PE downturn- Impact on a PortCo CFO / Operating Partner
There are plenty of threads here on whether PE is in a downturn, and most of them end up as a career question: is PE still worth it compared to staying in IB? For those that think the answer is no, the reasons I see are fewer VP promotions, even fewer partner seats with seniors who have no reason to retire, longer holds and fewer exits making carry slower and harder to realize, IB comp that now competes with or is better than PE in some cases, and hours that aren’t meaningfully better.
I have found all these debates pretty interesting, but I wanted to ask a similar question about the impact of PE industry trends on Operating Partners and PortCo CFOs.
If you’re a PortCo CFO or an Operating Partner, a big chunk of the economic case is obviously the equity (MIP units, co-invest, or a share of carry). But that only pays when there’s an exit, and even then, hurdles and the waterfall mean your equity % doesn’t necessarily equal your share of the proceeds. So if the problems people point to in PE are as significant as reported (longer holds, fewer exits, more continuation vehicles, deals done at 2021 multiples that need a lot to go right to clear hurdles, etc), doesn’t the operating path take a similar hit as the PE deal side, maybe even worse, since cash comp is usually lower than the deal side and the equity is a bigger share of the total? And that’s on top of what I imagine are already high stress and long hours, probably not far off from the deal side.
I am currently in turnaround/restructuring consulting, with some interim CFO work on smaller companies. My plan has been to build more of that experience, potentially by moving to an OCFO group (mostly interim CFO roles at PE PortCos) or a PEPI/value creation group at another shop (A&M, Alix, Accordion, etc.). The end goal is a PortCo CFO seat where I can see a company through to an exit, and eventually a longer-term CFO role.
So my main question: is the Op Partner / PortCo CFO path still as attractive as it was 5 to 10 years ago, or has the risk/reward shifted along with the rest of the industry? It is probably the latter answer but I would welcome additional context or different viewpoints. I realize there may not be very many operating partners or PortCo CFOs on this forum, but I would also be curious to hear the perspective from those of you on the PE deal side.
The concerns you’ve raised about the impact of a PE downturn on Operating Partners and PortCo CFOs are valid and align with some of the most helpful WSO content on this topic. Here’s a breakdown of the key points to consider:
1. Equity and Exit Challenges
2. Cash Compensation vs. Deal Side
3. Stress and Workload
4. Shifting Risk/Reward
5. Your Career Path
Final Thoughts
The Op Partner/PortCo CFO path remains attractive for those who thrive in high-stakes, operationally intensive environments and are willing to take on the risks associated with equity-heavy compensation. However, the shifting dynamics in PE mean that the path is less predictable and potentially less lucrative than it was 5-10 years ago. If you’re comfortable with these risks and passionate about driving value creation, it can still be a rewarding career path.
Sources: Private Equity Operations / Portfolio Career Path, Q&A: Private Equity Portfolio Company CFO, Q&A: Private Equity Portfolio Company CFO, Q&A: Private Equity Investor at a Large Buyout Firm Focused on Growth and LBO Strategies
I don’t have anything other than an anecdote, but recently had a good friend who’s CFO who left for a different firm’s PortCo. The equity upside wasn’t there at his prior place.
I’d assume there will be a bunch of CFOs voluntarily leaving over the next year or two to pursue that equity upside.
That makes sense, I didn't think about that, but I agree we will probably see more of that movement.
Certainly seems like it will be more difficult to squeeze out > 2x outcomes in the 5-7 year frame, but I think this probably just varies with industries as it always has. Biggest difference right now is cost of financing.
It’s an interesting question. Like the poster above said, I imagine there will be tons of movement as comp becomes unatainable. Unlike investment seats, it’s much easier to move around as an operator, and you’re not necessarily siloed to PE backed companies. Those PortCos will still need leadership, and they will have to attract talent. I would not be surprised if targets / packages were modified to retain and recruit.
Seems like it might be a favorable market for those with experience to land roles with attractive comp. I also wonder if the retirement of older CFOs will leave a significant gap that needs to be filled, or if the pipeline of younger PE backed CFOs is already crowded. If it is the former, then I think that is where the Interim CFO work could be in demand (as it takes longer to find a good permanent candidate) and function as a good stepping stone to the full time roles. Though I don't know how much PE Operating Partners recruit from the interim CFO firms they work with for temporary roles. Either way, it looks like an interesting space at the moment.
I would agree. I’m currently in the seat, although for a non-PE capital stack. The talent, at least in my industry, is antiquated and lacking. May be different in SaaS or other more modern sectors. I imagine you will not see a step back in comp, but ad hoc resets as there is turnover. The trend is currently up, and has been since the creation of the CFO position.
Sharing some perspective as someone in LMM PE (investing seat).
Over last ~3 years, I've gotten a decent amount of recruiters / search firms email in-bounds saying they are working with an experienced CFO candidate and wanted to see if any of our portcos had a CFO need.
On the comp side, ~90% of the equity compensation figures we've quoted to our management teams (CEO/CFO/etc) in our "base case" projections turned out to be significantly off (actual performance was weaker). Their equity wasn't worth much in reality. We've had some management turnover, I think they all realized their equity wasn't worth much / not likely to be realized anytime soon so they focused on their cash comp (base+ year end bonus for hitting EBITDA) and weren't really incentivized to stay long-term. The macro issues as you mentioned made them realize exit timelines are pushed out years, so instead of getting $1 million in 5 year exit, they more likely would get $[500k] in 8 year exit.
Quia autem molestiae nemo placeat. Et quis magnam in ut.
Est recusandae corrupti optio deleniti id et. Et vero praesentium fugiat velit velit laborum ab placeat. Quam possimus nostrum qui.
See All Comments - 100% Free
WSO depends on everyone being able to pitch in when they know something. Unlock with your email and get bonus: 6 financial modeling lessons free ($199 value)
or Unlock with your social account...