Untrended YoC - Construction Escalation Included?
Curious to hear how other people underwrite this with untrended Yield on Cost. Do you use escalated construction number as the denominator for your untrended yield on cost calculation? Or do you take out any construction cost escalation?
Based on the most helpful WSO content, untrended Yield on Cost (YoC) typically incorporates the escalated construction costs as the denominator. This approach ensures that the calculation reflects the most realistic and current cost basis, accounting for the rising construction expenses that are prevalent in many markets. Ignoring construction cost escalation could lead to an overly optimistic YoC, which might not align with actual project economics.
However, practices can vary depending on the firm or market. Some professionals might exclude escalations for specific internal benchmarks or conservative underwriting purposes, but the general consensus leans toward including escalated costs for a more accurate representation of untrended YoC.
Sources: Looming Liquidity Crisis?, Yield on Development Costs, My Private Equity Recruiting Process, Real Estate Trends (All Asset Types)
Every firm I've been at has included the escalated construction costs in UYOC.
I can understand the argument to not inlcude because you're assuming stabilized NOI without any escalators, but then you're just using a wrong construction total cost at that point. Construction costs are going to inflate almost no matter what, but rents could maybe stay flat.
Why trend the construction costs but not the operating income/expenses? Understand and agree costs will likely rise, but that assumption is still a forecast, just like trending rents and expenses is a forecast. So why trend one but not the other?
I’m not a developer but the purpose is to understand the spread in YOC to market cap rates of a stabilized deal today. Because of this you want to underwrite today’s market rents (untrended) against the cost to build. You don’t want to account for rent growth because that’s not an apples to apples comparison and it’s a speculation. If you have a big enough spread in your untrended YoC to market cap rates with today’s rents then it might make sense to build. If you’re comparing a YoC with trended rents against today’s market cap rates, your spread is going to be dependent on the market rent growth you’re comfortable assuming which one developer might have totally different from another and is more of a bet. Someone tell me if there’s more to it than that - again that’s just my common sense way of thinking about it
it’s one view of it but industry standard is NOI as if existed today / escalated cost i.e. fully baked construction cost you anticipate will be in the jv docs and you stand behind when we start construction X months/years in the future. Mack cali would make investment decisions untrended NOI / no escalation budget. Mill creek will inflate NOI to construction start to put on equal footing. If you’re a developer and want any shot of your deal getting done today, need to bank on 0 escalation.
Do you include free rent for retail industrial or office in the denominator?
Firm i'm at includes all stabilization costs, so TIs, LCs, carry costs (more free rent = more loan interest not covered by property cashflow), etc. in the denominator on industrial deals. So indirectly yes.
What do you mean escalation? Do you not have a GMP? And soft costs and financing costs should be pretty priced in at closing.
Harum earum molestiae aliquam est deserunt aut dolor. Voluptas autem quia autem maiores. Aut sed ipsum non sunt ducimus. Quia rem id in quasi. Atque et consequuntur qui sequi architecto perspiciatis. Placeat quo quia ab.
See All Comments - 100% Free
WSO depends on everyone being able to pitch in when they know something. Unlock with your email and get bonus: 6 financial modeling lessons free ($199 value)
or Unlock with your social account...