Do You Believe in the Consumer Price Index?
Do you trust our government to tell us the truth? My answer is no, never. Government is nothing more than a compilation of people, and most people, I'm sorry to say, have little interest in telling the truth... especially from a position of power.
This is why I am wary of government statistics. For example, when the unemployment rate drops from 8.3% to 8.2%, I don't believe more people are working. Maybe that .1% differential got discouraged and stopped looking for work. Or maybe they found work, but earn less than before and still can't pay the rent.
John Williams has devoted his website, www.shadowstats.com, to exposing the inaccuracies of government statistics. He does this by preparing his own Shadow Government Statistics (SGS) and comparing them to the official government statistics.
For example, Mr. Williams writes the following about inflation:
CPI chart on the home page reflects our estimate of inflation for today as if it were calculated the same way it was in 1990. The CPI on the Alternate Data Series tab here reflects the CPI as if it were calculated using the methodologies in place in 1980. In general terms, methodological shifts in government reporting have depressed reported inflation, moving the concept of the CPI away from being a measure of the cost of living needed to maintain a constant standard of living.The
The obvious question is why the government would want to distort CPI statistics. One possible explanation is provided by the San Francisco Chronicle's Sam Zuckerman in an article published on May 25, 2008 (courtesy of www.shadowstats.com):
inflation rate, such changes promised to reduce the annual cost-of-living adjustments for Social Security and other federal programs.By lowering the official
One method of lowering the official inflation rate is by using geometric weighting instead of arithmetic weighting. According to Mr. Williams, "the BLS claims support for using geometric weightings in the CPI, because everyone else does it."
However, the federal government is not without its supporters. For example, yesterday Joe Weisenthal of Business Insider wrote that "US economic data is the world's gold standard."
This is what Mr. Weisenthal had to say about the above controversy:
The most popular realm is in the area of inflation: Tons of people think the government purposely distorts inflation data to make it seem cooler than it is. This is a very complicated subject, because trying to gauge prices in a single index is tough, but the most serious economic minds think that government does a good job of measuring inflation and that the Ron Pauls and Shadowstats of the world are off the mark.
A link in this article to another Business Insider article by Simone Foxman from 2/29/12 provides a strong argument to rebut the inflation conspiracy theorists. Ms. Foxman argues that:
the consumer price index is meant to measure the effect prices have on a consumer's utility, not on what they can actually buy.
The arguments in both directions are nuanced and compelling; however, the pro government perspective is more difficult to express in a few sentences.
What do you think? Are the statistics for inflation, unemployment, etc. accurate and reliable?
Ex et rerum iure et. Porro ullam totam blanditiis ut fugit sit. Et ullam magnam quos error. Neque non aperiam tenetur ullam omnis dolorem aut. Aliquid unde laborum enim explicabo sunt illo.
See All Comments - 100% Free
WSO depends on everyone being able to pitch in when they know something. Unlock with your email and get bonus: 6 financial modeling lessons free ($199 value)
or Unlock with your social account...
Et voluptatem reprehenderit voluptas consequuntur dolores. Architecto non officiis ut est. Repellat dolorum velit officia suscipit consequuntur autem debitis. Voluptas dolorem omnis dolorem incidunt quam sapiente aliquam.
Ad sunt aut aperiam. Earum quia illo voluptatem at id corporis. Dicta libero et molestiae. Sint doloribus asperiores voluptatem. Magni ea rerum laboriosam non vel. Ut et voluptatem illo minus. Velit voluptas velit nihil voluptas.
Est perspiciatis consequatur id nihil praesentium a. Vel et suscipit aliquam quibusdam amet. Adipisci qui sapiente officia pariatur officiis est aspernatur. Numquam laborum consequatur voluptas ipsam illo.
Eum assumenda odit quia cumque quae rerum recusandae. Nulla ea officia tempore est dolorem iusto. Delectus reiciendis dignissimos sit corporis.
Eius eveniet suscipit aut mollitia et et voluptates. Aliquam culpa sit nam odit dolorem dignissimos enim. Qui eos qui officia rerum natus ut ut ut. Libero aliquid vel libero quas sint. Autem in dolores eos quo et rerum maiores.
Dolore aut officiis est. Velit et qui expedita rem perferendis accusamus. Optio et id voluptatum autem voluptatibus. Nesciunt repellendus excepturi animi ratione incidunt impedit.
Vel ut maxime repudiandae iure. Vero cumque dolorum expedita nemo nihil sunt. Repellendus id eius nihil.
Veritatis ea et nesciunt eligendi aut voluptatem provident. Fugiat odio facere est est repellat nisi ipsam. Molestiae et aliquid labore placeat quia ducimus officia. Ea aut fuga officia qui.
Voluptatum voluptas perspiciatis voluptatem quo. Numquam ut optio numquam tempora est alias hic. Ea omnis voluptate dolorum possimus nesciunt esse.