Choosing between internship offers: BB Trading or ER at large LO AM?
Hi guys. I'm a UK Humanities student who got lucky during spring week applications and emerged with a few decent springs. I managed to convert two of these and have ended up with two very different conflicting internship offers. I'm kind of at my wit's end about which one I should choose and I really don't want to fumble. Please knock some sense into me.
BB Trading: this is at a BB that's very good for markets (JPM / GS) in London. The intern cohort will be much bigger and I'll definitely have lower chance of grad scheme conversion with how cutthroat getting ROs can be. I don't know what desk I'd be on and would have little input, although I did position myself as someone more interested in distressed credit so that might have some bearing. I don't have a massive maths background, I've never done trading before outside of a few sims, and I have no idea if I'd be good at it or terrible; the interviewers liked me but that's literally the only proof I have that I'd be non-awful. Having said that, it's a Big Bank and rejecting that name feels genuinely insane. I don't think I'll ever get another shot at trading with my humanities background, especially somewhere so well-known for it.
ER at very big (500bn+) LO AM, also London. Kind of the opposite story. I've already completed a mini-internship of sorts with the firm as a follow-up from the spring week so I know people from both the hiring and the research teams quite well. I know I'm decent at the role because I performed well in the mini-internship and was explicitly prioritised r.e. the summer. I'd be part of a much smaller cohort and would stand a very strong chance at converting. The firm itself has a great upwards pipeline into PM roles.
Both have similar comps (trading a little higher but the internship is shorter by a week and sign-on bonus is lower so it evens out).
I know I'd like ER, and I like the firm too. I don't know if I'd like trading. But I don't know if I'll ever get this chance to try it again, and the Big Bank is That Big Bank and I feel like a madman to turn them down. Maybe I'm just getting horribly prestige-dazzled?
I appreciate this is a bit of a lobster-buttery situation but the two are so different and I really, really don't want to fuck this up. Any advice as to what the better choice is would be so appreciated--I feel like I'm fumbling in the dark at the moment.
Choosing between these two offers boils down to your long-term career goals, risk tolerance, and how much weight you place on prestige versus fit. Here's a breakdown to help you decide:
BB Trading:
Pros:
Cons:
ER at Large LO AM:
Pros:
Cons:
Key Considerations:
Long-Term Goals: If you see yourself in a PM role or staying in the public markets, the ER role at the LO AM seems like a better fit. If you’re unsure or want to explore trading as a potential career path, the BB trading internship gives you that chance.
Risk vs. Certainty: The ER role offers more certainty in terms of conversion and alignment with your skills. The BB trading role is riskier but could be a once-in-a-lifetime opportunity to break into trading at a top firm.
Prestige vs. Fit: While the BB name is prestigious, don’t let it blind you if the role doesn’t align with your interests or strengths. Prestige matters, but so does finding a role where you can thrive and build a sustainable career.
Recommendation:
If you’re genuinely curious about trading and willing to take the risk of a lower conversion rate, the BB trading internship could be worth it for the experience and prestige. However, if you value stability, know you enjoy ER, and want a clear path to a PM role, the LO AM internship is the safer and more strategic choice.
Ultimately, it’s about balancing your curiosity and ambition with your long-term goals and risk tolerance. If you’re still torn, consider reaching out to mentors or alumni who’ve worked in both areas for additional perspective.
Sources: Being Black is Paradise, What offers would you take over a BB S&T?, https://www.wallstreetoasis.com/forum/investment-banking/qa-md-in-ma-and-capital-markets-with-bulge-bracket-and-boutique-experience?customgpt=1, https://www.wallstreetoasis.com/forum/equity-research/qa-er-analyst-at-top-bb-plus-about-er-general-advice?customgpt=1, Equity Research: Wall Street's Best Kept Secret
Try the Canary Wharfian website, most advice here is US focussed
Minus qui perspiciatis voluptatum voluptatem voluptatum earum voluptates. Praesentium exercitationem et error voluptas. Nam aut cumque aut aut qui nostrum quos ea. Aliquam dolores ut est consectetur consequatur cupiditate.
Rem consequatur unde quasi aliquid. Vero exercitationem in qui eum error. Ab tempora aut suscipit sit et et.
See All Comments - 100% Free
WSO depends on everyone being able to pitch in when they know something. Unlock with your email and get bonus: 6 financial modeling lessons free ($199 value)
or Unlock with your social account...