Offer help - Appreciate some help

Thanks for the feedback. People I have talked to seem to have very polarised views on this choice, which is interesting but a little confusing. Anyways here's why I'm currently leaning towards RBS:

1. RBS is very strong in London and in Europe for rates, HSBC is less dominant in any particular product area in London. Though it is strong in EM, I am working in London for the foreseeable future.
2. Although I haven't fully decided between structuring and trading yet, it shouldn't be difficult for me to switch to trading at RBS especially on a desk with so much flow. I have spoken to RBS structurers who have indeed traded their own products.
3. Though a rotational programme may provide me with insight into which product I prefer, there's no guarantee I'll end up somewhere I like, whereas I'll be happy with RBS rates.
4. I'd get responsibility quicker at RBS whereas at HSBC there may be a "lost year" in terms of career progression, though arguably it may be a worthwhile year to find out exactly what I want to do.

Tbh, I can't be making a bad decision going one way or the other, I'm thankful for the offers that I have, so I'm just happy to hear some views from other people, especially if they feel any one of the above points is just plain wrong.

Thanks