May 22, 2018
Do you really need to tip that much when you order a single expensive bottle of champagne?

When you go to a club and order a $2000 bottle of champagne. If you tip the average rate, say 15%. Then, the person who did nothing except bring the bottle from their fridge to your table made $300 in less than a minute. Do you feel that the waiter/waitress deserve that much tip from that little effort?
Consulting Case Interview Course
- 2,037 questions across 209 consulting firms. Crowdsourced from over 600,000 members.
- 11 Detailed Exclusive Cases developed by a McKinsey Associate and 10+ hours of video.
- Trusted by over 1,000 aspiring consultants just like you.
Wall Street Oasis Notifications
Please tell us a little bit more about yourself to send you the most relevant notifications
Get Notified?
Popular Content See all
- Investment Banking is BrokenI just left IB and went entrepreneurship way, so this is a bit of a rant post and a throwaway account, but felt like I need to share. With all do respect to hard-working individuals out there - investment banking industry is broken and absolutely worthless. The advisory side is the most...
- An Honest reflection from my first Summer Analyst role: The Good, The Bad, The Ugly (mainly bad and ugly)I come from a target West Coast school. I say target because being on the West Coast, there are only three name-brand schools you can land a job on at an i-bank on the West Coast. Those name brands from my POV are Stanford, Berkeley, and USC. I go to one of the first two. Hats off to the Moelis...
- AMA: Non-Target -> 3rd Year Analyst MM IBUnfortunately turning comments on a pitch deck today so I have some time in between turns to do an AMA. Thought I'd give back to the community here now that I'm wrapping up my 3rd year at a MM. Definitely wouldn't be here today if it wasn't for WSO. ###Quick background...
- Nuances of Corporate Finance in each IndustryI want to start a thread talking about the nuances of corporate finance within each industry (Oil & Gas, Healthcare/Pharma, Aerospace & Defense, Manufacturing, Consumer Packaged Goods, etc). The impression I've gotten is that you can bounce around between industries in the first...
- How I messed up my career and then got it back on trackA little mini rant/story about how I messed up my career but have finally (I hope at least) gotten it back on track. I started off on a Big Four graduate scheme. Initially in audit but then moved over to the transactions side. Great learning experience, worked on big clients, but not exactly...
- The WSO Job Board is Now FREE The WSO Job board is now free for anyone that wants to apply...all anyone has to do is upload a resume and they will be allowed to submit their application. Create Your Oasis Job Profile Here's a peak inside:
- Join the Email & WhatsApp groups for your city Join the email list for your city to receive updates on future WSO events in your city. When signing up you will also receive a welcome email with a link to join your city's WhatsApp group. We created these WhatsApp groups with the goal of making it easier for WSO members to organize events...
- Top Chicago IB Background: Notre Dame sophomore looking into Investment Banking internships/jobs in Chicago. Was wondering if there was a list or if people had suggestions of top IB firms and groups to start networking with.
- Why do most people suck at Excel?Microsoft Excel: the lifeblood of 21st century finance and business. A phenomenal spreadsheet tool used by the lowest level analysts through the most executive tier of management. A wonderful program capable of performing complex mathematics, charting graphs and calculating thousands of data...
- Does school pedigree matter after getting the job?I read that firms are considering hiring more and more consultants from different backgrounds and non-target schools. However, does being from a non-target background affect your opportunities to advance after getting hired? I'm asking because I notice that most of the highlighted employees...
Leaderboard See all
1 | ![]() | 97.4 |
2 | ![]() | 97.2 |
3 | ![]() | 97.1 |
4 | ![]() | 96.9 |
5 | ![]() | 96.9 |
6 | ![]() | 96.8 |
7 | ![]() | 96.4 |
8 | ![]() | 96.4 |
9 | ![]() | 96.4 |
10 | ![]() | 96.4 |
Upcoming EventsSee all
- Feb20
- Feb20
- Feb21
- Feb21
- Feb21
Comments (12)
Yeah, it sucks but pretty standard to tip $300-400 on that.
https://www.townandcountrymag.com/leisure/drinks/a...
"If you always put limits on everything you do, physical or anything else, it will spread into your work and into your life. There are no limits. There are only plateaus, and you must not stay there, you must go beyond them." - Bruce Lee
To be polite, yes, but it's pretty dumb that they expect a tip that large.
It's actually pretty smart to get a job where dumbass finance bros will give you $300 for bringing them a bottle of alcohol to impress some strangers
heister:
Look at all these wannabe richies hating on an expensive salad.
Don't they usually include a 10-12.5% service charge? That usually eliminates the need for OOP tips.
If you're that stretched to just afford the bottle and not the tip, then don't get the bottle. Said another way: if you cannot afford the tip, then you cannot afford the bottle.
Side-by-side comparison of top modeling training courses + exclusive discount through WSO here.
Tipping is completely out of hand these days and $300 is outrageous. Don't ever feel pressured in to giving someone else your money because "it's the polite thing to do."
It is. I've lived half my life overseas where there is no tipping culture. Always feels good to pay only what you see on the bill and not feel bad about it.
I take a two way approach to this, if I'm at a restaurant and order a bottle of wine ill tip 20% on that. Usually if I'm ponying up for a whole bottle/bottles there usually is a sommelier opening it, allowing me to taste, it telling me a story of why this wine (x) pairs with food (y).
But at the club some girl bringing me a bottle of mid grade liquor with a sparkler... I usually tip what the bottle is worth in the store.
The $300 tip is outrageous but the $2000 bottle of shitty champagne you can get at costco for, what $149, isn't?
Agree with the general comments that if you can't afford the tip, you can't afford the bottle. That being said, I would consider a 15-25% tip to be the scale for food service (it would have to be atrocious to warrant a lesser tip), but maybe a lower range for the wine. If I order a bottle and my server just opens it, then maybe I'm only tipping 5-10%. If I'm being given a lesson in what wines pair with my specific meal and an opportunity to make an educated choice and taste the wine, then I'll taste more. It's the same concept - you tip for service, though the range might be lower.
If I was at a club and ordered one bottle, I'd tip 10-20%. If I ordered 3, that percentage number might slide downwards a bit.
Honestly the tipping in the US is plain bat sh1t crazy! Completely out of control.
I think of it this way,let's say you order a bottle of Prosecco for $60 instead of your $2,000 bottle of champagne (on which you are already paying a massive mark-up on) why would you pay significantly more in tip for the $2k bottle?
The same service is provided in both cases.
I like the idea of giving somebody something extra when they go the extra mile and provide really good service but it leaves a completely sour taste in my mouth when a tip is expected regardless of service quality.
See All Comments - 100% Free
WSO depends on everyone being able to pitch in when they know something. Unlock with your email and get bonus: 6 financial modeling lessons free ($199 value)
Want to sign in with your social account?
Want to Vote on this Content?! No WSO Credits?
Join Us
Already a member? Login
Popular Content on WSO
Related Content on WSO