Convertible Note
A type of debt security that can be converted into equity at a later time
What is a Convertible Note?
Convertible notes are a type of debt security that can be converted into equity at a later time. They are popular financial instruments startups and early-stage companies use to raise capital without diluting the ownership of existing shareholders.
This note's basic configuration involves issuing a promissory note that contains a transformation feature. As a result, the note typically has a maturity date and an interest rate lower than the rate delegated by conventional lenders.
The conversion feature allows the holder of the note to convert it into equity at a later time, usually at a discount to the current valuation of the company.
Startups frequently use them since they offer a means of raising money without ascertaining the company's worth. However, valuing a business may be tough, especially in the early phases of low income.
By issuing these notes, startups can postpone the valuation query until a later time when the company is more established and more data is unrestricted to determine its value.
Understanding Convertible Note
A convertible note is a debt instrument that can convert into equity, usually in a startup, at a future specified event, typically a funding round.
One of the primary advantages of these notes is the chance of a more substantial return on investment. If the firm increases in value, the investor can transform their debt into equity at a bargain to the previous valuation, thus increasing the number of shares they control.
This can result in a higher return than if the investor had simply bought equity at the current valuation.
Another advantage of these notes is that they are relatively simple to structure and execute. Unlike equity financing, which requires a formal valuation of the business and negotiation of terms, these notes can be issued quickly and with the tiniest legal fees.
One of the most significant risks to investors is that the firm may fail before the notes are transformed into stock.
In this instance, the investor might lose their whole investment because they are not entitled to debt recovery if the firm fails. A conflict of interest between investors and the board of directors may also result from the conversion feature's design, which overly dilutes current shareholders.
In recent years, there has been some objection to the widespread use of these notes in the startup environment.
Some contend that they can be a way for companies to bypass setting a valuation and diluting existing shareholders at the expense of investors who may not fully comprehend the risks involved.
Others argue that the simplicity of these notes can lead to careless structuring and misunderstandings between investors and management. Despite these points, such notes continue to be a prevalent instrument for startups and early-stage businesses seeking to raise cash.
They propose an easy-going and fairly simple way to raise funds without cutting existing ownership and can provide investors with the prospect of a high return on investment.
Before investing in these notes, investors should carefully assess the risks involved, and corporations should be upfront about the notes' conditions.
Convertible Note Valuation Parameters
When contemplating investing in a convertible note, investors should examine many critical characteristics to assess the possible return and amount of risk. Here are some crucial criteria to consider:
1. Conversion Price
The conversion rate is the cost of converting the note into equity. The lower the conversion price, the greater the investor's potential return if the company's valuation rises.
A lower conversion price, on the other hand, implies that the investor is taking on more risk because the conversion price indicates a greater valuation for the firm.
The discount rate is the percentage discount applied to the company's current valuation when the note is converted into equity. For example, if the current value is $10 million & the rate at which it is discounted is 20%, the investor's note would be converted into equity at an $8 million valuation.
Note
A higher discount rate implies a bigger potential return for the investor and a higher risk because the firm must expand by a greater proportion to make the investment worthwhile.
3. Interest Rate
The interest rate on the note shows the investor's return if the note has not been transformed into equity. This rate is usually lower than the rate charged by traditional lenders since these notes are a higher-risk investment.
Investors should examine the interest rate in conjunction with the conversion price and discount rate to evaluate the total possible return on investment.
4. Maturity Date
The note must be repaid on the maturity date if it does not turn into equity. This date is often set many years in the future to allow the firm time to flourish and boost its worth. The investor may lose their entire investment if the corporation cannot repay the note when it matures.
5. Valuation Cap
A valuation cap restricts the firm's value at the time of conversion. For example, suppose the value cap is set at 20 million, and the business's market value at conversion is 30 million. In that case, the investor will convert their note into equity at a 20 million valuation.
Note
A valuation cap can protect an investor's ownership stake from being diluted excessively, but it can also limit the investor's earnings potential if the company's valuation exceeds the cap.
6. Liquidity Event
The liquidity event is the event that triggers the conversion of the note into equity. This event is typically an equity financing round or an acquisition of the company.
To calculate the probable return on investment, investors should evaluate the odds of a liquidity event occurring and the event's volume.
Along with these crucial factors, investors ought to examine the company's reputation and track record, along with the overall market circumstances and competition in the industry.
Advantages of Convertible
Convertible notes are a popular way for startups and early-stage companies to raise capital without diluting the ownership of existing shareholders. While these notes have some distinct advantages for both startups and investors, they also carry a higher level of risk than traditional debt securities.
The advantages for Startups are:
1. Deferred Valuation
One of the most significant advantages of such notes for startups is that they allow for deferred valuation of the company.
As a result, the firm is relieved of the burden of determining a precise valuation at the time of the original investment, which may be challenging for early-stage businesses with little operational experience and hazy future prospects.
2. Flexibility
These notes can be structured in various ways, allowing startups to customize the terms to meet their specific needs.
The conversion price, discount rate, interest rate, and maturity date can all be discussed to strike a harmony between the company's financing requirements and the investor's return on investment.
3. Reduced Dilution
These notes also offer startups the opportunity to raise capital without immediately diluting the ownership of existing shareholders.
Since the notes are debt securities, they do not result in the issuance of new shares, which can be particularly appealing for startups with a limited number of authorized shares.
The advantages for Investors are:
1. Conversion Option
The conversion option is one of the most significant advantages of these notes for investors. This gives them the option to modify their debt into equity at a subsequent time, usually upon a particular event, such as a second round of funding or an initial public offering.
This may provide investors with a better potential return on investment compared to conventional debt instruments.
2. Reduced Risk
They offer investors reduced risk compared to traditional equity investments. Since the notes are debt securities, they have a higher priority in the event of bankruptcy or liquidation.
3. Liquidity
These notes can provide investors with greater liquidity than traditional equity investments since they can be sold or traded on secondary markets.
Disadvantages of Convertible Notes
The disadvantages for Startups are:
1. Uncertainty
Since the company's valuation is deferred until later, These notes can create uncertainty for startups and their investors. In addition, this can make it more difficult to attract subsequent financing rounds, as investors may have different expectations about the company's valuation.
These notes typically carry an interest rate, which can be a significant expense for startups not yet generating revenue which can further strain the company's finances and reduce its runway.
The disadvantages for Investors are:
1. Dilution
While these notes do not immediately dilute the ownership of existing shareholders, they can result in significant dilution if the conversion feature is structured in a way that favors the investor.
Arguments amongst investors and management may result from this, making securing funding for the following financing rounds more challenging.
2. Risk of Default
They carry a higher level of risk than traditional debt securities since the company may fail to grow as expected and may be unable to repay the note at maturity. In this case, the investor would lose their entire investment.
3. Uncertainty
These notes can create uncertainty for investors, as the company's valuation is deferred until a later date. As a result, estimating the prospective return on investment may be challenging, and arguments among investors and management can arise.
Structuring a Convertible Note
When structuring a note, the startup and the investor have important considerations to remember. Success relies on striking a harmony between the startup's financial needs and the investor's desire for a respectable return on investment.
In this post, we'll talk about some best practices that can assist both parties in having a better chance of success.
1. Define Key Terms Clearly
The terms of the note should be clearly defined and agreed upon by both parties. This includes the conversion price, discount rate, interest rate, maturity date, valuation cap, and liquidity event.
These terms should be specific and measurable to avoid any misunderstandings or disagreements down the road.
2. Set a Realistic Valuation
Based on the company's present state of development, market opportunity, and growth prospects, the value should be established at a realistic level.
Setting a valuation that is too high can discourage future investment and may make it difficult to attract subsequent rounds of financing.
3. Choose the Right Conversion Trigger
The conversion trigger should be carefully considered to ensure it aligns with the startup's long-term goals and objectives. For example, if the startup seeks to raise additional capital in the near future, the conversion trigger may be set to a subsequent round of financing.
Alternatively, suppose the startup is planning to go public. In that case, the conversion trigger may be set to an IPO.
4. Balance the Conversion Price and Discount Rate
The conversion price and discount rate must be matched to offer the investor a just return on their investment and allow the business a chance to grow.
Note
A higher conversion price may result in lower dilution for the startup, while a higher discount rate may provide a greater return for the investor.
5. Choose an Appropriate Interest Rate
Based on the startup's capacity to pay back the loan; the interest rate should be established at a suitable amount. The interest rate should be decreased or postponed later if the company is not yet making money to prevent creating a financial strain.
6. Consider a Valuation Cap
A valuation cap can be used to limit the potential dilution of existing shareholders in the event of a successful exit. This can provide additional protection for early investors and may help attract subsequent financing rounds.
7. Include a Liquidity Event
A liquidity event should be included in the note to provide a clear exit strategy for both the startup and the investor. This can include an IPO, acquisition, or another sale of the company.
8. Seek Legal Advice
Finally, seeking legal advice when structuring a note is important. The conditions of the note may be made clear, valid, and compliant with applicable securities regulations with the aid of an expert lawyer.
How Does a Convertible Note Work?
Consider the following scenario to understand better how these notes work in practice:
Assume a startup wants to raise 500,000 dollars to support its operations and grow its product offerings. The company decides to issue a convertible note to raise the funds.
The terms of the note are as follows:
- Conversion price: $ 1.00
- Discount rate: 20%
- Interest rate: 5%
- Maturity date: 3 years from issuance
- Valuation cap: $ 10 million
This implies that investors who buy the note will have the advantage of converting it into equity for $ 1.00 per share. They will, however, receive a 20% reduction on the conversion price, implying that they will be converting the note into equity for a cost of $ 0.80 per share.
The note will likewise earn 5% interest per year and will maturity in three years if not converted into stock. Finally, the company's valuation at the point of conversion will be limited to $ 10 million.
Several investors decide to invest in the note, and the company can raise the $ 500,000 it needs. The firm will persist in evolving its product offerings and build a solid customer base over the next few years.
Eventually, the company attracted the attention of a larger company in the industry, which offered to acquire the startup for $ 50 million.
The investors who acquired the note must choose whether to convert their debt into equity or to get principal plus interest payments.
Given that the company had a value of $ 50 million at the moment of purchase in the market, the conversion price of $ 0.80 per share represents a significant decrease. So instead, the investors choose to convert their debt into equity and acquire shares in the acquiring business for $ 0.80 per share.
Because the value ceiling was set at $ 10 million, investors' ownership stakes are not diluted excessively, and they can make a considerable return on their investment.
However, not all notes end with a successful acquisition or IPO. In other circumstances, the firm may not expand as projected and may be unable to repay the note when it matures.
In this instance, the investors would lose their whole investment because they would not be entitled to debt recovery if the firm failed. Additionally, if the conversion feature is structured to dilute existing shareholders too much, it can lead to conflicts between investors and management.
In a nutshell, a convertible note is a sort of financial security that may subsequently be converted into equity. It is frequently utilized by startups and the initial stages of an organization to obtain funds without diluting current shareholders' equity.
Note
When evaluating such a note, investors should consider several key parameters, including the conversion price, discount rate, interest rate, maturity date, valuation cap, and liquidity event. While these notes have a larger possible return on investment than traditional debt securities, investors should carefully consider the risks and benefits.
Convertible Note FAQs
Convertible notes can provide startups with a way to raise funds quickly without having to give up equity in the company at an early stage. They also offer flexibility in terms of repayment and can be used to attract investors interested in the potential for future equity.
It can offer investors a potentially high return on investment, as the note can be converted into equity at a discount to the company's future valuation.
If the business does not experience the anticipated degree of development or profitability, they also offer some downside protection.
At the time of conversion, the conversion price is often discounted to the company's future worth. Depending on the details of the note, this reduction might be between 10 and 30 percent.
The note will normally be returned to the investor with interest if the firm does not experience a liquidity event before its maturity date. However, the investor may have the option to extend the maturity date or convert the note into equity at a predetermined valuation.
A valuation cap is the maximum valuation at which the note can be converted into equity. If the firm acquires a high valuation at the time of conversion, this offers some protection against dilution to early investors.
One potential drawback is that these notes can be complex and may require legal and financial expertise to structure properly.
The investor could not get the anticipated investment return if the firm did not accomplish a liquidity event. Finally, if the firm obtains a high valuation at the time of conversion, these notes may result in dilution for current owners.
or Want to Sign up with your social account?