TDP vs S&T

Having trouble deciding between BP/Shell TDP (Chicago/Houston) and BB S&T in NYC. More interested in commodities than S&T, but all of my friends are going to NYC post-grad. 

Any and all advice appreciated. Thanks!

3 Comments
 

Choosing between BP/Shell's TDP (Trader Development Program) and BB S&T (Sales & Trading) in NYC depends on your long-term career goals and interests. Here's a breakdown based on the most helpful WSO content:

BP/Shell TDP (Chicago/Houston)

  1. Focus on Commodities: If you're more interested in commodities, TDP is the better choice. These programs are designed to immerse you in physical commodity trading, which involves understanding the logistics, operations, and risk management of physical assets like oil, gas, and power.

    • You'll learn how products flow, optimize assets, and manage risks, which are critical skills for physical trading.
    • Physical trading offers broader career optionality and a deeper learning experience compared to S&T.
  2. Career Optionality: Physical trading skills can transition into S&T roles later if desired, but the reverse is much harder. The TDP provides a strong foundation in physical commodities, which is a niche skill set with high demand.

  3. Location: While Chicago and Houston may not have the allure of NYC, they are hubs for energy and commodities trading. Networking and career growth opportunities in these cities are significant within the commodities space.

  4. Program Structure: The TDP typically involves rotations across different desks, giving you exposure to various aspects of the business. Networking during rotations is crucial to securing your desired role post-program.

BB S&T (NYC)

  1. Broader Exposure: S&T at a BB will expose you to a variety of asset classes, including equities, fixed income, FX, and commodities derivatives. However, commodities are often a smaller subset of the overall S&T business.

  2. Automation Risk: S&T roles, especially in equities and FX, are increasingly under pressure from automation. Commodities desks may be safer, but the industry as a whole is evolving rapidly.

  3. Exit Opportunities: S&T skills are more niche and may limit your ability to transition into other roles outside of trading. Additionally, post-2008, S&T has shifted more towards trade execution rather than proprietary trading, which may not align with your interest in commodities.

  4. Lifestyle and Prestige: NYC offers a vibrant lifestyle and the prestige of working at a BB, which might align with your social circle. However, the work-life balance in S&T can be demanding, and the long-term career stability is less certain compared to physical trading.

Key Considerations

  • Interest in Commodities: If commodities are your passion, TDP is the clear winner. It provides hands-on experience in physical trading, which is vastly different from the derivatives-focused trading in S&T.
  • Long-Term Goals: Physical trading offers more stability and career optionality, while S&T may provide a broader initial exposure but with higher risks of automation and niche skill development.
  • Social Influence: While your friends heading to NYC might make it tempting, prioritize your career interests and goals over peer pressure. Commodities trading is a specialized field, and starting in the right program (like TDP) can set you up for long-term success.

Final Advice

If you're serious about commodities and want to build a career in physical trading, go with BP/Shell's TDP. It aligns better with your interests and offers a more stable and rewarding career path in the long run. NYC and BB S&T might seem glamorous, but the TDP provides a unique opportunity to specialize in a high-demand field.

Sources: Is S&T still a good career path?, The Efficient Career Hypothesis: Almost All Jobs Are Priced In, Crude Oil trading at big oil exit opps, Advice for a 21-year-old entering BB S&T?, Commodities Trading - Tons of post that S&T is downsizing

I'm an AI bot trained on the most helpful WSO content across 17+ years.
 
Most Helpful

Both are good choices, but set you up differently. Firstly what desk is your S&T job in? Secondly, what are your main career goals- TDP is arguably the best programme to get into physical commodities trading in the world, but pay isn’t amazing for the first 3 years and the trader assessments pass rate varies year by year (some 20%, some over 60), so there is this to factor in as well. But there is no better pedigree if you want to be a phys trader and comp here, once you get a trading seat, is much more and has great exits to Vitol/Traf etc which needs no mentioning about their comp. For the S&T role, comp will outperform for the first few years, and dependent on desk, exits could be good to HFs etc where long term comp is aligned with merchants but cant really compare as a lot of what ifs go into both. TL:DR if commods is what you want choose TDP, if you just want to max comp and dont care about asset class too much and also want to have a good time with your mates in NYC then choose the BB S&T as long as its a good trading desk

 

Et maiores laborum incidunt tempora. Perferendis est suscipit molestiae ratione. Architecto iusto praesentium unde adipisci et commodi excepturi. Amet voluptatem aut praesentium dolorum.

Iste qui aut amet blanditiis ab eum rerum. Debitis quia in delectus architecto autem velit quisquam. Quidem optio quae qui doloribus consequatur magnam. Aut sit est soluta labore cumque est repellendus. Numquam tenetur est inventore soluta praesentium laudantium.

Dolorum quia dolores reiciendis. Suscipit fugiat voluptatum rerum autem esse. Sed et minus eum porro sit et. Repudiandae sint facere ut omnis molestiae.

Velit sed saepe vitae et quae ea enim magnam. Officia deleniti animi sint eaque fugit. Debitis ut et eum qui sed sit.

Career Advancement Opportunities

November 2026 Investment Banking

  • Evercore 01 99.5%
  • Moelis & Company 01 99.0%
  • JPMorgan 01 98.4%
  • Guggenheim Partners 02 97.9%
  • Morgan Stanley 06 97.4%

Overall Employee Satisfaction

November 2026 Investment Banking

  • Moelis & Company No 99.5%
  • Morgan Stanley 02 99.0%
  • Evercore 01 98.4%
  • Banco Santander 04 97.9%
  • BMO Capital Markets 13 97.4%

Professional Growth Opportunities

November 2026 Investment Banking

  • Evercore 01 99.5%
  • Moelis & Company 01 99.0%
  • Morgan Stanley 05 98.4%
  • Goldman Sachs 01 97.9%
  • JPMorgan No 97.4%

Total Avg Compensation

November 2026 Investment Banking

  • Vice President (17) $409
  • Associates (58) $261
  • 3rd+ Year Analyst (8) $210
  • 2nd Year Analyst (29) $183
  • Intern/Summer Associate (16) $161
  • 1st Year Analyst (84) $151
  • Intern/Summer Analyst (77) $101
notes
16 IB Interviews Notes

“... there’s no excuse to not take advantage of the resources out there available to you. Best value for your $ are the...”

Leaderboard

1
redever's picture
redever
99.2
2
kanon's picture
kanon
99.0
3
BankonBanking's picture
BankonBanking
99.0
4
Secyh62's picture
Secyh62
99.0
5
CompBanker's picture
CompBanker
98.9
6
GameTheory's picture
GameTheory
98.9
7
dosk17's picture
dosk17
98.9
8
DrApeman's picture
DrApeman
98.9
9
Betsy Massar's picture
Betsy Massar
98.9
10
Mimbs's picture
Mimbs
98.8
success
From 10 rejections to 1 dream investment banking internship

“... I believe it was the single biggest reason why I ended up with an offer...”