is it true that BB PWM >> no-name IBD/HF/other FO role for SA recruiting?

I keep hearing conflicting views about BB PWM internships.... is it true that BB PWM on resume >> no-name HF/IBD/other front office role?? (for SA recruiting)...

i had the chance to do BB PWM in soph year too, but I turned it down to work at a no-name HF (albeit $2B+ AUM) because the work I did there and what I learnt were way more meaningful than what I would have learnt in BB PWM...I did this because some upperclassmen said BB PWM is not respected, and everyone knows its BS, but on the other hand, i hear that all that matters is the brand name of the BB, eventhough all u did is get coffee and cold call....and every time i heard this i feel that I made a mistake not doing PWM

 

I feel like it does help to have a BB pwm internship. That's probably the route a lot of people take. But if you have legit stuff about your HF with decent GPA etc and good networking, you'll get noticed no prob.

 

I was faced with the same dilemma and ended up going the no-name IB route...so glad i did, def learned 100x more than I could've at the BB pwm where i even had a ft position lined up. BB name is just an eye catcher, it's what you actually do at your internship/job that actually matters.

 

To answer your question...

It pulls weight in 2 cases. Here you go:

PWM carries weight for non-IB front office jobs (BB S&T, PWM, etc.) or intra-firm (same firm sophomore and junior summers). Otherwise, it doesn't.

For example, if you do Morgan Stanley PWM sophomore summer in order to get GS IB Junior summer, it won't help you at all. A wasted summer - you should've done what you did, get no-name IB experience. You made the smart move. If you do MS PWM for GS S&T, that could work. I've had friends successfully pull that off.

However if you do Goldman PWM to get Goldman IB the next year, that's a smart move. You can network within the company easily, you know people, and the people you'll network with will know people too, and they might be able to pull some weight when intern-recruiting and later offer season comes around. I have one friend who's working there now because of this.

 
gGeck0:
To answer your question...

It pulls weight in 2 cases. Here you go:

PWM carries weight for non-IB front office jobs (BB S&T, PWM, etc.) or intra-firm (same firm sophomore and junior summers). Otherwise, it doesn't.

For example, if you do Morgan Stanley PWM sophomore summer in order to get GS IB Junior summer, it won't help you at all. A wasted summer - you should've done what you did, get no-name IB experience. You made the smart move. If you do MS PWM for GS S&T, that could work. I've had friends successfully pull that off.

However if you do Goldman PWM to get Goldman IB the next year, that's a smart move. You can network within the company easily, you know people, and the people you'll network with will know people too, and they might be able to pull some weight when intern-recruiting and later offer season comes around. I have one friend who's working there now because of this.

Shit I wonder if this happens often... thanks for the post though. It's interesting to hear that PWM could lead to S&T

 

Sorry to hijack, though this is related to the PWM>S&T idea.

For S&T (specifically T), would BB PWM be better, or trading at a HF/anything FO of a quantitative nature (quant developer/programmer, actuary, maybe engineering, etc.)? Also, how would boutique IB compare to the HF/quant FO stuff?

I'm guessing PWM is great for getting into S, but only useful for T if you network/leverage contacts intra-firm. Trading at a HF should be the best experience, though the HF name/size probably matters too. I'm guessing if the trading experience has enough modeling, it would be better than boutique IB. However, I'm not sure whether boutique IB would be better or FO quant. I'm wondering specifically for an actuarial internship, since I did one at a large life insurer this summer as a rising soph. Would my actuarial internship carry any weight given its mathematical nature, or none because it's not finance? (Is the latter still a problem if I demonstrate interest by being a finance major+part of finance clubs?) I'm also trying to find a school-year internship, and am aiming for either a small quant HF, a small non-quant HF, boutique IB (if I can even get it), or possibly even PWM (if it would be useful). How do these compare?

(So my path would be as follows, where ? can be filled in with anything, and BB S&T junior summer is the goal. This is also complicated by the fact that I'm a Canadian on F-1 and have limited OPT hours for paid employment, which I would probably only use for summers) (1st year summer actuarial->2 fall/spring ?->2 summer ?->(resume for 3 summer recruiting handed in)->3 fall/spring?-> [[[3 BB S&T]]] goal)

What about for non-FO quantitative jobs (probably MO risk, I'm guessing BO IT won't be much help)?

 

i think it depends on what you are doing at either, and the people you are likely to meet while working there. what you are basically asking is "is name brand better than work experience"

at the end of the day, do you want to be working for someone who values the name of a firm that an individual worked for more than the experience that that person had at the firm?

looking for that pick-me-up to power through an all-nighter?
 

Depends... if you're working at a regional branch doing PWM, it might not be that great, but if you get in a top PWM Group in a central office, you're superiors are bound to know some bankers. If you impress them enough, they should be willing to go to bat to keep you at the firm. Keeping that in mind, I was the top intern in a BB financial services group (non private wealth) and my bosses were unable to get me a spot in the banking class. This could be due to the fact that they did not start making calls for me until recruiting was completed, or because I turned down an offer for their group. Nevertheless, if you don't have many choices, take a PWM internship. Make the most of your time, and leverage the firm and experience to get into banking the following summer.

 

i actually did that exact same thing. the summer after sophomore year, interned at merrill lynch PWM (before it was acquired by BofA). next summer came (last year) and because of the shitty economy, couldnt land an IBD internship (got a great one regardless at a major corporation). then used those experiences to land a full time job in banking. firms arent necessarily looking for IBD experiences (tho that is nice); theyre looking for any valuable experience you can talk about and relate the skillset over to banking. PWM sophomore year is a good way to not only show interest in the financial markets, but it gives you something to talk about in interviews. not to mention, it can greatly broaden your network (for example, while i was at merrill i occasionally met with fund wholesellers, some of whom ASKED for me to send then my resume.. great connections!).

i guess in conclusion, for a sophomore year internship, this is definitely a good thing to have.

 

Yeah, I second that. It might not be ideal, but you are absolutely going to want to have some solid internship experience. Look at it as a chance to network and meet people within a firm that you might be interested in working, albeit in a different function (ideally).

 

I was in your same situation my sophmore summer.

Honestly, just the name of the BB that you're currently working at will help you get your foot in the door for next summer's recruiting. Any work you can do using Excel would be helpful - the more you know the better you will look next summer when you're on the job. I also made sure I networked well at the BB I was currently working for. Those networking contacts will help you get a job at the current BB next summer. Even if you don't want the job at the same BB next summer, you will be better able to get it, and use it to help you should your target firm be on the fence come offer time.

Basically, network as best you can and try to pick up the skills of the trade (excel and modeling, although if you're aiming for S&T, modeling is not essential). Pick a target firm or two for next year, and make contacts/network with their executives/analysts/whoever. The earlier you start, the better.

 
quag_mire:
i hear that all that matters is the brand name of the BB, eventhough all u did is get coffee and cold call...so apparently that mean BB PWM on resume >> no-name HF/IBD/other front office role (for SA recruiting)...

Who the hell cold calls during a PWM internship? If you show in the first few days you're reliable, they'll give you some decent projects.

 

PWM, even within the BBs vary widely. My family is a client with a number of the different formerly elite firms, so I can give a decent explanation of what I have seen. Some offices are very much connected to the home base(may be located in or nearby an actual IB office), they tend to deal with bank employees' money. i.e. they will handle accounts of associates, VPs, MDs. Depending on the bank and department, you will need to have your PA through the bank's brokerage for monitoring purposes. When I was working at Bear and Scotia, that was the case, not so at my current employer. Depending on the account holder's knowledge, the FA will function as anything from a trade executor to a full service adviser encompassing asset allocation, fund recommendations, etc. These also serve to help place employees in internal funds (bank-owned HF and PE). These offices will also deal with select other client, usually HNW and UHNW. Then there are what is called a "regional office" on this site. This is not necessarily in the middle of nowhere, plenty exist in NYC especially for MER, UBS, and Smith Barney. These really range from legit full service offices that cater to the HNW and UHNW including financial planning. They use legit asset allocation techniques and financial analyses to help their clients achieve superior returns. The experience one can gain at one of these offices is legit, and many former bankers and traders end up in these types of positions. A third type of office serves the middle class. These offices are in the suburbs, retail bank branches, etc. They also use the MER, UBS, and Smith Barney name, but they tend to use less sophisticated techniques, because there is less upside to doing well for the client (other than keeping the client to churn the account). These offices are really a volume business as they make money mostly on commissions, and they tend to hire lots of interns and other unqualified people to cold call mom and pop to sell a specific mutual fund, or to try to setup an initial meeting. There is little to actually be learned in this type of an office which is relevant to "high finance", and it is unlikely you will make any connections to further that goal. However, if you are a freshman or sophomore, you will impress your friends (whatever that's worth), and it will show initiative that you were at least thinking about finance while your friends were not. To conclude, not all BB offices are created equally. Some shit on all PWM, those people don't know what they're talking about. The real PWM offices are extremely profitable and lucrative to the lead advisers there.

Career Advancement Opportunities

April 2024 Investment Banking

  • Jefferies & Company 02 99.4%
  • Goldman Sachs 19 98.8%
  • Harris Williams & Co. New 98.3%
  • Lazard Freres 02 97.7%
  • JPMorgan Chase 03 97.1%

Overall Employee Satisfaction

April 2024 Investment Banking

  • Harris Williams & Co. 18 99.4%
  • JPMorgan Chase 10 98.8%
  • Lazard Freres 05 98.3%
  • Morgan Stanley 07 97.7%
  • William Blair 03 97.1%

Professional Growth Opportunities

April 2024 Investment Banking

  • Lazard Freres 01 99.4%
  • Jefferies & Company 02 98.8%
  • Goldman Sachs 17 98.3%
  • Moelis & Company 07 97.7%
  • JPMorgan Chase 05 97.1%

Total Avg Compensation

April 2024 Investment Banking

  • Director/MD (5) $648
  • Vice President (19) $385
  • Associates (86) $261
  • 3rd+ Year Analyst (13) $181
  • Intern/Summer Associate (33) $170
  • 2nd Year Analyst (66) $168
  • 1st Year Analyst (205) $159
  • Intern/Summer Analyst (145) $101
notes
16 IB Interviews Notes

“... there’s no excuse to not take advantage of the resources out there available to you. Best value for your $ are the...”

Leaderboard

success
From 10 rejections to 1 dream investment banking internship

“... I believe it was the single biggest reason why I ended up with an offer...”