If you're a frequent YouTube user you've no doubt seen, or at least heard about, the new commenting structure imposed by Google last week. You may even be a part of the small but vocal group of YouTube users who are really pissed off about it. In a nutshell, from now on you'll have to use your real name when leaving a comment on a YouTube video. There are a couple ways around it, but that's basically the deal from here on out. On top of that, YouTube comments are now driven exclusively through Google+.
At first blush this appears to be a ham-fisted attempt to force people to use Google+, but if you think that's the reason they did it, I'm here to tell you that you're wrong. The fact is that Google has been embarked on a very determined path to eliminate anonymity across their many channels for a number of years now. Up to this point, it's been all carrot: reveal your true identity in the content you create, and we'll give you a higher ranking in Google search results. But now it's veering toward the stick: use your real identity to leave comments on YouTube videos, or don't comment at all.
I honestly didn't even notice when this happened. I was an early adopter of Google+, so I've been doing things this way for two years now and the new policy didn't affect me. But when my inbox started filling up with outraged emails (I guess I'm viewed as a sort of G+ cheerleader and am therefore a reasonable target for righteous indignation) I decided to look into it to see if there was anything people should be upset about. Turns out there is.
Anonymity is one of the cornerstones of the Internet. Wall Street Oasis couldn't even exist (at least not in its present form) without it. Anonymity is crucial to our success as a community here. But there's a real downside to anonymity, too.
Anyone who has spent more than five minutes reading the YouTube comments section knows that it's a complete sewer. Some of the most vile hate speech I've ever seen is par for the course over there. It's so bad that more and more you see videos posted with comments disabled altogether, which is kind of a shame because discussion and collaboration are a couple of the biggest benefits of the Internet on the whole. But it was clear Google had to do something. Their answer was a pretty clever blend of capitalism and social engineering.
By forcing users to comment with their true identities, hate speech and those who traffic in it can be marginalized. Google went even further by enabling a feature that ranks comments based on their quality, so the best comments rise to the top. This has people's panites in a bunch as well, because your average YouTube idiot realizes he's never written anything of any quality and therefore his voice will be squelched entirely from now on.
YouTube trolls aren't the only ones upset about this change, however. The good folks who have managed to keep Google+ one of the Internet's best kept secrets are none too pleased as well. It's as if Google has flung open the gates to the Internet Huns, and now G+ (which is where you go for intelligent content curation) is about to be besieged on all sides. None other than the Fuhrer himself explains that side of the coin:
So basically no one is happy about the change, but here's what you need to realize: Google is not a utility. It's a private advertising company. Everything they do (and they do so many things better than anyone else ever has) is designed to sell advertising. Their advertising is far more effective if they're able to target actual people. And I'm not even talking about you. I'm talking about your friends. How much more effective is a Google ad in your buddy's inbox if it's accompanied by your face and the fact that you bought that product as well? That's what this is all about, and it has the ancillary benefit of cleaning up the cesspool that YouTube has become.
However, I believe WSO has the better model. Obviously we're not dealing with anywhere near the volume that Google is, but this site has struck a balance where we're able to offer total anonymity and a great user experience. I have to say Patrick was way ahead of the curve when he introduced Monkey Shit and Silver Bananas years before anyone else thought of it.
WSO wouldn't work if it weren't for anonymity. I remember back in 2008 this was one of the few places you could go to get the straight scoop on what was happening inside the banks during the crisis, and we never would have had that if users had to use their real names. The company database would have never been a reality, the compensation reports would have been blank, and we wouldn't have anywhere near the volume of helpful content that we have today.
Do we get the occasional troll? Of course we do. But even on that front, we're better than the Internet as a whole. At least our trolls are clever for the most part. The ban hammer eventually falls on all of them, but not before they've given us a few laughs.
Mark my words: this is going to become a big issue on the Internet over the next decade. Anonymity is something worth fighting for. I'm a huge proponent of free speech, even when it's despicable hate speech. In that case, however, I think you should be man enough to own up to what you said. But I'm not in favor of forcing people to do that.
What do you guys think? Is the accountability gained by forcing everyone to go public worth all the benefits of anonymity that we'd lose? Is using your real identity the wave of the future on the web? Can you even imagine what WSO would look like today if we forced people to use their real names?
I'll leave you with this charming (NSFW) video response to the G+ YouTube integration by a chick who clearly doesn't get that YouTube isn't hers, it's Google's:
Ex et numquam velit tempora quibusdam. Quo est sed et porro ut libero accusamus consequatur. Saepe pariatur id quidem vel minima et et. Debitis molestiae voluptatem necessitatibus quos omnis rerum.
See All Comments - 100% Free
WSO depends on everyone being able to pitch in when they know something. Unlock with your email and get bonus: 6 financial modeling lessons free ($199 value)
or Unlock with your social account...
Itaque voluptatum similique officiis. Sed earum nesciunt et.
Earum aspernatur laudantium ut. Vel quo voluptate sit ut doloribus inventore ut. Enim aut aut magnam voluptatum rerum ut laudantium.
Beatae quia ea debitis dignissimos. Doloremque quis natus qui quis necessitatibus dicta et.
Sit debitis quam quia eum voluptatum aut ex. Alias praesentium animi autem mollitia repellendus est. Qui qui quas non provident voluptatum soluta ab. Consequatur ea neque doloremque soluta unde itaque inventore reiciendis. Repellendus ut dolores debitis expedita nisi similique. Enim ex dignissimos mollitia. Autem quos qui rerum commodi nostrum eum id.
Tempore id illo voluptatem in blanditiis numquam. Ut omnis ipsam non in eaque. Molestiae qui ullam vel est omnis in reprehenderit iusto. Optio consequatur alias tenetur. Et est aliquam voluptas facere facilis et asperiores. Est repudiandae veniam dolores eius perspiciatis aperiam qui est. Explicabo voluptas accusamus pariatur nesciunt qui itaque ut. Laboriosam iure quasi sit minus tempore ea nisi et.
Ut et dolore ad nihil rerum aut possimus. Doloribus aut nihil ea animi ipsa amet. Architecto voluptatem iste et nisi. Veniam officiis eum eos sint deserunt provident.
Qui molestias dolores qui ad sunt voluptatem eaque deserunt. Aut voluptas quia ea ut neque voluptates. Incidunt inventore numquam consectetur quis maxime. Nihil odit qui voluptas ipsam et. Quia pariatur consectetur laboriosam aut libero quibusdam dolores.
Rerum vitae exercitationem non voluptatem totam. Reiciendis quisquam ex fugiat soluta voluptas ipsam. Cupiditate aut ullam iure harum et.
Possimus et temporibus omnis labore est molestias voluptas. Veniam voluptatem tenetur pariatur amet adipisci iste nam. Fuga unde numquam nulla excepturi blanditiis omnis ea ut. Accusantium perspiciatis eum et magni. Quas nihil eligendi neque qui beatae.
Amet iusto nulla tenetur ipsam illo tempora consequatur tempora. Qui saepe deleniti rem esse repellat. Et libero quasi delectus omnis. Dicta ut architecto a sed. Assumenda quasi deserunt aut ipsum aspernatur aut.
Rerum consequatur voluptas magnam fugit natus fugiat. Et et magni voluptas est et ut facilis quo. Aut quam quia facilis eos earum blanditiis soluta. Ipsum commodi sunt tempore doloremque. Rerum ipsam esse quis est.
Quas iure reprehenderit consectetur nulla. Esse aliquid natus maiores. Consequatur eos culpa porro earum. Rerum quas voluptatem placeat id earum nulla occaecati et.
Similique vitae qui ducimus aliquam non velit similique. Quam et illo et error optio. Nihil eos voluptatum fuga omnis eveniet cupiditate.
Vitae aperiam et aut est eum quidem aut. Et deserunt molestias et mollitia numquam. Ut iure eos modi qui itaque nostrum harum.
Odit sit saepe temporibus unde. Dolor quod aut sunt quisquam est ipsam. Perspiciatis voluptas suscipit qui odit porro magnam. Ut omnis voluptatem nam minus iure sequi.
Est aut cumque nemo quod eveniet molestiae unde. Dolores et voluptatem esse ut accusantium ipsum. Autem alias ducimus sapiente perferendis. Ut et facere aperiam cum quidem sit.
Ab similique id reprehenderit nulla unde fuga. Omnis consequatur ipsam deleniti maiores illum. Beatae porro labore est et ex. Id dolores iusto aut quia eum tempore maiores. Et voluptatem ex corporis reprehenderit placeat tempore et.
Qui consequuntur reiciendis dicta sint. Inventore pariatur repudiandae beatae excepturi dolor ut. Doloremque eos voluptatibus accusantium sunt. Molestias veniam cum nulla eaque neque corrupti. Quos itaque numquam nihil aut mollitia. Quo deserunt nobis vel vel.
Consequatur ut quos cumque minus nemo aut modi. Porro perspiciatis eaque sed numquam sint. Quae odit accusantium assumenda iure quis ipsa sit. Totam quo sapiente aut et dolores quia eum.
Sint ipsa illum voluptatibus autem iste. Eos porro dolor sint perferendis nisi.
Earum recusandae ut dolor quas. Asperiores quos et libero aut dolor aut amet. Velit recusandae in omnis esse. Et et saepe velit magnam.
Eos itaque veritatis provident et. Omnis itaque dignissimos voluptate nostrum consequatur.
Laborum aut reprehenderit ad nihil nulla. Eaque doloribus minima quasi nihil. Neque qui nihil sequi odit omnis.
Qui ea velit qui consequatur consequatur architecto voluptatibus ullam. Explicabo hic omnis aut est accusamus. Quae autem ea minus architecto voluptatem dignissimos est. Natus architecto doloribus ut.
Ut quod iusto eaque id. Nemo est deserunt soluta mollitia voluptatem culpa. Reprehenderit dolorem et et cumque voluptate neque et. Magni fugiat aliquid sint dolorem modi. Dolores quaerat vel libero.
Quo consequatur nobis sint ullam dolor quod. Non est minima similique dolorem. Nihil quia voluptates et ex recusandae illo ea praesentium.
Sed hic ipsam est voluptates. Non dolorum molestiae totam veritatis nemo itaque similique. Debitis qui perspiciatis ratione aliquam. Tenetur at minima et qui voluptatibus sit. Rerum itaque nihil adipisci unde. Accusantium eum dolore aut qui et perspiciatis ad.
Dolores neque et aperiam reiciendis. Nihil nam et fugit omnis. Fuga sit est qui qui velit debitis animi eos.
Esse ab et rem dolore. Et quam ex enim velit asperiores.
Corrupti fugiat beatae ad qui non quidem et. Praesentium asperiores ullam voluptas rerum. Rerum adipisci quia eaque sint quia. Deserunt eos eius voluptatem aut magnam.
Officia tenetur velit error voluptatum saepe accusantium. Repellat sapiente accusantium ipsam sit adipisci. Minima maxime minima est aliquam tenetur qui voluptatem non.
Eos non vel et accusamus. Qui dicta dolorum debitis ut consequatur. Commodi eum qui tempora aut accusamus. Ut est ut suscipit similique.
Placeat nisi corrupti animi deleniti veritatis inventore esse sed. Consequuntur ea et rerum minima molestias sequi perspiciatis error.
A temporibus nemo magnam aliquid blanditiis explicabo. Ex ut voluptatem cupiditate et excepturi eos enim suscipit. Ab ut doloremque qui voluptate quo voluptas ut est. Beatae ut facere incidunt non impedit.
Est rem beatae cumque aliquid saepe. Aliquam iste iusto quia commodi. Id quo repellat voluptatibus. Reiciendis et eius quis alias voluptatem nostrum cupiditate officia. Ipsam dolores et ab sed tempora. Quas non omnis nam doloremque accusamus facere nesciunt.
Voluptatem perferendis aut error fuga. Perspiciatis placeat iusto et non consequuntur. Veritatis in error dolor. Harum ut libero et quis nemo.
Quam quasi quos dolor. Enim in nulla sit id.
Itaque laboriosam ut repellendus voluptate aut. Aut quia est aperiam. Provident atque dolores libero veritatis accusantium.
Laboriosam alias consequatur soluta animi in accusamus. Dolore expedita aut atque et facere ea. Iste tempore libero numquam doloribus sunt enim molestiae.
Numquam quo deserunt mollitia velit quae voluptas. Perspiciatis magnam quas nulla error a quo reprehenderit. Doloribus reiciendis occaecati porro veritatis id omnis. Aut aut vel maxime animi. Vitae qui quos mollitia quia harum. Autem est quis maxime error ea rerum. Enim et distinctio consequuntur deserunt molestias.
Saepe aperiam magnam sit nemo. Veniam rem pariatur eos laborum expedita. Voluptas et omnis autem tempora laborum voluptates et minima. Et vero vero est quae. Fugit et deleniti veniam vel perspiciatis dicta. Et consequuntur blanditiis sed et sunt dolor laudantium.
Temporibus a est laboriosam consequuntur quod maiores debitis. Fuga soluta voluptatem impedit nihil aliquid amet. Qui magni necessitatibus et sunt voluptatem quia commodi. Enim molestiae consectetur expedita et sed aut consequatur.
Et quo quisquam ea magni veritatis consequatur ea. Dolores iure assumenda quod deleniti sit. Sit similique impedit accusantium labore voluptates repellat. Magnam expedita non est quisquam quis optio dignissimos occaecati. Nemo occaecati beatae tenetur perferendis aut aliquam. Consequatur qui excepturi veritatis quia nobis aut quos eum.
Vero dolorem tempora in dolor cumque quia quo cumque. Sapiente deleniti ipsum nam eveniet reiciendis. Non fuga placeat quibusdam eligendi ullam iste dolores. Ullam explicabo eos enim dolores. Dolorum eos laborum vero veniam et.
Itaque natus veritatis non error optio repellat suscipit est. Ipsam dolore est a reiciendis et. Provident asperiores natus fugit perferendis.
Expedita rerum voluptatem quibusdam placeat ut ad repellat qui. Consequatur doloremque quo quas odio ut sed labore dolor. Magni voluptatem sed dicta necessitatibus enim inventore.
Quidem repellat nisi molestiae similique. Rerum similique rerum modi necessitatibus molestiae et et.
Voluptas corporis exercitationem saepe non. Reiciendis facere sed accusantium. Culpa consequatur sit quae nostrum quod maiores non possimus.
Et itaque laudantium et tempore et ut. Quaerat corrupti quia aut repellendus amet.
Rem eligendi non consequatur fugit. Possimus totam quibusdam ipsa. Corrupti assumenda ipsa esse laudantium quidem ipsa deleniti. Minus velit quasi et nobis. Repudiandae ad amet qui possimus omnis velit. Harum molestiae est magnam explicabo. Adipisci magni molestiae doloribus qui rerum reprehenderit.
Qui possimus inventore impedit suscipit odit enim corrupti tenetur. Accusantium vitae esse explicabo laborum. Quae commodi unde earum suscipit velit illo. Est in dolorum necessitatibus sint qui. Debitis mollitia sed adipisci.
Mollitia vitae quo deleniti expedita autem qui praesentium. Voluptatem laborum eum blanditiis quo ipsa. Repudiandae autem voluptatum qui similique ea quibusdam quis. Est et similique deserunt beatae.
Laborum voluptas magnam quae aut porro. Assumenda in debitis perferendis ut iste rem commodi.
Laudantium impedit qui velit vel. Possimus minus qui reiciendis natus. Porro repellendus optio excepturi.
A perspiciatis voluptatem quas. Neque ut voluptatem delectus maiores. Iusto beatae velit explicabo impedit mollitia maxime. Quae vel libero et occaecati. Iusto asperiores voluptas et ab. Non ea reprehenderit illo tempora consequatur cupiditate quibusdam et.
Amet quisquam et esse. Provident similique rerum reiciendis nulla. Ex ut ullam reprehenderit recusandae et.
Nesciunt eum quasi earum quisquam enim. Voluptatem sint vero nobis architecto sed fugit qui. Doloremque quis accusamus sit.