How would that be treason? Obama is not British and it is not his job as an American president to protect British interests. I am not a fan of his by a long stretch and this transaction is shady as hell, but telling someone else's secrets in order to get an agreement beneficial for the US of A, is definitely a lot better than not getting the agreement or getting it in exchange for something that's valuable to us.
ArgonautHow would that be treason? Obama is not British and it is not his job as an American president to protect British interests. I am not a fan of his by a long stretch and this transaction is shady as hell, but telling someone else's secrets in order to get an agreement beneficial for the US of A, is definitely a lot better than not getting the agreement or getting it in exchange for something that's valuable to us.
The UK has been the US's most loyal ally since the end of WW2. I consider this a great injustice.
Men are so simple and so much inclined to obey immediate needs that a deceiver will never lack victims for his deceptions.
-Niccolo Machiavelli
It's not treason, but it certainly is betrayal. They've been our closest ally for ages. Pretty messed up in my opinion.
This is certainly a hit on US' image abroad. If we're betraying our closest ally, how can other countries trust us?
On the other hand-what if this leak gives us a reason to stop providing that info to Russia? This could certainly feed the conspiracy theories that the US/UK are running Wikileaks.
Thanks Julian. This "uncovers" criminal misdeeds by our government and was something the average citizen needed to know. We will all be better off now that the UK, one of our closest allies, know we F'ed them over. Really doing a wonderful job uncovering shit.
ANTThanks Julian. This "uncovers" criminal misdeeds by our government and was something the average citizen needed to know. We will all be better off now that the UK, one of our closest allies, know we F'ed them over. Really doing a wonderful job uncovering shit.
Could someone assassinate this cock sucker?
Knowing how back-stabbing and two faced your government is, is nice to know. Thanks Julian.
ANTThanks Julian. This "uncovers" criminal misdeeds by our government and was something the average citizen needed to know. We will all be better off now that the UK, one of our closest allies, know we F'ed them over. Really doing a wonderful job uncovering shit.
Could someone assassinate this cock sucker?
Knowing how back-stabbing and two faced your government is, is nice to know. Thanks Julian.
So you would accept that this knowledge being released publicly might diminish our close ties to the UK, because you would rather know the truth? Sacrificing national security just so that the public knows a little more about government dealings is not a satisfactory trade-off.
Couldn't agree with you more Ant. Only a matter of time before this guy and his followers are all quietly assassinated, and good riddance.
ANTThanks Julian. This "uncovers" criminal misdeeds by our government and was something the average citizen needed to know. We will all be better off now that the UK, one of our closest allies, know we F'ed them over. Really doing a wonderful job uncovering shit.
Could someone assassinate this cock sucker?
your being ridicoulus now. Stuff like this needs to get dug up. The US cant screw over its closed allies and then you complain that someone uncovers that? I would tell you what I think of you but that wouldnt make it past the language filter :/
A lot of cognitive dissonance in this thread that the bowing, kowtowing Obama was playing Realpolitik with the Ruskies and the British. New START was important to US interests and if an inconsequential secret about the UK's Trident force was a bargaining chip, so be it.
Besides, all the release of this "secret" did was verify information that is already available on Wikipedia:
While the theoretical capacity of the four Vanguard-class submarines is 64 missiles and 768 warheads, only 58 missiles were leased and some have been expended in test firings. The UK leases the missiles but they are pooled with the Atlantic squadron of the USN Ohio SSBNs at King's Bay, Georgia2 (previously the UK maintained its Polaris missiles).
The number of warheads is significantly less than originally intended, due to a changed strategic situation (i.e., the demise of the USSR). Currently there are fewer than 200 warheads, and the number is anticipated to fall close to 160 in near future.
@Bulge -- Did you really think global politics was a game of truth and transparency? The USA is playing a global game here. I think it is BS that we backstabbed the UK, but who knows the benefit that giving Russia this info might have done. Maybe it helped gain information on Iranian plans. Maybe it was a good faith measure to bring them to the table to disarm. Whatever, it was realpolitik. I don't sleep safer at night with this stuff uncovered.
Julian is an anarchist. He doesn't care about right and wrong, legality, etc. He simply wants to cause mayhem. This information does not show the USA committing any crime, violating civil rights, operating a hidden death camp. All it shows is the USA making back door deals. Wow. Thanks Julian. Really protecting my rights and freedoms with this info.
Our government is not perfect. It does shady shit. Everyone does this. Zero benefit in releasing this information.
The sooner Julian is in a box somewhere the better. This guy is a terrorist if I ever saw one.
ANT@Bulge -- Did you really think global politics was a game of truth and transparency? The USA is playing a global game here. I think it is BS that we backstabbed the UK, but who knows the benefit that giving Russia this info might have done. Maybe it helped gain information on Iranian plans. Maybe it was a good faith measure to bring them to the table to disarm. Whatever, it was realpolitik. I don't sleep safer at night with this stuff uncovered.
Julian is an anarchist. He doesn't care about right and wrong, legality, etc. He simply wants to cause mayhem. This information does not show the USA committing any crime, violating civil rights, operating a hidden death camp. All it shows is the USA making back door deals. Wow. Thanks Julian. Really protecting my rights and freedoms with this info.
Our government is not perfect. It does shady shit. Everyone does this. Zero benefit in releasing this information.
The sooner Julian is in a box somewhere the better. This guy is a terrorist if I ever saw one.
Agreed. Except the last point. I'm sure UK knew about the leaking.
It is global politics. Who knows what Russia put on the table. All I am saying is Julian is not releasing this information to the public to provide any benefit other than creating anarchy.
What is so funny is if Julian actually cared about democracy or freedom or whatever, he would be releasing Chinese, Russian, Iranian, African, etc documents. Let's shine a light on countries clearly violating human rights. But no, let's just release back door negotiations that are necessary and prudent in a complicated global environment.
I also think it is bullshit we back stabbed an ally like this, but if the info we gave Russia led to a decrease in nuclear weapons or a move towards stopping Iranian nuclear progression than I think the betrayal might be worth it.
@leverdarb - please tell me why this needs to be dug up? This is essentially none of our business. The average citizen is not having his rights violated. They are not being hurt by this behavior. The government is making deals on a global level. I didn't realize you had the right to know troop movements in Afghanistan or what the ambassador to Switzerland ate for lunch.
People love Julian for the same reason they love juicy gossip. Doesn't make what this guy is doing any better. People can revile in knowing that the USA told Russia some secretes. The USA now has to live with a less than friendly UK neighbor.
Also, on a practical side, is this even a worthwhile secret? The UK has nukes, but a small amount of them. They are no a significant nuclear power. Russia, USA, and China are serious nuclear powers. No news here, just gossip.
if you think what the ambassador had for lunch is on the same level as betraying one of your longest allies then we can end this discussion now since you are clinically insane?
I agree with you that assange should be jailed and wikileaks should be banned since publishing of the diplomatic cables and alot of other stuff is indeed unneccessary and none of the publics business.
In this case however we are not talking about releasing some minor wrong doing, this is a MAJOR wrongdoing on the US part and as such is worth exposing.
Ok, I may sound like a douche for saying this, and I already mentioned that this is some underhanded shady shit BUT.
While UK was a loyal ally, it hasn't exactly been the most useful. I mean Georgia is a loyal ally too, and why the f wouldn't they be with all the benefits they got without having to provide anything but loyalty in return?
But unfortunately now is the time when we need a friend, not a trusty loyal pet fish or a dog equivalent.
In that aspect Russia could be a lot more useful and thus more of an equal and a true friend than the UK.
Please inform me of what crime the USA broke in passing these secrets. I am not defending this behavior, but other than catching the USA pulling some bullshit, we haven't done anything that hasn't been done countless times before. This information does nothing but embarrass us. That is Julians real goal. He talks about freedom of information and being accountable, but in reality he just wants to see the shit hit the fan.
I 100% support transparency and accountability, but this is not what Wikileaks is doing.
Also, if anyone read the most recent businessweek, it talks about potential hacking by wikileaks to get their information. Apparently they posted blue prints of a missile defense the USA has. That is really relevant information. Julian is about making all of us unsafe, not more free.
Velit quod aut alias repellat. Nisi nam rerum maiores distinctio esse similique laboriosam. Necessitatibus accusantium omnis ut soluta corporis velit aperiam. Nihil omnis impedit molestiae qui veritatis dolorem.
Et error voluptas atque itaque corporis ut. Non corrupti et animi pariatur labore illo et. Rerum ut cumque aspernatur nisi porro. Ab pariatur cumque voluptatibus molestiae molestias non.
See All Comments - 100% Free
WSO depends on everyone being able to pitch in when they know something. Unlock with your email and get bonus: 6 financial modeling lessons free ($199 value)
Sorry, you need to login or sign up in order to vote. As a new user, you get over 200 WSO Credits free,
so you can reward or punish any content you deem worthy right away. See you on the other side!
That is ridiculous
How would that be treason? Obama is not British and it is not his job as an American president to protect British interests. I am not a fan of his by a long stretch and this transaction is shady as hell, but telling someone else's secrets in order to get an agreement beneficial for the US of A, is definitely a lot better than not getting the agreement or getting it in exchange for something that's valuable to us.
The UK has been the US's most loyal ally since the end of WW2. I consider this a great injustice.
That is disgusting. After everything the UK has done this is how that moron Obama repays them. I genuinely find this sickening.
It's not treason, but it certainly is betrayal. They've been our closest ally for ages. Pretty messed up in my opinion.
This is certainly a hit on US' image abroad. If we're betraying our closest ally, how can other countries trust us?
On the other hand-what if this leak gives us a reason to stop providing that info to Russia? This could certainly feed the conspiracy theories that the US/UK are running Wikileaks.
rest easy, guys. the other countries are doing the same and people have been doing this(selling others' secrets for private gain) for eons.
Thanks Julian. This "uncovers" criminal misdeeds by our government and was something the average citizen needed to know. We will all be better off now that the UK, one of our closest allies, know we F'ed them over. Really doing a wonderful job uncovering shit.
Could someone assassinate this cock sucker?
Knowing how back-stabbing and two faced your government is, is nice to know. Thanks Julian.
So you would accept that this knowledge being released publicly might diminish our close ties to the UK, because you would rather know the truth? Sacrificing national security just so that the public knows a little more about government dealings is not a satisfactory trade-off.
Couldn't agree with you more Ant. Only a matter of time before this guy and his followers are all quietly assassinated, and good riddance.
A lot of cognitive dissonance in this thread that the bowing, kowtowing Obama was playing Realpolitik with the Ruskies and the British. New START was important to US interests and if an inconsequential secret about the UK's Trident force was a bargaining chip, so be it.
Besides, all the release of this "secret" did was verify information that is already available on Wikipedia:
@Bulge -- Did you really think global politics was a game of truth and transparency? The USA is playing a global game here. I think it is BS that we backstabbed the UK, but who knows the benefit that giving Russia this info might have done. Maybe it helped gain information on Iranian plans. Maybe it was a good faith measure to bring them to the table to disarm. Whatever, it was realpolitik. I don't sleep safer at night with this stuff uncovered.
Julian is an anarchist. He doesn't care about right and wrong, legality, etc. He simply wants to cause mayhem. This information does not show the USA committing any crime, violating civil rights, operating a hidden death camp. All it shows is the USA making back door deals. Wow. Thanks Julian. Really protecting my rights and freedoms with this info.
Our government is not perfect. It does shady shit. Everyone does this. Zero benefit in releasing this information.
The sooner Julian is in a box somewhere the better. This guy is a terrorist if I ever saw one.
Agreed. Except the last point. I'm sure UK knew about the leaking.
It is global politics. Who knows what Russia put on the table. All I am saying is Julian is not releasing this information to the public to provide any benefit other than creating anarchy.
What is so funny is if Julian actually cared about democracy or freedom or whatever, he would be releasing Chinese, Russian, Iranian, African, etc documents. Let's shine a light on countries clearly violating human rights. But no, let's just release back door negotiations that are necessary and prudent in a complicated global environment.
I also think it is bullshit we back stabbed an ally like this, but if the info we gave Russia led to a decrease in nuclear weapons or a move towards stopping Iranian nuclear progression than I think the betrayal might be worth it.
@leverdarb - please tell me why this needs to be dug up? This is essentially none of our business. The average citizen is not having his rights violated. They are not being hurt by this behavior. The government is making deals on a global level. I didn't realize you had the right to know troop movements in Afghanistan or what the ambassador to Switzerland ate for lunch.
People love Julian for the same reason they love juicy gossip. Doesn't make what this guy is doing any better. People can revile in knowing that the USA told Russia some secretes. The USA now has to live with a less than friendly UK neighbor.
Also, on a practical side, is this even a worthwhile secret? The UK has nukes, but a small amount of them. They are no a significant nuclear power. Russia, USA, and China are serious nuclear powers. No news here, just gossip.
One in the head, two in the chest.
if you think what the ambassador had for lunch is on the same level as betraying one of your longest allies then we can end this discussion now since you are clinically insane?
I agree with you that assange should be jailed and wikileaks should be banned since publishing of the diplomatic cables and alot of other stuff is indeed unneccessary and none of the publics business.
In this case however we are not talking about releasing some minor wrong doing, this is a MAJOR wrongdoing on the US part and as such is worth exposing.
Oops, double
penetrationpost!Ok, I may sound like a douche for saying this, and I already mentioned that this is some underhanded shady shit BUT. While UK was a loyal ally, it hasn't exactly been the most useful. I mean Georgia is a loyal ally too, and why the f wouldn't they be with all the benefits they got without having to provide anything but loyalty in return? But unfortunately now is the time when we need a friend, not a trusty loyal pet fish or a dog equivalent. In that aspect Russia could be a lot more useful and thus more of an equal and a true friend than the UK.
Please inform me of what crime the USA broke in passing these secrets. I am not defending this behavior, but other than catching the USA pulling some bullshit, we haven't done anything that hasn't been done countless times before. This information does nothing but embarrass us. That is Julians real goal. He talks about freedom of information and being accountable, but in reality he just wants to see the shit hit the fan.
I 100% support transparency and accountability, but this is not what Wikileaks is doing.
Also, if anyone read the most recent businessweek, it talks about potential hacking by wikileaks to get their information. Apparently they posted blue prints of a missile defense the USA has. That is really relevant information. Julian is about making all of us unsafe, not more free.
.
Velit quod aut alias repellat. Nisi nam rerum maiores distinctio esse similique laboriosam. Necessitatibus accusantium omnis ut soluta corporis velit aperiam. Nihil omnis impedit molestiae qui veritatis dolorem.
Et error voluptas atque itaque corporis ut. Non corrupti et animi pariatur labore illo et. Rerum ut cumque aspernatur nisi porro. Ab pariatur cumque voluptatibus molestiae molestias non.
See All Comments - 100% Free
WSO depends on everyone being able to pitch in when they know something. Unlock with your email and get bonus: 6 financial modeling lessons free ($199 value)
or Unlock with your social account...