Hey guys. Would you say that all of these schools listed below are the same tier for NYC IB and MBB recruiting

Based on the most helpful WSO content, these schools are often grouped in a similar tier for NYC IB and MBB recruiting, but there are nuances to consider. Here's a breakdown:

1. Brown, Northwestern, Cornell, NYU (Stern), UMich (Ross), and Georgetown (McDonough) are generally considered strong semi-targets or lower-tier targets. They all have solid representation at top firms, but the level of effort required to secure top roles can vary.

2. Differences in Placement:

   • NYU (Stern) and UMich (Ross) tend to have higher absolute placement numbers due to their larger class sizes and strong alumni networks. However, this doesn't necessarily mean it's easier to land a role; competition within these schools can be intense.
   • Brown and Cornell are often noted for their strong per capita placement, meaning a higher percentage of students aiming for IB/MBB succeed, but they may not have as many firms recruiting on campus compared to Stern or Ross.
   • Georgetown (McDonough) and Northwestern are also well-regarded, with Georgetown having a strong presence in consulting and Northwestern benefiting from its overall prestige and alumni network.

3. Ranking (if distinctions are made):

   • Top of the group: NYU (Stern), UMich (Ross), Cornell
   • Middle: Georgetown (McDonough), Northwestern
   • Slightly lower: Brown (due to fewer firms recruiting universally, though it performs well at specific banks like MS and GS)

4. Resume and People Skills: At this level, your personal achievements, networking, and interview performance often matter more than the school name. While there are subtle differences in recruiting opportunities, excelling at any of these schools can lead to success in NYC IB or MBB.

In summary, while these schools are in a similar tier, slight differences exist in terms of ease of placement and firm representation. However, your individual efforts will play a significant role in determining your outcomes.

Sources: Comprehensive Undergraduate Target Schools Tier List 2020, 2019 Target School Ranking for NYC Recruit?, Undergraduate Target Schools Tier List (2021 Updates), 2019 Target School Ranking for NYC Recruit?, Comprehensive Undergraduate Target Schools Tier List 2020