Hello all, I am just about to start out in the commodity division of a cooperative mostly on the feed side doing purchasing. Wanted to know if even though the group I will be working with has a relatively small footprint, is this still good training to go and become a trader at a trading shop or a larger producer/processor that has a trading team? It seems functionally it is not that different from other procurement roles which from my understanding is training for risk taking roles.

I would definetly agree with thoroughbell except on their point that the shop will not have a great training program compared to an ABCD. While the certainly won't have the same buying power, which is an important thing to consider in this business, there are still great opportunities to learn the business in a more close knight environment.

Hopefully someone who knows what the hell they are talking about can answer, but my take is that they have enough volume required or associated to risk to have someone dedicated to the work. If you are handling logistics and have a certain degree of discretion as when to buy, then there doesn't seem to be anything separating you from another procurement guy. Just be aware that to trade you will eventually have to move and you won't necessarily have great training as opposed to an ABCD that have structured merchandising/trainee programs with trader roles that open up at reasonable frequency.

Given that is where you are starting if I had to design a likely path to trading at a large shop one day then it would be something like procurement at coop -> ddgs/midds/soy hull merchant at a processor -> corn/wheat/beans trader at that same processor -> corn/wheat/bean trader at a trade shop. It won't be easy though and will require you to do something different than everyone else starting out a couple steps above you. Are you different/better than the average guy starting in your position or the people already starting at a processor?What skill set do you have that others don't?

Ag procurement development

MC_HAMMER

Mentor

Most Helpful

As a purchaser, you're just 1/2 of a trader, you're just always short the market. in feedstuffs you have to analyze a variety of different markets and cant be fixated on just the commodity you are trading due to the existence of outside markets. i.e. if I am trading DDG's I need to be aware of the other mid-pro's. What are run times at flour mills so I know what wheat midds are going for? How has corn sweetener demand been for corn gluten feed? Are we crushing at capacity for soybean hulls? Its all about how you are able to sell your experience and have a market focused outlook on your position and how you look to generate value.

Quote

Report

Other

Authored by: Certified Sales & Trading Professional - TraderCertified Sales & Trading Pro

+12	Lateraling from Trading to IB vs. IB to Trading	TR	4	1d
+11	Loser on the trading floor - help please!	TR	3	2d
+10	Delta One Trading	TR	4	11s
+9	SA class size in BB FO (IB, S&T, AM PB)	TR	3	19h
+9	AVP / AD Fixed Income Trader Salary	TR	1	2d
+4	Understanding the Yield Curve	TR	2	5d
+3	What NOT To DO in S&T and Banking	TR	3	4d
+1	Difference in ops between Glencore and Trafigura. Commodities, path to trader, enjoyment of ops.	TR	3	2d
0	Trading house to HF	TR	2	1h

1	redever	99.2
2	Secyh62	99.0
3	BankonBanking	99.0
4	Betsy Massar	99.0
5	dosk17	98.9
6	kanon	98.9
7	GameTheory	98.9
8	CompBanker	98.9
9	bolo up	98.8
10	numi	98.8

Ag procurement development

Trending Content