Arbitrageur

Refers to investors that attempt to capitalize on market inefficiencies

Author: Adin Lykken
Adin Lykken
Adin Lykken
Consulting | Private Equity

Currently, Adin is an associate at Berkshire Partners, an $16B middle-market private equity fund. Prior to joining Berkshire Partners, Adin worked for just over three years at The Boston Consulting Group as an associate and consultant and previously interned for the Federal Reserve Board and the U.S. Senate.

Adin graduated from Yale University, Magna Cum Claude, with a Bachelor of Arts Degree in Economics.

Reviewed By: Sid Arora
Sid Arora
Sid Arora
Investment Banking | Hedge Fund | Private Equity

Currently an investment analyst focused on the TMT sector at 1818 Partners (a New York Based Hedge Fund), Sid previously worked in private equity at BV Investment Partners and BBH Capital Partners and prior to that in investment banking at UBS.

Sid holds a BS from The Tepper School of Business at Carnegie Mellon.

Last Updated:December 13, 2023

What is an Arbitrageur?

Investors who attempt to capitalize on market inefficiencies are known as arbitrageurs. These inefficiencies may be connected to price, dividends, regulation, or any other facet of the market. 

Arbitrage occurs most frequently due to pricing inefficiencies. For risk-free earnings, they trade off one another while taking advantage of price inefficiencies. 

For instance, they might purchase equities listed on various exchanges to compare prices. 

A discrepancy between two exchanges would be created by shorting the same amount of an overvalued stock on one exchange relative to an undervalued stock on the other. 

Understanding an Arbitrageur

Profit without taking any risks when prices on several exchanges converge. They occasionally try to make money by turning private data into arbitrage.

For example, an acquisition arbitrageur might use information about an impending acquisition to buy a company's stock and profit from the subsequent price increase.

The term "arbitrage" refers to an organization or person who generates spread income by:

Because arbitrage opportunities are rare to come by and demand relatively quick deals, these types of investors are typically experienced. 

They must also have an eye for detail and be risk-tolerant. This is so because carry trades generally carry a high level of risk. This is because they are also wagers on the market's future course.

Because they take advantage of pricing inefficiencies to make prices more accurate than they otherwise would be, these types of investors are crucial to the operation of securities and capital markets.

An investor that takes advantage of any market inefficiency is known as an arbitrageur. They are essential to ensuring that market inefficiencies are avoided or kept to a minimum.

They are typically experienced investors who must pay close attention to detail and be willing to take risks. As a result, price variations between stocks or other assets listed on various exchanges are frequently profitable for them.

In this scenario, this type of investor could buy on one exchange and sell short on a second, more expensive exchange.

Features of arbitrage

Some of the features are:

  • They must construct opposite positions: They have to buy significant positions on the one hand and sell large parts on the other. It is impossible to achieve arbitrage if they have only buy positions or only sell parts.
  • Arbitrage must be carried out simultaneously: When they carry out arbitrage, the buying and selling behavior is carried out at the same time. If only buying or selling behavior exists, arbitrage cannot be realized.
  • Price linkages allow them to benefit: Gain from the price differential between purchasing and selling specific assets simultaneously in the high-priced and low-priced markets. In the securities market, profit is generated by purchasing additional securities for the portfolio and selling a particular asset inside the portfolio.

Arbitrageur Example

As an illustration, a stock trades on the New York and London stock exchanges. 

Consider that the stock is valued at $172 in the New York market and £100 in the London market, with a $1.75 to £1.75 exchange rate

Regardless of transaction costs, investors can purchase 100 shares of the stock in New York and sell them in London for a risk-free return. The return at no risk is:

100 x ($1.75 x 100 - $172) = $300

Transaction fees may lower returns for small investors. 

However, both in the stock market and the foreign exchange market, substantial investment corporations have low transaction costs. The arbitrage above chances will appeal to them, and they will use them as much as possible. Arbitrage possibilities can't last forever. 

When this type of investor purchases equities on the New York market, stock prices will rise due to supply and demand. 

Similar to how they sell their equities, the price of the stock in sterling decreases as they do so on the London market. This causes the two prices to equalize at the current exchange rate quickly.

It was impossible to create such a stark disparity between the price of sterling and the dollar in the first place due to the existence of profit-driven arbitrageurs.

Arbitrageurs Vs. Speculators

These types of investors are those who take advantage of the opportunities in the futures market itself to buy and sell the same or similar quantities in the same or opposite direction to seek profit from:

  • The spread in different contract months
  • Different markets
  • The price difference between various commodities at the same time

From this, we can see that the difference between them is:

  • They purchase and sell both long and short simultaneously, while speculators only buy or sell one way while trading, either long or short
  • Speculators profit from changes in a single futures contract price, whereas they profit from changes in the relative merits of two different futures contracts

In other words, while they focus only on relative price changes, speculators only pay attention to absolute price changes. 

Unlike speculators, arbitrageurs are less hazardous, and established exchanges charge lower transaction costs for their arbitrage deals. 

Inter-period, cross-market, and cross-commodity arbitrage are the three basic trading strategies arbitrageurs use. But from other perspectives, speculators and arbitrageurs have similarities.

The only distinction between them is how they earn their profits; both have the same objective, which is the pursuit of profit, and there is no substantive difference between them. 

Arbitrage trading involves both the purchase and sale of speculative products. Accordingly, arbitrageurs pay attention to relative price movements and absolute price changes. 

The range of price swings is stabilized when they discover a strange price association between futures commodities and exploit the difference between the two futures prices to arbitrage at any moment.

Last but not least, the futures market is where all the profits made are found. They are all ancillary to manufacturing and constitute unproductive labor. 

Because neither of them can create surplus value on their own, which is a trustworthy source of profit, the nature of their gains comes from the surplus value provided by the hedgers.

In short, arbitrageurs seem separate from speculators and hedgers, but they are still speculators—a special kind of speculators.

Arbitrage Strategy and Arbitrageur

To generate revenue, an arbitrage strategy uses the momentary discrepancy between the price of specific financial items and the market's return rate. 

It is referred to as a risk-free arbitrage method when this price fluctuation results in a risk-free return. These arbitrage possibilities are uncommon and vanish right away. 

Some financial products' discrepancy between yield and price does not last very long. 

The risk of earning money through this change is that the price or yield might not change as anticipated.

This return-generating technique may not be a low-risk trading strategy for hedge fund managers but rather a risk arbitrage approach that could cause a price or yield deviation to reverse course or converge to the historical equilibrium level.

Using different pricing discrepancies in one or more markets, an investor can use an arbitrage method to potentially profit without incurring any risk of loss or using any of their own money.

There are several types of space, time, instrument, risk, and tax arbitrage. Limitations to arbitrage include trading noise and a lack of exact duplicates.

There are certain risks because arbitrage tactics are unstable, there is a lot of liquidity, and things change quickly. 

The intertemporal arbitrage approach is a transaction for the price difference between various stock index futures contracts. 

Investors must forecast the price difference and the operation of the price difference between the stock index futures contracts of various expiry months due to the unpredictability of the spread operator. 

Consequently, this arbitrage is not risk-free in this form. The inter-period arbitrage transaction can be beneficial if the spread's direction matches the investor's projected direction; otherwise, it will be lost. 

As a result, inter-period arbitrage involves some risk.

Arbitrageur Risks

The arbitrage method entails various risks due to instability, high liquidity, and rapid fluctuations. 

The intertemporal arbitrage approach is a transaction for the price difference between various stock index futures contracts. 

Investors must forecast the price difference and the operation of the price difference between the stock index futures contracts of various expiry months due to the unpredictability of the spread operator. 

Consequently, this arbitrage is not risk-free in this form. The inter-period arbitrage transaction can be beneficial if the spread's direction matches the investor's projected direction; otherwise, it will be lost. 

As a result, inter-period arbitrage involves some risk. Although calendar arbitrage tactics carry some risk, they are considerably less risky than trading solely based on speculation. 

The inter-period arbitrage strategy uses the price differential between futures contracts with various expiry months to buy contracts with one month's expiration and sell contracts with a different month's end. 

The inter-period arbitrage strategy is the opposite direction for two contracts with the same quantity. Arbitrage is risky since some parameters that estimate the intertemporal arbitrage boundary cannot be precisely established. 

After the spread reaches a particular level, arbitrage is advised for investors with lower risk tolerance. A margin system is used in futures. If the margin is insufficient, more margin will be needed if the price moves in a way that is adverse to investors. 

The possibility of forced liquidation is possible if the margin cannot be paid in full and on time. Arbitrage will be significantly impacted when this occurs, and failures may even ensue.

To account for this, we reserve a sizable amount of futures margin in the arbitrage technique described above. However, there is still no assurance that there won't be an inadequate margin if the price fluctuates quickly.

Researched and authored by Yiqing Qiao | LinkedIn

Reviewed and Edited by Priyansh Singal | LinkedIn

Free Resources

To continue learning and advancing your career, check out these additional helpful WSO resources: