Thought Banana
Everyone Say
Not to get too political, but…
Everyone is freaking out about ESG investing right now. Whether you’re on the left, right, center, up, or down, it seems like everyone with $100 in a Robinhood account has got something to say.
And yesterday, that tension came to a boil on Capitol Hill. Let’s see what’s going on.
During Big Donnie T’s administration, the Labor Department created new rules centered around reiterating existing law that essentially limited the considerations of investment managers for pensions, ERISA retirement plans, and other similar accounts to focusing solely on achieving the best returns for a client’s goals.
When Joey B showed up, he and his Labor Department scrapped that real quick and tossed another element into the mix, and that element was carbon, or more specifically, the lack thereof.
Recently, the federal government has given the thumbs up for “public” investment managers to consider other factors in their decision-making, including things like…ESG.
Suddenly, and noticeably as we sit here still down over 16% from the S&P 500’s all-time high, ESG investing has become the hot new topic in Washington and your parents’ Twitter feed.
In case you live under a rock, ESG is Environmental, Social, and Governance investing, an investment style that intends to reward the companies most friendly to social justice causes over those that snub the subjects. The key word there is “intends” as, like anything in investing, it doesn’t always work out like that.
This could be a large contributor to why Congress has moved forward with a bill to reverse the Biden Admin’s changes and make sure that those investment managers only consider the investment return they mean to achieve for their clients.
I mean, the fact that the government has to tell investors and fund managers what they can and can’t think is wild enough, and the fact that there’s so much beef around it only adds to the entertainment.
Now, in all reality, none of this actually really matters. I’d bet my life savings that Biden vetoes this thing without a second thought, so it’s kinda moot to be talking about as it stands. Where things get interesting, however, is speculating wildly on what this means for ESG investing overall.
Look, we’re barely even a year into the latest bear market, while the S&P’s return over the past year is basically flat. However, during that same period, as liquidity crunched and all of a sudden, making money in stocks wasn’t completely automatic, ESG funds saw their priority in the minds of investors diminish like you to your Hinge date after you spilled your drink at dinner last night.
Don’t get me wrong—this isn’t to say ESG investing is or isn’t good or bad; we’ll let the data speak for itself. What it does confirm, however, is the fact that politicians will literally fight over anything as long as they look cool to their constituents?
The big question: Was the whole ESG investment strategy always just a ZIPR, bull market fantasy? Can the strategy make a comeback in future years once markets figure out how to go up again?
|
Reprehenderit odio beatae minima maxime ut sit. Commodi velit neque atque fugiat. Deleniti ducimus dolore enim nihil officiis sit recusandae. Et sed beatae sapiente expedita quia et aperiam et. Perferendis et et sunt explicabo quia deserunt.
Maiores quaerat non quas laudantium veritatis tenetur. Doloremque natus cumque dolore consequatur fugiat sed dignissimos.
Illum nam nobis vel perferendis sunt est. Ducimus nam et saepe totam. Voluptates rerum qui dicta qui.
See All Comments - 100% Free
WSO depends on everyone being able to pitch in when they know something. Unlock with your email and get bonus: 6 financial modeling lessons free ($199 value)
or Unlock with your social account...