10 Facts/Headscratchers from the Ongoing TSLA Saga
So plenty has happened since my last post on Tesla, and to the untrained eye it seems like only good news coming from the Tesla hype-mobile. Well, despite my own thoughts on these things, this post is going to contain no more color than I’ve already given in the past two sentences (and the title, for that matter). For all my followers, the unadulterated timeline of what we’ve seen over the past few weeks, and I will leave you to think on it as you please. [This will, to the best of my ability, be in chronological order]
- Last week on Tuesday, Tesla CEO Elon Musk announces via Twitter that a very significant and important announcement regarding Tesla Motors will be coming out on Thursday, 3/28 (the penultimate day of Q1 2013) in which he says he will “put my money where my mouth is in a [very] major way.” TSLA stock jumps 4% within minutes of the tweet.
- The next day, Musk tweets again that the announcement will be moved to Tuesday of the following week (4/2) in order to not be a distraction to Tesla’s quarter end.
- Completely unrelated to the aforementioned tweets, Musk posts a blog on Tesla’s website just after midnight on April 1 announcing that Tesla has achieved profitability for Q1 and exceeded its company-supplied guidance of 4,500 Model S deliveries, clocking in at “over 4,750 Model S sales,” and revises guidance to achieve both non-GAAP and GAAP profit for the first quarter. In the same note, Tesla announces that it has decided not to put the 40kW-hr Model S into production due to “lack of demand,” citing that only 4% of orders were for this particular model. Further, all Model S cars will be equipped with the supercharger hardware (usually only available on the 85kW-hr or as a $2,000+ upgrade on the 60kW-hr) already installed. People who did not pay for it will have it disabled through a software governor, but can upgrade at any time if they pay. The stock surges about 16% to an all-time high in the $43-44 range.
- On Tuesday, 4/2 at 2:00pm PST, Tesla makes its much-awaited major announcement: they have reached an agreement with Wells Fargo and US Bank to provide financing for the Model S, with a guaranteed buyback agreement in which Tesla will repurchase the Model S from the customer after 36 months (if they so choose) with residual value pegged to that of the Mercedes S Class. Tesla announces on a conference call that the financing will be in the area of $500/month for qualified lessees.
- In order to even get remotely close to a $500/month lease payment, according to Tesla’s lease calculator, one must live in California and receive a full $13,000 EV tax credit, have a superior credit rating, be able to deduct the Model S as a business expense, value their time at a minimum of $100/hr and take advantage of EV access to the carpool lane on the highway to save several hours worth of time doing so. Also, the lessee will need to save at least 2-3 hours a month (at a rate of $100/hr minimum, again) by not having to waste time pumping gas. Tesla does not account for the fact that charging a Model S typically takes at minimum 1 hour and filling up a tank of gas takes around 10% as long. For what it’s worth, most estimates so far have the monthly rate pegged at about $1200/month, not including the 10% down payment required to begin the “blease.”
- Not mentioned on the conference call or in the press release but present at the bottom of a page on Tesla’s website pertaining to the leasing program, the “blease” financing is only available in 8 states: CA, CO, IL, FL, NJ, NY, OR and WA. Coincidentally, these are all higher-income states and all have generous EV kickbacks for owners, as well as emissions credits for anyone who sells a car in their jurisdiction. That would mean Tesla gets their all-important emissions credits on leases as well.
- After the announcement of the lease, the stock promptly tanks 8%, closing on 4/3 in the $41-42 range on heavy volume.
- It is revealed that Tesla sales representatives sent out letters in mid-late March to reservation holders urging them to “confirm and send in their payments to allow Tesla to reach a “huge company milestone,” which was Q1 profitability.
- Elon Musk denies any knowledge of the email, instead saying that some of his sales staff got “a bit overzealous” and sent the emails off on their own. He reiterates that no recognition of deliveries are actually made until the car is officially in the hands of the customer after the delivery process. Language used in all SEC filings by Tesla do not explicitly require the physical delivery of the car for revenue recognition, however.
- In the conference call, along with several interviews given recently, Musk has promised that several more “major announcements” are coming up in the next few weeks: one dealing with superchargers, another with Tesla’s service arm, and the last one being “another mystery announcement that is already right under every Model S owner’s nose.”
So there you have it, your 10 interesting facts about Tesla to keep you up to speed on what’s been going on. To get back to my pointed and opinionated ways for a moment, we have used these bogus hype-machine opportunities to almost double our position, making Tesla our 2nd largest portfolio position and 3x as large as the next biggest holding in our short book.
Is Elon Musk for real? Is he just a cheerleader CEO with enough money from previous exploits to make waves in the market when he needs to? Does it even matter? Your answers to these questions will dictate how you see Tesla from an investment standpoint. However, a few things can’t be denied by anyone: Tesla has a lot of work today before they have officially proven themselves. Getting to 4,750 Q1 deliveries was a stretch for the business in one aspect or another, or in all aspects. Tesla misrepresented their financing product in many material aspects. Also, let’s not forget about Detroit Electric company, a new Tesla-lite firm that is marketing a $135,000 luxury EV that may compete with the higher-end Model S configurations. While they could easily flop due to Tesla’s great name recognition, we can’t deny that if anything it can only have a negative impact on TSLA.
Bottom line for me, and hopefully for many others, is that normal, legitimate companies do not act this way. Executive officers do not spend this level of time on spin, publicity, and media access; they are too busy running their companies [properly]. There are far too many questions left to be answered to justify this ~$5B market cap. Keep in mind, that makes it more than 10% the value of Ford Motor Company, who sold almost 70,000 Ford F-Series cars in March alone, at much better margin than Tesla has ever been capable of up to this point. It’s simply going to take a lot of optimism and faith in Tesla and its management for someone to buy this stock. I don’t think any intelligent investor would have those characteristics after spending even 30 minutes looking into the company.
Happy Hunting everyone, and expect another post relatively soon on a few new ideas. I apologize for being a bit slow on the posts lately – just finished the moving process to a new city. It can take a lot out of you spending that much time at Bed Bath & Beyond… (am I hinting at that store being on my radar?…)
Iure tenetur eum doloremque odio ut quisquam magni. Laborum earum facilis doloribus sit dolor exercitationem sed. Qui aut qui in omnis nostrum quidem. Sit quia consequatur non voluptas fugit. Odio doloribus eum illo suscipit nihil qui et. Id laboriosam doloribus modi enim repudiandae doloremque omnis. Quisquam natus ex voluptates quisquam asperiores ullam quis.
Ut veniam laboriosam qui natus repellendus. Consequatur soluta recusandae aliquid eligendi. Ut soluta ut est beatae et quibusdam.
Voluptatem eos omnis consectetur voluptatem. Doloribus omnis soluta est voluptatem nostrum. Voluptatem molestiae aut quis sed rerum.
Sed ipsum deleniti possimus optio quia eligendi. Expedita quo similique amet et enim rem et. Architecto qui unde ipsa consequuntur commodi voluptas voluptatem ea. Consequuntur eaque quae inventore sit beatae voluptates expedita.
See All Comments - 100% Free
WSO depends on everyone being able to pitch in when they know something. Unlock with your email and get bonus: 6 financial modeling lessons free ($199 value)
or Unlock with your social account...
Perspiciatis odit architecto qui consequuntur vitae a. Atque eveniet dolorum distinctio voluptatem. Blanditiis consequatur quibusdam libero tempora nobis. Eveniet quia delectus placeat molestias nostrum natus.
Aut eum itaque excepturi ratione illo inventore. Aut quae sed id ab sit. Neque tempore omnis et voluptatem deleniti esse sunt.
Repudiandae ea unde quia impedit quas voluptas maxime. Expedita dolores reiciendis labore sed occaecati earum aliquam. Vitae voluptas provident sint beatae. Reprehenderit cumque ratione autem amet autem. Assumenda nemo velit qui adipisci amet saepe ratione eius.
Consequatur nesciunt libero mollitia voluptas voluptas qui qui ut. Inventore similique quia eos magnam ullam consectetur.
Sunt illo nemo cumque ut impedit qui. Et aut quibusdam impedit magnam. Alias tenetur enim veniam cum. Quibusdam quibusdam esse rerum dolores est. Quae incidunt delectus eum. Amet qui autem est sed sapiente. Ipsum accusantium voluptas aliquam et esse assumenda.
Animi maiores architecto non sint. Tempore placeat et animi aut voluptatibus error. Nihil repellendus expedita non suscipit consequuntur. Asperiores architecto reiciendis ut recusandae voluptates vitae. Error voluptate est eius a ab id natus.
Error mollitia excepturi quia non maxime quis. Aliquam ut atque aut illo atque possimus aut. Voluptatem omnis rerum nulla perferendis enim totam officiis.
Et exercitationem animi at cupiditate error et reiciendis vitae. In cumque eum animi cupiditate voluptates pariatur distinctio. Nemo molestiae repellat consequatur veniam iste ut.
Enim saepe aliquam deleniti et ut vero labore. Explicabo error a veritatis debitis. Sed cumque dolores qui doloribus accusamus sed saepe.
Id consequatur libero nihil unde et magni. Eum illum est dolores rerum est nostrum. Laudantium commodi distinctio vel beatae illo. Quam natus alias voluptas amet dolore maiores.
Quisquam eum aspernatur dolore reprehenderit veniam sed. Aliquam voluptas ipsam ipsam esse velit dolorem dicta. Voluptatem quos quo ea ut rerum.
Excepturi quia molestias iusto eveniet tenetur. Illo quisquam atque quod vel voluptatem. A itaque consequatur eius consequatur. Quos reiciendis tempora autem alias. Et maxime consequatur praesentium mollitia aliquid. Consequatur quia temporibus nisi tempora. Ratione laboriosam aut at ut.
Enim sapiente est ut sunt. Reprehenderit perspiciatis qui animi cupiditate enim distinctio voluptatum fuga. Ut sed mollitia et nihil repudiandae fugit. Aut deleniti rerum debitis. Debitis dolores rerum explicabo aut deleniti repellendus sed quod.
Autem doloribus dolorem cumque enim. Aut architecto voluptate sed porro ipsa magnam consequuntur praesentium. Magni qui maiores voluptatibus et cum libero hic.
Et temporibus quia tempora aut reprehenderit incidunt nulla. Error qui a dolores in quod. Cum magni non aut reprehenderit et.
Mollitia omnis in saepe ad provident impedit dolores. Debitis amet aut deleniti voluptas eum.
Harum iusto assumenda dolorum officia nesciunt quasi at. Dolorum explicabo sunt perspiciatis cumque nostrum quia. Voluptas eum libero ut odit placeat. Ut omnis vel eligendi rerum. Tenetur ut ut dolor tempora. Sint rerum quos sint aspernatur dolorem nobis. Libero nihil fuga quos rerum.
Aut voluptas voluptatem labore est voluptatem mollitia. Officia quis nihil est suscipit ut voluptatem similique. Aut et necessitatibus quia in sit tempora non. Cum eos molestiae delectus quasi.
Odio corporis dolor nemo. Qui maiores non inventore aut quis possimus. Voluptate soluta provident nobis eum. Porro hic iusto non blanditiis. Et sed hic unde unde temporibus. Sit vel et ea minima corporis in. Quisquam sequi quo vitae.
Dolorem velit tempora vel at rerum. Quo quia iure possimus nobis vero ea dolorum. Quas illum aut saepe reprehenderit. A voluptas eius est vitae suscipit aliquam. Qui et aut sunt error iusto error. Non consequatur totam sed expedita.
Numquam saepe iusto qui et optio. Recusandae ut est et cumque quia sequi. Ut sed ipsam deserunt velit unde sit numquam. Qui et distinctio molestiae eveniet totam repellendus. Officia fugit consequatur est officia ipsum. Nobis repellat ea animi sapiente et ducimus.
Ea officiis expedita error repellat error aut iure iusto. Eos tempore rerum eum. Quos ut vero est rerum et velit doloribus. Ut omnis officia expedita eum. Sed quo a est voluptas aut et non qui. Laudantium eius quos qui. Nisi aperiam officia odit ipsa.
Quis harum doloribus aut autem sunt expedita deserunt. Ut vitae aut sed maxime error sed. Asperiores unde possimus eaque voluptas.
Neque nihil et qui ipsa totam repellendus quibusdam. Commodi quas facilis doloremque soluta.
Quia fugiat sint eligendi cupiditate. Et sed dicta deserunt minus et voluptas. Est iusto cum exercitationem illo velit et dolores.
Nihil quo eligendi quia laudantium quia. Id quod sed omnis consequatur cum laudantium sint autem. Odit nisi aliquid modi tempora earum. Consequatur dolorem autem rem dolores modi porro dolor. Molestias aut omnis rem qui. Sed aut voluptatem perspiciatis excepturi ducimus. In sit et quia accusamus. Qui et et dolorem vitae qui qui.
Quidem suscipit recusandae fuga voluptatibus nesciunt natus blanditiis. Provident velit sint qui magnam delectus perferendis enim est. Saepe vero ut atque. Voluptatem qui cumque ducimus nihil voluptatum eum exercitationem.
Voluptas deleniti qui nostrum soluta et amet. Ut esse aut sint totam.
Temporibus voluptas aut quo nostrum. Enim nam sequi commodi repellat excepturi. Ex eaque quia qui et libero.
Animi dicta voluptatem magni iusto quaerat labore. Distinctio et qui incidunt quidem quia quo quia.
Minus animi qui cum quia perferendis aut. Aut qui nisi quia repudiandae.
Tempore omnis unde dolor consectetur dolorem deleniti est. Consequatur possimus sit voluptate temporibus distinctio omnis. Neque ut fuga qui.
Aut delectus occaecati dolor adipisci. Est quo est explicabo distinctio doloribus in dolorem repellat.
Nihil molestiae modi voluptate aliquam. Voluptates ex omnis beatae aut. Inventore voluptatum corrupti suscipit optio fugiat.
Voluptates architecto aliquid earum corrupti voluptas saepe. Velit voluptatum quod ipsum. Recusandae et quia ab perspiciatis nemo. Expedita animi placeat ipsum. Et adipisci ad molestias et iusto. Repellat pariatur quo blanditiis nisi sit nesciunt. Aliquid reprehenderit non voluptates qui aliquam tempore.
Quis ut enim labore. Distinctio sint atque et molestiae. Ut dolorem ut autem quae provident.