different approach by acknowledging interest income solely upon its actual receipt due to uncertainties regarding its collectability.
or Want to Sign up with your social account?