Does not attending Kellogg MBA hinder your chances of landing MBB?

jnhadekjs's picture
Rank: Orangutan | banana points 362

I finally gave up on dreams of attending Wharton. Almsot everyone from my country at Wharton either went to IIT or IIM. So I'm currently shortlisting schools to apply to this year. I will apply to 4 max because I work like 12 hours and it's hard to apply to more than that.

My post-MBA career goals: Buy-side research, but I'm also open to consulting (preferably MBB) and BB/EB IB.

The schools I've shortlisted are:
1- Columbia
2- Booth
3- Kellogg
4- Fuqua

However, I've been thinking about switching Kellogg with Dartmouth Tuck. Why? Because they have a very small class size, very loyal alumni according to what I've heard, they do pretty well placing in buy-side/PE, it's a match school so I'll have 2 matches instead of 1, they do well in IB and consulting as well.

But will attending Tuck instead of Kellogg hinder my chances of landing MBB in case if I couldn't get buy-side research? I know landing EB/BB IB is relatively easy so I'm not worried about that.

It would be really great if anyone here could provide some insight.

@BreakingOutOfPWM I couldn't PM you because I don't have enough points but would love to know what you think.

Comments (5)

Mar 29, 2018

If you can't get MBB from Tuck, you won't get it from Kellogg. So nope, it doesn't "hinder" your chances.

Best Response
Mar 29, 2018

I'm not the best resource on Tuck. But a few things to consider:

  1. It's really difficult to recruit for both buy-side and consulting if your goal is buy-side. Consulting recruiting happens much earlier than a lot of buy side recruiting. Some people score earlier offers for buy side, but most of them come later.

Also, if you're recruiting for buy-side investment management, your fall is taken up by stock pitch competitions (all organized through the school); this is a huge time sink but very necessary for the process. Consulting networking happens at the same time. So it's really hard to do both at once (read: impossible to do both properly at once). Reneging on a b-school OCR offer is a big, big deal, so you kind of have to pick. As an aside, people don't really recruit for investment management and PE; they're very different, figure out where you want to focus before going to school. If you're recruiting for PE, you'd best have a relevant background and ideally some connections coming in; it's not an industry traditionally lateraled to from b-school.

You can recruiting again in year two of course, but you'll be much better served by deciding which you want to recruit for before recruiting begins (a lot of offers get locked up in internships for consulting, and a buy-side internship helps a lot with buy-side full time recruiting). That doesn't mean now, it means after orientation at school, so don't sweat too much yet.

  1. Tuck places really well for consulting. I don't know the dynamics of the school's OCR though. One thing that typically separates the M7 from the rest, though, is that literally every major U.S. office will be represented through OCR, on campus, for you to network with and meet. Outside of the M7 it's usually only a few offices that show up in person and it's kind of on you to drive relationships with other offices. I don't know if that's the case with Tuck. I'd assume at least Boston and NYC will be on campus though. Kellogg might have more national cachet (i.e. west coast, midwest) than Tuck in that regard, while also being equally easy to recruit for east coast offices from. Tuck might be an exception to that dynamic though.
  2. Both schools are known for their cult-like hugs and rainbows culture. I wouldn't consider the tightness of the community a real differentiating factor. Yeah, Kellogg is bigger, but Kellogg students tend to frolic hand in hand, 700 students strong, to pretty much everything. The real differentiator is going to be Evanston vs Hanover. If you're a woodsy, outdoorsy person and enjoy hiking, skiing, bouldering, the warm rain on your face while you lie in a mossy glade with 5 best friends wearing the same green sweatshirt, etc Tuck is probably the way to go. Northwestern's a huge school with a fun sports culture and a lot to offer as well, and is accessible to Chicago for a night out (45 minutes away - Tuck is not accessible to ANYWHERE for a night out).
    • 5
Mar 31, 2018

Thank you.

I have worked in Private Equity as I mentioned in my other post. So I was hoping if buy-side research didn't work out, I'd just go the PE route. Consulting and IB are just secondary/back-up to be honest if in case it doesn't work.

Mar 31, 2018

I wish I wasn't out of credits so I can throw you an SB. You just sold me on Tuck haha (specifically, the mossy glade part)

Apr 4, 2018
Comment