2nd tier Mgr or m/b/b Associate?

This question makes no sense. Are we talking about choices that exist in different dimensions? If you're post MBA, then wouldn't both positions be post-MBA? Why is one position called a manager and the other an associate. If the firms are both in the top ten, I can't imagine them doing things that differently.

maybe the first is engagement manager (higher than associate at mckinsey) role

then second one would be the associate role?

that really depends on your long term goals

if you want to stay in consulting, its basically 2 years difference from the 7+ years that it will take one to make partner

(personally i would take post-mba role at MBB because the projects you work on and your exposure is at a different level, exit opportunities also very different)

7S you're right. First is engagement manager, second is associate role. Thanks for your input! And jhoratio: Yes, they evaluate do those things differently for an experienced hire.

MBB

MBB generally promote on merit not tenure so if you join and perform at "manager level" it won't be long until you make manager.