how does engagement go?
been seeing this girl for a while, we're both pretty convinced that we're the one for each other, so we're going to get married (we've decided to get engaged around the end of the year)
what is an engagement and how does it work? we've been looking at rings and stuff, probably gonna get a lab grown diamond ring for ~2k.
she's a pretty chill girl and doesnt need/want anything over the top, what kind of engagement am i supposed to do? how does it even work?
I’m Catholic, so typically an engagement entails 6 months of counseling to prepare for marriage.
Most secular couples don’t do this, but they also carry a higher divorce rate. Even if you’re not Catholic, I’d recommend a few couples therapy sessions before you tie the knot.
Are you married?
Nah. I’m single for a few more years. Just living the dream.
Have you read like any of his posts ever? The shirtless pics? Come on man.
Misleading stat. Catholic couples have a lower divorce rate because there are religious incentives against divorce, not because they are happier/find better spouses/use counseling
Counseling helps and to say it is not a factor is misleading as well. More couples of all faiths and non-faiths should prepare through couples therapy. Getting married without thinking about it too much is a recipe for disaster for some.
Dgo you r
You really think that getting advice from "celibate" (pedophiles) can make a marriage last? What do they know abt marriage save for their clandestine relationships with minors?
Most believers stay in loveless marriages, even abusive, because they were fed bullshit by those pedophiles; they fear offending god lest they are thrown to hell. Adults don't need no fucking advice on how to run their lives.
So uh... you aren’t catholic?
engagement is dumb as fuckkk. so full of yourselves to do a whole thing. just go get married. or don't. nobody cares and it's not a huge deal. gonna drop money you could put on a down payment to formally promise a bitch some shit. get over yourselves
hahahah should have known you'd drop in
i kind of agree with you, we're only spending like 2-3k on the ring and maybe a nice dinner
no fancy yachts or whatever
From your wording, it sounds like you think of marriage as something akin to signing a 1-year apartment lease. You should enter marriage because you can’t imagine being without her not because it seems like the next logical step or she has decided it’s time.
+SB
I came here to say exactly this. The tone of OP's post is casual and flippant. I don't have it in me to try and shake sense into OP over this forum, though.
not at all tbh, you're right about that on not being able to imagine life without her, i'm just asking for views on how to do the engagement
To be fair, he's here for information. He's not really looking for validation about his relationship, so it wouldn't have made sense for him to have justified his relationship by talking about how he "can't imagine being without her".
Agreed.
I was given great advice before I proposed to my now wife, “If it’s not a ‘fuck yes’, then it’s a no”
Getting married isn’t really a pragmatic thing...
I just said fuck it and blew my SA money on a ring. Can’t take it with you.
hahaha wym
all my summer money is gone i started FT with a deficit LOL
In case the satire wasn’t obvious for you youngins - plz don’t listen to this guy.
3 month salary is the dumbest shit ever. 1 month, maybe. Spend the rest on a vacation or two or save for a down payment
If you go on the ring company's website, they will say "2-3+ months of salary." But of course they will say that they want you to pay them a lot of money
im not even spending 1 month ahahaha im at bb ib gonna spend between 2-3k on a lab grown diamond which is the same as a "natural" diamond aside from its provenance
dude it's like 3x cheaper
How much do make monthly? If it's like $1k, I get what ur saying lol
3 months of his corporate finance bonus prorated ;)
Engagement usually starts with some market research, opportunity identification and sourcing. Once potential target is identified, initial risk assessment. If this is looking satisfactory, then you'd do a fancy proposal pitch, get a commitment, proceed to a 3 to 6 month due diligence, culminating with signing. Everything will seem great once you've signed, but then you gain access to all the inside secrets, and that's when things could get messy as you work toward financial close... wait... what engagement are we talking about here? Ah, works the same either way. All the best.
I spent like 5k on engagement + wedding rings combined from Blue Nile (online). We picked out how she wanted it to look by visiting stores and then bought online. Simple engagement and modest wedding. Saved extra money toward investing / down payment on a condo. Our 9 year anniversary's coming up.
Your results may vary.
The bigger the wedding, the more accelerated the divorce especially when the engagement is shortened IME.
I get anxiety at the idea of having a big wedding. Even if you end up having a good time on the day, you spend the build-up stressing about so many things. Not to mention the exorbitant cost.
if you havent already, I'd talk with her dad and get his approval. Pretty traditional, but it's what I would do. As for the actual engagement... think about what she likes. Propose during a hike? After a nice dinner? During a vacation? Maybe have a friend lurking around to get pictures of her reaction? Possible tell one of her friends to take her out that day and get a manicure (without it being obvious you're going to propose.. Maybe schedule the dinner a day or two after the manicure, so it's still fresh, but not suspicious of it happening the same day)
For me, I'd definitely like to have her surprise/reaction photographed. Nice memory for the moment, but all couples are different. Good luck man and congrats!
god damn dude good point on the manicure her fingernails are actually always done
holy crap that is some ib level attention to detail and context
if your group is hiring, lmk lol
My two cents.
Ask father now. Over golf or ballgame.
Proposed stroke of midnighf new years eve at Harvard Club.
Vintage cocktail ring. We agreed for a down payment on house.
Elope and get married at justice of the peace. Just the two of you. Quietly.
Have a "wedding" later. Trust me. It will be 10x easier.
OPEN BAR. Do not be THAT couple.
Take money/gifts from wedding and furnish house.
25+ years and counting...
before you buy her a big diamond, check this out:
that said, if you're with a girl who already values that kinda shit, you're stuck. I was lucky in that I expressed my disdain for that kinda shit early on and wifey was super onboard. it helped that she's eccentric as well so didn't want a diamond like all of her friends. we ended up going with a gemstone with diamond accents, cheaper than a diamond, rarer, and more unique. less than 1 month's income
asked the old man at around midnight over christmas, we were both hammered on bourbon, he accepted, I promptly threw up (true story)
proposed to wife out of the blue, favorite dinner, wine, flowers, all that stuff was ready when she got home. wasn't some big production but I tried to be thoughtful and memorable. she hates surprises so I didn't want to do some secret thing where all of her friends saw it and there was a photographer. she constantly rips on her friends who did that. the key here is know your soon-to-be fiance. what works for me won't necessarily work for you. and what gets posted on isntagram may not be appropriate for her
she accepted and said she'd think about a wedding but didn't want a long engagement. after 1 year, she came to realization she didn't want a wedding so just went to the courthouse and then to the caribbean.
all in under $5k (rings, wedding paperwork, honeymoon). I'm at the age where my contemporaries are going through their first divorces/marital troubles and so far, it's been the people with $50-100,000 weddings and $10-20,000 engagement rings. correlation is not causation, but it is interesting.
Interesting last point... what do you think explains that correlation? That an expensive wedding sets expectations too high from the beginning of the marriage? Or could it be a selection bias thing where the needy chicks want expensive weddings and the down to earth ones dgaf
see here: https://www.miamiherald.com/news/nation-world/national/article214550500….
this is one of those things that's not knowable I don't think so I can't say why for sure. it could be what you're saying, it could be selection bias, it could be completely random.
my point is this - one size does NOT fit all. 3 months income did not work for us, nor did a formal wedding, but for many of my more traditional friends, what my wife and I did would be grounds for divorce. it all depends
Considering the divorce rate is ~50% I think this is more anecdotal to your life experiences (after all you deal with a lot of HNW clients), rather than something we can draw from.
possible! however I'm not the first to posit this: https://www.miamiherald.com/news/nation-world/national/article214550500….
Especially taking that probability into account, you definitely shouldn't overspend on weddings... it's not any more likely to keep your marriage together.
Adam Conover lets his wife peg him
While he is undoubtedly one of the biggest douches in the world, he’s still correct
Well whatever you do, protect each person's assets. Get a prenup
My girl insists on a natural diamond vs lab grown diamond. Really seems like a waste of money to me as it’s not an investment to me but whatever.
why tho
Even leaving aside the fact that lab grown diamonds are more flawless than natural in every way, they also mitigate the cruel African diamond mining process.
Architecto excepturi voluptatem quis cum. Et vel quo ut illum tempora. Distinctio autem occaecati quia eaque voluptatem velit. Quo fuga voluptas animi laborum expedita ut. Iste ipsam quisquam non aut doloribus vel voluptatum et. Suscipit cumque delectus et optio earum.
Ut laudantium veniam aliquam repellendus deleniti eveniet pariatur. Quo occaecati debitis incidunt facilis porro.
Eius voluptates voluptatem occaecati debitis eaque sunt aut voluptas. Quia soluta sed id sit hic. Aut aut ut tempora dolor voluptatibus aspernatur sunt minima.
Consequuntur quia cupiditate id dolore. Et quis ducimus assumenda et. Laborum odio voluptatem molestias fugiat eos aut voluptates. Dolorem pariatur sed dignissimos voluptatem.
See All Comments - 100% Free
WSO depends on everyone being able to pitch in when they know something. Unlock with your email and get bonus: 6 financial modeling lessons free ($199 value)
or Unlock with your social account...
Nam aut odio dignissimos debitis. Omnis est inventore non sint ad numquam. Voluptas tenetur ipsa qui omnis ab aperiam sint enim. Et consequatur architecto et vero optio fuga sed. Iure et eligendi aliquam quo et temporibus id. Cumque debitis velit facilis provident ducimus. Doloribus placeat repellendus dignissimos non unde et.
Aut accusantium unde repudiandae id est vel quasi. Ut eum in quia corporis unde et doloremque. Illo vitae excepturi labore. Neque nemo natus et aliquid molestiae tempora culpa laudantium.
Ut quia voluptas omnis recusandae aperiam animi voluptas ab. Natus error sint ab hic.
Illum sed dolor ut sapiente eaque exercitationem et. Rerum eveniet enim ab. Magnam consectetur ea ut cumque nulla sit. Eaque sapiente autem cupiditate adipisci quisquam. Dolorem maxime distinctio maiores recusandae. Occaecati eos culpa aut aut numquam ipsum praesentium. Magni voluptatem facere voluptatem voluptatum sunt.
Consequatur nihil error suscipit voluptatem commodi cumque qui. Rerum et consequuntur eos saepe. Dolorum delectus est ut. Molestiae quisquam magni dolorum quia iure. Impedit animi ut iusto praesentium necessitatibus sed ut.
Dicta distinctio qui ipsam voluptatibus eius quis occaecati. Consequuntur excepturi voluptas possimus minus eum. Tempore magnam libero non culpa. Asperiores amet omnis tempora quia sunt minus. Aliquam odit perspiciatis est maiores tempore non alias.
Quod quia et perspiciatis nulla. Consequatur unde qui omnis vitae nam nihil tempora. Voluptatem rerum doloribus nostrum quia. Quo voluptates quia eveniet expedita reprehenderit libero.