What causes WACC to invert?
Hi together, I'm currently working on a valuation and cannot figure out my mistake (if it is one). I calculate WACC by using the basic formula:
WACC = (E/V) * Cost of Equity + (1-(E/V)) * (1-t) * Cost of Debt
Since the company is private I calculate the Cost of Equity using the CAPM and a relevered beta. The formula therefore becomes:
WACC = (E/V) * (rf + BETAu * (1 + (1-(E/V))/(E/V)) * (1-t)) * MRP) + (1-(E/V)) * (1-t) * Cost of Debt
I noticed with my specific inputs (infrastructure company = very low unlevered beta, low risk free rate, low cost of debt) WACC declines when I increase (E/V) which seemed counterintuitive. I just differentiated the above formula (by hand so there might be a mistake) with respect to (E/V) and got the following result:
dWACC/d(E/V) = rf + t * BETAu * MRP - (1-t) * Cost of Debt
Looking solely on the deviated formula I can see that if the last part of the equation (= (1-t) * Cost of Debt) becomes greater than the first part (= rf + t * BETAu * MRP) WACC should decrease for an increase in (E/V). Mathematically understood (correct me if my maths has errors) but how can expain the result economically?
I most likely expect that indeed the math is wrong. The effect can happen when the asset yields an (unlevered) return that is lower than the cost of debt (which also seems counterintuitive in this case)
I would be grateful for any help!
Unless I missed it, you've provided no context for your cost of debt. You say it is "low" but it seems that it isn't actually that low relative to the cost of equity. Since your company appears to have a cost of debt, we can assume it actually has borrowings. Are the interest rates in your CAPM actually what the company pays in interest? Other potential culprit is your "very low" beta. Where did you get that? Can you defend it?
Nemo cupiditate sit qui porro vel excepturi optio sunt. Explicabo placeat similique in nemo quod sit fugit. Quis rem in explicabo. Officiis est animi recusandae commodi eligendi. Omnis aspernatur ut eos cumque veniam quidem. Aspernatur rerum esse necessitatibus ut.
Dicta non animi sit voluptatum. Quidem voluptas tempora ipsam odio culpa quae consectetur illo. Nobis quisquam sed similique. Unde ut ea quaerat enim voluptate. Exercitationem necessitatibus eum rerum corrupti consectetur. Labore earum reprehenderit deserunt officia porro voluptas aut omnis.
See All Comments - 100% Free
WSO depends on everyone being able to pitch in when they know something. Unlock with your email and get bonus: 6 financial modeling lessons free ($199 value)
or Unlock with your social account...