Currently in the process of interviewing at a place that trades both physical/paper in ags. How much of it involves global macro, geopolitics, and having a directional view you can put in trades? Or is it more relationships based and narrow focused on the industry?
| +53 | Commodities trader comp progression? | 26 | 11h |
| +19 | University for 17yo Intl. Student Breaking Into Quant/HF/S&T | 10 | 11h |
| +12 | How to improve at trade pitches | 2 | 20h |
| +10 | D | 2 | 3d |
| +9 | Asking for higher drawdown / VAR asks | 1 | 4d |
| +3 | Stifel FI Capital Markets | 1 | 20h |
| +1 | Math/CS woman aiming for trading at quant/technical desk? | 3 | 4d |
| +1 | Stats minor to s&t | 4 | 15h |
Career Resources
Get instant access to lessons taught by experienced private equity pros and bulge bracket investment bankers including financial statement modeling, DCF, M&A, LBO, Comps and Excel Modeling.
When it comes to trading physical commodities, especially in the agricultural sector, the role tends to be more relationship-based and narrowly focused on the industry. According to insights from top WSO threads, physical commodity trading often revolves around managing supplier and customer relationships, procurement, and understanding micro-level factors like local weather conditions, crop yields, and supply chain logistics. For example, traders rely heavily on data from agronomy teams, crop scouting, and procurement tours to make informed decisions.
However, global macro and geopolitics do play a role, particularly in paper trading and when assessing broader market trends. Factors like trade wars, import/export policies, and geopolitical tensions (e.g., US-China relations) can significantly impact commodity prices and trade flows. For instance, the trade war with China led to a shift in grain purchases from the US to Brazil, which had a direct impact on prices and trading strategies.
In summary: - Physical trading: Primarily relationship-driven and focused on micro-level industry specifics. - Paper trading: Involves more global macro, geopolitics, and directional views for trades.
Your role may depend on whether you're more involved in the physical or paper side of the business, but having a solid understanding of both micro and macro factors will undoubtedly be an asset.
Sources: Q&A: I'm an Agricultural Commodities Trader, Q&A: I'm an Agricultural Commodities Trader, 1st Year Macro HF Analyst: My Macro Framework, Global Macro's Future "Stars" - Where Are They Coming From?, A Contrarian View - Raging Bull
Qui molestiae rerum voluptas eligendi et incidunt. Dolores ratione aut quia. Labore consectetur esse et. Non dolorum similique voluptatum. Maxime quia nihil fugiat ea possimus magni voluptatum. Recusandae quis et dolor aliquam quia est. Rerum exercitationem minima at et non molestiae.
Corrupti itaque sint ut laboriosam. Et id similique autem non animi reiciendis quasi omnis. Nihil sint voluptatibus minus fugiat. Provident mollitia perspiciatis neque doloremque illo sint eveniet.
Dicta id mollitia iure iure nihil aut debitis sed. Dolor rerum et ipsam distinctio velit. Qui voluptatem necessitatibus molestias nihil voluptate mollitia. Quod vel voluptatibus architecto odit.
Rerum delectus sit ut magnam dolorem et. Sint veniam harum ut unde enim harum neque. Reiciendis facilis expedita commodi. Eos voluptatibus minima quidem ab voluptas. Autem et sed illo optio aperiam.
See All Comments - 100% Free
WSO depends on everyone being able to pitch in when they know something. Unlock with your email and get bonus: 6 financial modeling lessons free ($199 value)
or Unlock with your social account...