How to spin a bad 1st year review for on-cycle?
Save the think pieces, but for what it is worth I got a mid-bucket / low-bucket end of year review at a BB. I won't say it was intentional, but the culture of my group is unreasonably intense in my opinion so I just was not willing to trade my health or mental sanity to keep up face with the other few try hards in my class. However, nothing about my performance review was critically bad (I.e no PIP or dangerous red zone anywhere) and I've decided that I'm willing to recruit for 2025 exit opportunities even if it means toughing another year here.
I know at this point the true "star analysts" out there will get on their mighty high horse about how this is a reflection of my ability to perform on the buyside yadda yadda, but I do not care for opinions. I am a pretty charming interviewer and have the buyside prep down (modeling is nowhere near an issue as I spent my time sharpening that toolkit more than giving 110% at work - and that is a decision I am comfortable living with).
The question is HOW do I spin the low reviews for interviews? I will worry about references as they come, but being one year in the reviews seem like a new gating item to even begin the process. I don't want to share details, but the poor reviews were never about technical ability or quality, but more about communication, proactive-ness attention to detail etc.
Why would you even have to talk about the review? Maybe I’m missing something but unless your next gig asks several questions about it don’t say anything.
You’ll realize that most of your former bosses will usually give decent reviews too. If you end up leaving and use them as a reference, highly doubt your MD will light you up
This doesn't feel like something to worry about.
I can't imagine they will see the actual review. Feels like the references will sort this one out.
If what you're saying is true, it will be easy enough to find a few associates who agree with your approach/mentality and will support you if you do a good job for them.
It's great that you can pass a modeling test but this is really a check the box exercise. You can certainly lose your offer if you don't perform on it, but no one is hiring someone just because they do great at a modeling test.
Call me dishonest, but I don’t think you need to be 100% truthful with your interviewer regarding your reviews. If they ask how your reviews have gone (which is rare to begin with), can always say something like “they were very positive, people were complimentary about x, y, z. Some goals for me this year are to continue to take the lead on calls, blah blah (the humble brag type things to work on”
Agree with the others, not sure why your review would be relevant since they can't actually see it. Just say it went well and spin the positive / negative feedback you were given.
To the above - I generally agree with the idea of don't ask don't tell, but for specific processes, I've had HH explicitly ask me about my mid-year / end of year review feedback, so in a case where I need to discuss (or put it in writing) I rather have a strategy that won't completely backfire.
Would suggest focusing your efforts on the 95% of processes that don't...
If they put enough effort in to verify your actual ranking / review, clearly it's an important metric for them and no one is going to believe whatever b/s you come up with as to why you chose to perform poorly.
Exactly the above - say the review was positive and cherry pick a few "stretch" opportunities for you to "work on". It's not like they will see a copy of the review.
Unless you are literally the worst analyst ever, your references will not throw you under the bus.
Vitae consequatur ut laboriosam eos fuga eum. Eveniet commodi exercitationem est iure impedit labore blanditiis odit. Laudantium laborum praesentium excepturi sed consequatur quidem non.
Sunt itaque tempora quas dolores non facilis nam. Velit quia dicta rem vitae. Rerum aliquam a natus voluptas. Odit dolores iure tempore voluptatum possimus ipsa incidunt.
Perferendis repudiandae fugiat fugit dolor perferendis. Nostrum provident nihil quaerat amet praesentium.
See All Comments - 100% Free
WSO depends on everyone being able to pitch in when they know something. Unlock with your email and get bonus: 6 financial modeling lessons free ($199 value)
or Unlock with your social account...