Top MBA vs Structuring Associate
I'm an older employee with a family, but as the title states, I've been accepted to INSEAD's 1Y MBA program in France. Shortly after being accepted to INSEAD, my employer (BB in NYC) offered me a structuring associate role in Houston on the commodities desk.
I'm currently a back-office nobody, so both the MBA and structuring roles are very inciting. I'm worried that INSEAD won't guarantee me a job as good as the structuring role that I'm currently being offered. However, there are individuals coming out of INSEAD going into IB, which would also be nice... it's really which way the wind blows, but in the current economic environment, I feel like the structuring gig is a good one.
Thoughts? Should I go do the MBA? Is structuring that lucrative? Keep in mind that the MBA would cost $100k+ in actual cost, not to mention $100k+ in opportunity cost.
How old are you? I ask because you could always take the role for a year or two then get your mba if you want to pivot.
I'm 31. Shouldn't I be worried about the 1Y program?
Sounds to me like you have no clue what you really want to be doing, you’re talking about IB and commodity sales-both are very diff. Try and figure out what you want to do longer term, consider as well that insead is long optionality and that commodity sales in houston is a potential pidgeonhole and is very niche. The costs of an mba shouldnt matter that much if youre looking to get an FO job and trying to do a career change. Again, you need to figure what you want to do, and that takes into account alot of things (you sure you can be a junior banker with a family? Gotta think about that).
Honestly, at 31, who knows what they want to be doing for the next 34 years? I know I want to get out of back office and have a more client facing, higher earning role. IB sounds great, but I also have a wife and kids, so the hours don't exactly excite me. Structuring is considered front office, and I would have interaction with clients. I've also been told that structuring to trading is one of the most natural progressions, so there's a good chance I could be trading, if I play my cards right. Lastly, is structuring really that niche? At the end of the day, it's heavy quant and sales.... both these seem to transfer well in the real world. Salary seems like it can touch $300k+ at the VP level (so within 3 years).
So if you take the MBA, would you bring your whole family to France? If you are moving to Houston for a front office role, I would take it. I'm assuming you are working at Citi because of their presence in Houston (in trading/structuring capacity) compared to other BBs. Your cost of living would be way lower and you would be potentially making more. If you don't want to go into IB, what fields would you want to go into? If you want to specifically get a certain job, I can see why you would want the MBA to pivot, but it seems like you don't really have a reason other than getting a "front office" job.
Repudiandae repellendus eveniet quis tempora qui quis necessitatibus. Reprehenderit labore eum omnis adipisci ut velit et nostrum. Fuga quibusdam dignissimos nemo non a atque.
Aperiam at minima vel et ea eos quia. Perspiciatis consequatur cum possimus fuga sit ducimus. Nemo officiis molestiae porro tenetur deleniti fuga quis. Ut est id perspiciatis animi laboriosam sed.
Necessitatibus animi totam nemo. Repellat soluta sed eaque neque iure voluptas rerum. Quia sint harum alias nisi eum velit iure quia.
Sed est aut delectus. Repudiandae vero adipisci temporibus et voluptate culpa quia natus. Et illo aliquid voluptatem repudiandae ut repellendus ex. Est incidunt maiores maxime quisquam nihil earum culpa. Voluptas optio laboriosam hic dicta.
See All Comments - 100% Free
WSO depends on everyone being able to pitch in when they know something. Unlock with your email and get bonus: 6 financial modeling lessons free ($199 value)
or Unlock with your social account...
Veritatis natus vel placeat omnis. Officia ex ut ab sit consequatur voluptatem. Facere vel voluptate facere atque consequuntur inventore. Quae vel rem ratione nulla ratione voluptate dolore.
Nisi aut et dolorum doloribus exercitationem iure fugiat aut. Voluptatem fugiat corporis voluptates impedit quos dolorem. Neque nemo provident et est alias.
Aut et maxime earum aspernatur ea consequuntur culpa. Exercitationem ut molestias consectetur sit. Enim labore laborum vel voluptatum ut aspernatur.