MBA Decision for IB - Ross vs Darden vs Johnson vs Tuck
Hey everyone,
Looking for some advice as I make a final MBA decision with the goal of pivoting into investment banking.
I’ve been fortunate to get accepted into:
Michigan Ross
UVA Darden
Cornell Johnson
Dartmouth Tuck
I’m pretty location agnostic. Not NYC or bust, just want a chance to secure an internship and get that return offer.
Would really appreciate any insights from current students, alumni, or anyone who went through IB recruiting at these programs, as well as anyone in the industry who has an opinion on the matter.
Thanks!
Based on the most helpful WSO content, here's what you need to know about these programs for investment banking (IB) recruiting:
Cornell Johnson
Darden (UVA)
Tuck (Dartmouth)
Ross (Michigan)
Key Takeaways for Your Decision
Ultimately, all four programs can get you into IB, so your decision may come down to personal fit, financial considerations, and the type of MBA experience you’re seeking.
Sources: Review of Investment Banking Recruiting at Cornell Johnson, Review of Investment Banking Recruiting at Cornell Johnson
Historically, all of these programs have had respectable IB placements. With so many offers, you should try to negotiate scholarship offers (if you didn't already do this), since presenting your competing offers in the right way as a part of these discussions can often lead to increased scholarship offers.
If it's helpful, here is a video in which I interview a Ross MBA student who went through IB recruiting and describes how the process worked at Ross, leading to an offer at Guggenheim:
Interview: IB recruitment at Ross
So far I’ve had some success with negotiations, and I’ve updated my original post to reflect that. Does this change your opinion at all?
I would probably select UVA Darden or Ross if the offers do not change. Arguments could be made for East Coast schools having a slightly stronger presence in NYC (which you could confirm or deny with LinkedIn research), but the $60k gap vs. Cornell and $120k gap vs. Tuck is a major factor you should consider.
You can also consider the nature of the programs beyond the recruiting stats. For example, UVA Darden is going to involve a much heavier academic workload than Ross. This can be good (arguably, you learn more) or bad (you have less time for recruiting and networking).
Be careful what you post in public forums; it's not impossible for admissions officers to read posts like these.
Thanks for the advice and for the heads up, I've edited the post to no longer include some information.
I'd pick Tuck just because New Hampshire is awesome. Surprisingly underrated golf. You could go skiing in the winter, go boating in the summer on one of the lakes, or go white water rafting in Maine. Take trips to Boston for baseball games or go to Cape Cod for the beach. Go hiking in the White Mountains. Take a girl to Bar Harbor for a getaway.
New Hampshire is paradise.
Yeah, I was getting really excited thinking about the chance to be in nature and really enjoy my time there. A lot of what I was hoping to do, you already mentioned. I’ve now updated my post to reflect the current scholarship situation. Does that change your opinion at all?
Going into the applications, I had Tuck as my number one and Ross as number two. But now with the scholarships, it feels tough to turn down Ross. I’m still waiting to see if Tuck will increase their offer, though I doubt it will be anywhere close to matching.
Autem maxime nostrum quidem quam consequatur facere. Eligendi corporis nam debitis eos aut animi. Neque qui nobis quos sit nemo est.
Iure excepturi hic enim a id sapiente animi. Consequuntur aut hic voluptatem expedita tempora reprehenderit. Corrupti ea aut autem consequatur occaecati illum recusandae. Rem nihil in delectus nihil.
Odit dolores voluptates rerum libero ipsam. Quod porro aut sint est quia quo officia. Optio voluptas quia blanditiis nihil. Ut aspernatur veritatis unde odit.
Qui illum animi ipsam nesciunt officiis odio. Qui tempora voluptatum reprehenderit dolorem voluptas. Voluptatem placeat qui quaerat quas.
See All Comments - 100% Free
WSO depends on everyone being able to pitch in when they know something. Unlock with your email and get bonus: 6 financial modeling lessons free ($199 value)
or Unlock with your social account...