Ferragamo Loafer Recs

Stay away from penny loafers.

These are the only loafers I recommend:

http://www.allenedmonds.com/aeonline/producti_SF40002_1_40000000001_-1_

I have the 'Magnifico's' and they're great, comfortable and not too flashy. That being said, mine are brown and for black I do like the ones with the black buckle.

Gucci horsebit loafers look better, imo. Check those out

I would say the first one looks the best for a business environment. I have almost the same exact pair of loafers and have gotten numerous compliments. Take a look at the AE Firenze italian loafer. It's, AE, made in italy, and overall pretty great quality. I would say it is a little less narrow, but AE's are usually more round, but it works for me as I have flat feet.

I do no like the edging on shoes, so I would choose the first variant

Stay away from horse bit loafers, they're tacky and way too casual for a business environment. Besides, ferragamo isn't exactly known for their construction and leather quality.

Get some Carmina navy or black shell cordovan loafers: http://cdn.shopify.com/s/files/1/0211/7958/products/5748a_1024x1024.jpg…

If you have time go for Bespoke shoes...Edward Green, George Cleverley, W.S. Foster & Sons and so on, else the first variant looks sound for a business purpose not to flashy apt with slacks and suits both.

Of your 3 Gamo suggestions, I really like the middle pair. To me, they would look way better than the others with jeans at the bar and would still be a nice look in the office.

I have the middle ones and so far they're pretty good -- the calfskin is very soft and comfortable. They're a little skinny so I got the 2E width which is perfect for my wider than usual right foot. Aesthetically speaking I'd say the penny loafers looks sleeker and more formal.