Franchise Tax

What Is a Franchise Tax?

The franchise tax is a type of tax that certain businesses or corporations pay to operate in specific states. This tax is not tied to income. It is calculated on the business's net worth or capital.

Corporations are essentially charged for the privilege of doing business in the state through this tax. It is also known as a privilege tax and grants businesses the authority to be chartered and/or to conduct operations within a specific state. 

Despite its name, it is not directly tied to taxes on what is commonly recognized as franchises. It is distinct from the annual federal and state income taxes that individuals and businesses need to report. 

This tax generates income for the specific state, representing a fee businesses incur for using the state's facilities.

These taxes help pay for infrastructure development, contributing to the education, transportation, and healthcare sectors. The amount of tax isn't the same for every state.

Understanding Franchise Taxes

Franchise tax is a type of tax imposed by some U.S. states on companies or organizations that conduct business within their respective jurisdictions. This represents a compensation or expense these entities undertake to access the amenities and infrastructure in those locations.

It serves as a significant revenue stream for states, crucial in funding vital infrastructure projects and supporting development in areas like healthcare and education. 

The franchise tax board gathers taxes based on the regulations set by the state. Certain states exempt specific types of businesses from paying this tax, such as businesses below a certain revenue threshold or non-profit organizations.

Taxation is determined by either the organization's net worth or total assets, and the calculation can become intricate. This complexity arises not only from the business's scale but also due to the specific regulations of the state, making the process challenging.

Organizations must adhere to state tax regulations to avoid facing penalties and interest charges. Failure to comply may result in legal actions taken by the state. To ensure compliance, companies should seek guidance from tax experts.

Franchise Tax Rates

Franchise taxes do not replace federal and state income taxes. They have their purpose and are usually paid annually, following deadlines similar to those of other taxes.

The tax amount can vary widely due to different tax regulations across states. Different states use varying methods to calculate this tax. Some rely on a company's assets or net worth, while others assess it based on the value of the company's capital stock. 

Some states may apply a flat fee for all businesses, while others determine the tax rate by considering a company's gross receipts or paid-in capital.

Let's consider franchise tax rates for some states:

1. Delaware

The annual tax rates are based on the size of the corporation and the chosen filing method, ranging from $175 to $250,000. The limited partnerships, limited liability companies, and general partnerships established need to pay only an annual tax of $300.

2. California

California has a tiered tax structure, including a franchise tax that applies to certain small businesses in specific scenarios.

While corporations and LLCs choosing corporate status are not subject to these taxes, S corporations, LLCs, LPs, and LLPs in California must adhere to the applicable tax rates.

For S corporations, the tax rate is determined by comparing the higher value between $800 and 1.5% of the corporation's net income. LLCs have to pay an $800 franchise tax, but if they choose corporate taxation, they face California's corporate income tax instead.

LLPs and LPs must also pay at least $800 in franchise tax, with varying tax rules for each.

3. Louisiana

The starting franchise tax is $110. If a business uses capital, it pays $1.50 for every $1,000 (or part of it) in Louisiana. If the capital exceeds $300,000, the fee becomes $3 for every $1,000 or fraction.

4. Mississippi

In Mississippi, the franchise tax applies to many companies. It is calculated at $2.50 for every $1,000 of capital used in the state. The taxable amount includes capital stock issued, along with surplus, undivided profits, true reserves, and outstanding profits. The minimum tax base is set to the corporation's assessed tangible and real personal property value.

How Is Franchise Tax Calculated? 

The two common approaches to calculating franchise taxes include:

1. Business Profit Margin Method

In this process, the profit margin is determined by deducting the corporation's costs and expenses from its revenue. The resulting margin is then multiplied by a percentage representing the business conducted in that particular state.

If a company conducts 70% of its business within a particular state, this tax is computed based on that 70% of revenue. A corporation operating 100% within a state must pay this tax on all its profits. The determined margin is then subjected to state tax rates as applicable. 

2. Authorized Shares Method

The tax amount is determined by multiplying the total authorized shares specified in the company's charter by the prescribed tax per share.

The specific details of these calculations can vary between states, as each state may have its regulations and requirements for franchise tax assessment.

Impact of Franchise Taxes on Business Decisions

Here are key areas where franchise taxes impact business decisions:

1. Location Selection

These taxes often influence where to establish or expand business operations. Businesses may weigh the tax rates, calculation methods, and exemptions different states offer. 

Some states may be more tax-friendly, leading companies to choose locations with lower tax burdens.

2. Expansion Strategies

The cost of compliance and the tax burden in each jurisdiction may impact the feasibility and profitability of expansion plans. Companies may prioritize growth in states with more favorable franchise tax conditions.

3. Capital and Net Worth

These taxes often consider a company's net worth or capital. Businesses manage their capital structure to optimize these taxes. 

This involves deciding how a company gets its money, handles debts, and chooses where to invest. 

4. Operations

Managing taxes can significantly challenge businesses, impacting their operational efficiency. 

To handle this, companies might invest in tools and procedures that make tax reporting easier, ensuring they file accurately and on time. This helps them avoid penalties and use resources more efficiently.

5. Financial Planning and Budgeting

These taxes represent a fixed cost for businesses, and their predictability is crucial for financial planning. The stability of the tax rates allows businesses to incorporate these costs into their budgets accurately. 

Any changes in these tax rates or calculation methods can impact financial forecasts and planning.

Entities Exempted from Franchise Taxes

A business conducting operations in various states might have to fulfill these tax requirements in all the states where it maintains formal registration. 

The following entities are exempt from franchise tax:

1. Sole proprietorships usually don't have to pay franchise or state business income taxes because they often operate without officially registering with the state.
2. General partnerships when all direct ownership consists of natural persons (excluding limited liability partnerships)
3. Individuals and entities that fall under Tax Code Chapter 171, Subchapter B 
4. Some unincorporated passive entities, certain trusts created by grantors, estates of individuals, and escrows  
5. Real estate mortgage investment conduits and specific qualified real estate investment trusts 
6. Nonprofit self-insurance trusts established under Insurance Code Chapter 2212
7. A trust approved under IRS Section 401(a).
8. A trust exempt under Internal Revenue Code Section 501(c)(9)
9. Unincorporated Political Committees

Consequences of Neglecting Franchise Tax Payments

Below are key repercussions businesses may face when franchise tax payments are neglected:

1. Notice and Tax Lien: Neglecting franchise tax payments may result in the issuance of a notice. A tax lien could be imposed on the business if the taxes remain unpaid, creating additional financial complications.
2. Loss of Legal Status: Failure to fulfill franchise tax obligations can lead to a loss of legal status for businesses. This can impact their ability to operate, engage in commercial activities, and honor contractual agreements within the state.
3. Operational Restrictions: Businesses that lose their legal status may face operational restrictions, potentially hindering their day-to-day activities and growth opportunities.
4. Risk to LLC Protections: If the franchise tax for a Limited Liability Company (LLC) goes unpaid, the LLC may forfeit its protections. Franchise tax exposes management or owners to financial liability and vulnerability, as the legal safeguards provided by the LLC structure may be compromised.
5. Financial Consequences: Neglecting franchise tax payments can lead to financial repercussions, including penalties and interest charges, further straining the company's resources.
6. Impact on Contracts: A business in default of its franchise tax obligations may need help to fulfill contractual agreements, damaging its reputation and relationships with clients, suppliers, and partners.
7. Legal Consequences: Continued neglect of franchise tax payments may result in legal action by the state, adding legal expenses and potential court judgments to the financial burden faced by the business.

Article 9-A

One needs to file and pay the franchise tax for general business corporations if:

1. A corporation is incorporated within New York State (domestic corporation).
2. A corporation operates outside New York State but conducts business, uses capital, owns or leases property, maintains an office, or generates income within New York State.
3. A corporation is a foreign corporation serving as the general partner in a partnership and meeting the criteria mentioned in point 1 (incorporated within New York State) are required to file and pay the franchise tax.
4. A corporation is a foreign corporation acting as a limited partner in a partnership, meeting the criteria mentioned in point 1 (incorporated within New York State), and having a role in running or controlling any part of that business.

Franchise Tax vs. Income Tax

Let's understand how both the taxes differ:

Example of a Franchise Tax

Let's take the example of Texas:

Here, the state's comptroller imposes taxes on all entities conducting their business within its borders and mandates the submission of an Annual Franchise Tax Report by May 15th each year. 

Texas calculates the franchise tax based on a company's margin, determined through one of four methods:

1. Find 70% of the revenue
2. Subtract the cost of goods sold from total revenue
3. Deduct compensation paid to all personnel from total revenue
4. Subtract $1 million from total revenue

Corporate revenue is calculated by subtracting statutory exclusions from the reported revenue on a corporation's federal income tax return.

Suppose a business has a total revenue of $1,000,000, a cost of goods sold amounting to $300,000, and compensation paid to all personnel totaling $150,000.

Using Method 2, which involves subtracting the cost of goods sold from total revenue, the franchise tax calculation would be as follows: $1,000,000 (total revenue) - $300,000 (cost of goods sold) = $700,000. 

This represents the franchise tax amount that the business would be liable to pay based on the specified calculation method.

Authored and researched by Rani Thakur | LinkedIn

Reviewed and edited by Parul Gupta | LinkedIn

Free Resources

To continue learning and advancing your career, check out these additional helpful WSO resources:

• A-Shares
• Bank Reserves
• Clawback
• Debenture
• EBIT