Goldman Sachs vs Cargill vs Noble Group
Goldman Sachs vs Cargill vs Noble Group
For entry level full time trader
Trending Content - Sales and Trading Forum
Career Resources
None hire you directly as a trader but cargill noble gs is my pick
Cargill
Monty, could you explain why you picked the companies in that order? I am assuming that the questions refers to commodity trading (maybe agricultural trading?) at all the three places. Would you choose commodity shops over banks all the time? If so, why?
Thanks for the answers!
do you want to learn the physical market or do you want to learn market making
assuming you are indiffrent between both
None hire you directly, all 3 trade physical and very much do the same thing. Somehow I am sensing you do not have all 3 offers...
I would work at Cargill or GS based on the people/product/desk, Noble would be my last choice.
Could you share more on why these three firms?
More info helps everyone give you better feedback
I don't believe Noble is big in U.S., it's based in Hong Kong isn't it?
Noble is huge in the us
Pretty vague question and to be honest without any details this question remind me of the threads of an overzealous sports or comic fans trying to compare one entity to something completely random (95 Nebraska vs Batman).
Short answer would be whoever has given you an offer.
If you are interested in soft/ag trading then Cargill hands down. Noble has lost talent to BTG Pactaul but still a good shop despite being cut-throat/slave shop. Not sure why GS is being mentioned--they trade everything beyond physical commodities (unlike the previous two) so it's like asking someone if they want sushi or a cruise ship buffet.
Noble has lost people to everyone in the past 6 months
Not sure why you wouldn't list Glencore.
Et ut sequi nihil veritatis. Ut pariatur tenetur sit nostrum velit dignissimos. Et officiis quam sint officia libero molestiae. Autem ut odio nam iusto ut. Voluptates ipsum quia ex eum repellat doloremque nulla.
Fuga sint consequatur voluptate incidunt odit. Quia quaerat nulla dolor ab molestias quia. Sed corrupti aut rerum mollitia et et a. Itaque ea voluptatem tempore laborum quod. Qui voluptas qui dolorem aut.
Rem soluta et omnis ratione magni. Ratione et doloremque quia dolorem officiis laborum. Est consequatur repudiandae harum aliquid cum sequi.
Culpa nostrum pariatur nobis. Officiis consequatur ducimus perferendis reprehenderit et officiis. Consequatur eos qui aut itaque provident. Quaerat voluptates nihil omnis aliquam quia voluptas laborum voluptate.
See All Comments - 100% Free
WSO depends on everyone being able to pitch in when they know something. Unlock with your email and get bonus: 6 financial modeling lessons free ($199 value)
or Unlock with your social account...