Sophomore at a target school interested in S&T / commodities — how should I approach recruiting?

I’m a sophomore at a target undergrad trying to figure out the best way to position myself for trading recruiting, particularly commodities/energy, although I’m also open to broader S&T roles.

For context, I spent this past summer in a research-oriented role where I worked on an energy/infrastructure-related project involving data analysis. That experience pushed me much more toward markets and energy than traditional IB. I’ve since been networking pretty aggressively with people at trading desks, energy firms, and a few physical commodities shops.

Right now I’m trying to figure out how I should prioritize the next 12–18 months:

* How heavily should I focus on BB S&T versus physical commodities shops, energy merchants, exchanges, utilities, etc.?
* For someone interested specifically in natural gas/power, how important is having a recognizable BB internship versus getting directly relevant experience at a smaller trading shop?
* What should I be doing technically right now beyond following markets? Python, statistics, commodity fundamentals, trade pitches, etc.?
* If I land a smaller commodities/trading internship for sophomore summer, does that put me in a strong position for junior-summer BB/HF recruiting?
* How much does sophomore-year networking actually matter for junior-summer S&T recruiting?
* For people actually on desks, what separates the sophomores who successfully break into trading from everyone else blasting out coffee-chat emails?

Long-term, I’m much more interested in actually trading than using S&T as a stepping stone to something else, so I’m trying to optimize for becoming good at the job rather than just maximizing brand name.

Would appreciate advice from anyone who has recruited for S&T, commodities, or energy trading recently.

280 WSO Academy Sales & Trading Session Reviews: 4.85/5

Class of '28 Aug 2026 Cohort

5.00/5

Sales & Trading Career Roadmap (optional)

“John listened before giving advice. I told him I had accepted an offer at Bank of America but was still interested in JLL and Wellington. Instead of telling me what to do, he asked what I wanted from my career and helped me think about which path would give me more options. I also liked that he was honest about what he knew and didn’t know. He gave me a clear reason to keep working toward JLL, while reminding me that Bank of America was still a good place to start. When I practiced my interview answer, he told me what worked and gave me one simple way to improve it. That made the feedback easy to use. Most of all, John made me feel less stressed about figuring everything out right now. He offered to help with a mock interview too, which meant a lot to me. ”

Class of '28 Apr 2026 Cohort

5.00/5

Sales & Trading Mock Interview

“The mentor provided extremely detailed and thoughtful feedback throughout our session. What I appreciated most was that the advice was not generic. He took the time to understand my background, past experiences, and the specific roles I am currently recruiting for, and then tailored his suggestions accordingly. He also connected many of his recommendations to his own professional background and experiences, which made the feedback much more practical and credible. Instead of simply telling me what to change, he explained why certain answers or approaches would be more effective and how an interviewer might interpret them. He also shared specific examples from his own experience to illustrate his points. I came away from the session with a much clearer understanding of both my strengths and the areas I should improve, as well as several concrete ways to strengthen my interview preparation. Overall, the session was extremely helpful, personalized, and actionable, and I would definitely work with him again.”

See All 11,117 WSO Academy Reviews

2 Comments

WSO Monkey Bot

O

1mo

To position yourself effectively for S&T and commodities trading, here’s a breakdown of how you should approach the next 12–18 months based on the most helpful WSO content:

1. Prioritizing BB S&T vs. Physical Commodities Shops

BB S&T: Offers broader exposure to markets, structured training, and a strong brand name. It’s a great option if you’re still exploring different asset classes or want a safety net for other finance roles.
Physical Commodities Shops/Energy Merchants: These are more niche but provide direct exposure to the commodities space. If you’re set on natural gas/power, these roles can give you highly relevant experience and a head start in understanding the fundamentals of the energy markets.
Recommendation: If you’re leaning toward commodities, prioritize internships at physical trading shops or energy firms for sophomore summer. For junior summer, you can leverage that experience to target BB S&T desks or hedge funds with a commodities focus.

2. Natural Gas/Power: BB Internship vs. Smaller Trading Shop

A BB internship is valuable for its prestige and networking opportunities, but smaller trading shops often provide hands-on experience that’s directly applicable to commodities trading.
Key Insight: For natural gas/power, direct experience at a smaller shop can be more impactful than a generalist BB S&T internship. However, if you aim to transition to a hedge fund or BB later, having a recognizable name on your resume can help.

3. Technical Skills to Develop

Python: Essential for data analysis, backtesting strategies, and automating tasks.
Statistics: Focus on probability, regression analysis, and time-series modeling, as these are critical for understanding market trends and pricing.
Commodity Fundamentals: Study supply/demand dynamics, storage, transportation, and seasonality for natural gas/power.
Trade Pitches: Practice creating concise, actionable trade ideas. This will help you stand out in interviews and networking conversations.
Market Tracking: Follow energy markets daily, understand price drivers, and build a habit of forming your own market views.

4. Sophomore Summer Internship Impact

A smaller commodities/trading internship can position you well for junior-summer recruiting, especially if you gain relevant skills and can articulate your experience effectively.
Tip: Use your sophomore internship to build a narrative around your passion for trading and your ability to contribute to a desk.

5. Networking for Junior-Summer Recruiting

Networking during sophomore year is crucial. Building relationships early can give you an edge when junior-summer recruiting kicks off.
Focus Areas:
- Target alumni and professionals on trading desks or in commodities roles.
- Be specific in your outreach—mention your interest in natural gas/power and ask for advice on breaking into the space.
- Follow up consistently and share updates on your progress.

6. What Separates Successful Candidates

Market Knowledge: Sophomores who can discuss markets intelligently and present trade ideas stand out.
Technical Skills: Proficiency in Python, Excel, and basic modeling is a differentiator.
Networking Strategy: Successful candidates build genuine relationships rather than sending generic emails.
Passion for Trading: Demonstrating a clear interest in markets and a willingness to learn is key.

Long-Term Optimization

Focus on roles that allow you to develop trading skills early. Whether it’s a BB or a smaller shop, prioritize opportunities where you can learn about risk management, market-making, and strategy development.
Keep refining your technical skills and market knowledge to position yourself as a strong candidate for trading roles post-graduation.

By aligning your efforts with these priorities, you’ll maximize your chances of breaking into S&T or commodities trading and setting yourself up for long-term success.

Sources: Advice for a 21-year-old entering BB S&T?, Commodities Trading - Tons of post that S&T is downsizing, Conversation with an Equities Sales Trader, Crude Oil trading at big oil exit opps, Navigating The Floor: A S&T Analyst's Guide

Reply

Quote

Report

Other

I'm an AI bot trained on the most helpful WSO content across 17+ years.

ratemyswap

ST

1mo

Blanditiis non cum ex quis. Nam sed quidem et. Quis odio quo assumenda vero quisquam voluptatem qui. Nihil et velit molestiae eos.

Magni accusantium ab non sed. Occaecati minus et expedita explicabo. Natus aut perferendis non magni.

Tempora exercitationem asperiores voluptatem cumque est quod ut. Quis laboriosam ea eos ratione. Est eveniet autem possimus facere similique.

Dolorem occaecati id illo dolorem laboriosam accusantium. Dolores eos quibusdam dolores explicabo reiciendis consequuntur architecto. Repellendus temporibus iusto aperiam nesciunt ea. Autem eos dolorem optio.