Is this a good ranking of trading desks?

See http://www.wallstreetoasis.com/forums/a-response-to-which-desk-is-best-…

Also that's just credit and those rankings probably vary considerably year to year, much like league tables.

ambition56http://www.totalsecuritization.com/569/75659/TS053110s.pdf

what do you guys think? is this a good ranking of the trading groups at top BBs? Or does it only cover a few desks

I'll be honest, if you read the first sentence or even looked at the host name on the link you'd know the answer to that question.

The best desk is one which maximizes your profit potential. This depends on:

1. The product (more importantly your ability within a product)
2. The client base of the firm (amt of flow)
3. The presence of a mentor
4. Your risk limits (responsibility) which is directly related to 1

Notice how only one is relevant on which bank you are at, rankings are largely irrelevant.