Active Management

It is a dynamic strategy where managers proactively aim to outperform benchmarks or market indices

Author: Nathan Kulakovski
Nathan Kulakovski
Nathan Kulakovski
I am a Commerce student, majoring in Finance & Accounting at UNSW in Sydney, Australia. I have experience as a business owner of a music tutoring company as well as a disability support worker. Both of these roles fostered key communication & organizational skills which I now consider my strengths.
Reviewed By: Sid Arora
Sid Arora
Sid Arora
Investment Banking | Hedge Fund | Private Equity

Currently an investment analyst focused on the TMT sector at 1818 Partners (a New York Based Hedge Fund), Sid previously worked in private equity at BV Investment Partners and BBH Capital Partners and prior to that in investment banking at UBS.

Sid holds a BS from The Tepper School of Business at Carnegie Mellon.

Last Updated:February 9, 2024

What is Active Management?

Active management is a dynamic investment strategy where fund or portfolio managers proactively make decisions to outperform specific benchmarks or market indices through ongoing engagement in the investment process.

This strategy calls for ongoing, direct engagement in the investing process, in contrast to passive management, which aims to mimic the performance of a chosen index.

Active management forms are based on the notion that greater returns above the whole market may be achieved by careful analysis, extensive research, and prompt decision-making.

This method entails a thorough assessment of several variables, such as the state of the market, prevailing economic patterns, and the particular performance of individual assets.

Active managers make deliberate adjustments to asset allocations, choose specific stocks or bonds, and react quickly to changing market conditions by utilizing their knowledge and market insights.

While this style of management has the potential to beat passive methods, it's important to recognize that these techniques frequently come with greater fees. 

The continuous argument between active and passive management is based on investor preferences, risk tolerance, and convictions on the relative merits of various investing philosophies.

Key Takeaways

  • Active management involves aiming to surpass specific benchmarks through continuous engagement in the investment process.
  • Active managers can swiftly adjust asset allocations, choose specific securities, and respond to changing market conditions, allowing them to capitalize on opportunities and navigate diverse market cycles.
  • In times of market volatility, strategies, including asset allocation modifications, hedging, and diversification, are used to reduce possible losses.
  • The strategy offers the potential for outperformance through careful analysis, extensive research, and timely decision-making by skilled fund managers.
  • Active management comes with higher fees compared to passive alternatives.

Theory of Active Management

Active fund managers execute extensive research, considering variables, including the performance of specific assets, economic trends, and market circumstances.

This thorough analysis guides their selection of specific stocks or bonds and adjustments to the portfolio's asset allocation to achieve returns that potentially surpass the overall market.

The standout characteristic of active management lies in its adaptable nature. Managers can take advantage of anticipated opportunities and navigate various market cycles because they are adaptable enough to purchase or sell stocks in response to shifting market circumstances.

A key component of this strategy is effective risk management. Managers use hedging strategies, portfolio diversification, and asset allocation modifications based on risk assessments to reduce possible losses.

Investment choices are made on an ongoing basis for actively managed funds, which are subject to regular performance monitoring. The goal is to find mispricings or market inefficiencies that may be used to increase returns.

However, it's crucial to understand that, in general, active forms of management entail higher costs than passive techniques. 

Investors continue to make judgments regarding their investments based on their opinions about market efficiency, risk tolerance, financial aspirations, and the ongoing debate between active and passive management.

Active Management Process

The foundation of active management is the belief that skilled fund or portfolio managers may outperform a certain benchmark or market index by utilizing their knowledge, research, and market insights. This process involves several components.

Study and Analysis

To identify possible investment opportunities, active managers carry out in-depth studies. This involves examining financial accounts, economic indicators, industry trends, and company-specific data to identify assets or securities that could yield higher returns.

Asset Allocation

Active managers systematically divide the assets in the portfolio based on their outlook for different market segments and asset classes (e.g., stocks, bonds, etc.). This flexibility allows them to overweight or underweight certain investments to take advantage of opportunities or manage risks.

Market Timing

Dynamic allocation includes market timing when managers attempt to take or abandon holdings at appropriate times. 

Note

Market Timing might include taking advantage of transient market volatility or hedging the portfolio's exposure to other asset classes in anticipation of market movements.

Risk Management

Proactive managers employ risk management strategies to minimize potential losses. To assist in achieving this, diversifying the portfolio across various assets, industries, or regions might be beneficial. 

Additionally, managers might use hedging techniques like futures and options to shield themselves from adverse market movements.

Constant Monitoring

Macroeconomic developments, asset performance, and market circumstances must all be continuously monitored as part of the ongoing active management process.

Note

Managers monitor shifts in the investing environment and make necessary adjustments to the portfolio to consider new risks and opportunities.

Performance Evaluation

The performance of actively managed funds undergoes regular assessment against a benchmark or index. Consistent outperformance deems the fund successful.  However, underperformance may trigger scrutiny and potential adjustments to the investment strategy.

Note

Active management costs are greater than passive methods since continuous research and decision-making need a lot of work. The effectiveness of active management depends on the fund managers' ability to skillfully and perceptively negotiate the complexities of the financial markets.

Investors considering active management should carefully analyze prior performance, manager track record, and associated fees before making an investment decision.

Advantages of Active Management

Active management presents various potential advantages for investors interested in leveraging fund managers' expertise and active decision-making. Here are some key benefits:

1. Possibility of Outperformance

Proactive management aims to surpass a benchmark or the competition. 

Skilled fund managers can yield greater returns than passive strategies because they can identify investment opportunities and adjust portfolios in reaction to changing market conditions by utilizing their knowledge, investigation, and analysis.

2. Possibility of Profiting from Market Inefficiencies

Vigorous managers look for mispricings or market inefficiencies that provide a financial advantage.

Note

In an attempt to generate alpha (returns above the benchmark), fund managers actively assess and choose assets in an attempt to take advantage of these market anomalies.

3. Personalization & Customization

An approach to portfolio development that is more individualized is made possible by active management. Fund managers provide a more personalized approach to investing because portfolios can be modified to account for investor's goals and risk tolerance.

4. Active Income Generation

Active managers can select high-yield bonds and manage interest rate risk to capitalize on changing market conditions in fixed-income portfolios. This is especially important for investors who prioritize income over capital gains.

Before utilizing this strategy, investors should thoroughly evaluate active managers' backgrounds, performance histories, and investment philosophies. 

Moreover, an investor's personal tastes, risk tolerance, and investing goals all play a significant role in determining if active management aligns with their entire strategy.

Disadvantages of Active Management

While active management holds promise, it brings along specific drawbacks and hurdles that investors should weigh:

1. Higher Fees

Active management typically incurs greater fees than passive strategies, covering expenses tied to research, analysis, and active decision-making by fund managers. These fees can significantly impact returns, particularly if the fund doesn't consistently outperform its benchmark.

2. Underperformance Risk

Not all actively managed funds succeed in outperforming the market despite the goal being to do so. Underperformance relative to the benchmark carries a risk that might rob investors of the benefits of a passive strategy with reduced costs.

3. Manager Risk

The success of active management heavily relies on the expertise and experience of the fund manager. Changes in management or a lack of requisite expertise can impact the fund's performance.

Note

Manager risk is a notable concern, and leadership changes may alter the investment strategy.

4. Market Timing Challenges

There are inherent difficulties in timing the market or choosing a tactical asset allocation. It is difficult to predict short-term market movements, and making decisions at the wrong moment might increase risk and result in worse-than-desirable outcomes.

5. Tax Inefficiency

Regularly making bigger capital gains distributions from investments in actively managed funds may not be the most tax-efficient option for investors. This might affect after-tax returns, especially in taxable investment accounts.

Conclusion

Among the constantly evolving field of investment methods, active management is a dynamic strategy that seeks to maximize returns by utilizing the knowledge and judgment of fund managers.

The fundamental idea behind this strategy is proactive decision-making, where managers make an effort to outperform particular benchmarks by doing in-depth analysis, comprehensive research, and frequent portfolio modifications.

However, the benefits of actively managing coexist with notable disadvantages. The higher fees associated with ongoing research and decision-making present a challenge, and the risks of underperformance, manager risk, and market timing challenges should not be underestimated. 

An informed choice on whether to actively manage or not should be made after considering risk tolerance, personal preferences, and long-term financial objectives. Investors need to weigh the possible rewards against the expenses and hazards involved.

The investor's convictions ultimately determine which way to vote in the continuing debate between active and passive management. 

A well-rounded and robust investment portfolio may be achieved by balancing actively managed and passive methods, achieving appropriate diversification, and remaining aware of market fluctuations.

Active management is still a powerful tool for anyone looking for a personalized, hands-on approach to managing the intricacies of the markets, even as the financial field changes.

Researched and authored by Nathan Kulakovski | LinkedIn

Reviewed and edited by Parul Gupta | LinkedIn

Free Resources

To continue learning and advancing your career, check out these additional helpful WSO resources: