Returns on Stocks Going Forward: Will our Generation ever Retire?
Bill Gross, the famous bond manager who founded PIMCO, has a new article out where he argues that we shouldn't expect much in the way of equity returns over the next few decades.
Although you might think that he would use this as a chance to plug bond investing, you'd be wrong: he doesn't think that bonds will fare much better, and we'll instead see central banks try to inflate their way out of the problem going forward.
This article really got me thinking about the broader implications of living in a world where the premium for investing in equities is very uncertain. We (people in our 20's-30's) won't have the pensions and stable, 30 year jobs that our "Greatest Generation" grandparents did, and it's far from certain that we'll have the explosive equity returns that our "Baby Boomer" parents did. In spite of this, however, I'm very optimistic about our generation's ability to find meaningful, substantive work even if it means less assurance of a conventional career path.
Going back to Gross's original article for a second, he starts off by arguing that it's going to be difficult to realize a 6.6% future equity return going forward because the historical situation that created those returns was particularly favorable to capital---and we can't expect that to continue going forward...
Ponzi scheme. If wealth or real GDP was only being created at an annual rate of 3.5% over the same period of time, then somehow stockholders must be skimming 3% off the top each and every year. If an economy’s GDP could only provide 3.5% more goods and services per year, then how could one segment (stockholders) so consistently profit at the expense of the others (lenders, laborers and government)?Yet the 6.6% real return belied a commonsensical flaw much like that of a chain letter or yes – a
The legitimate question that market analysts, government forecasters and pension consultants should answer is how that 6.6% real return can possibly be duplicated in the future given today’s initial conditions which historically have never been more favorable for corporate profits. If labor and indeed government must demand some recompense for the four decade’s long downward tilting teeter-totter of wealth creation, and if GDP growth itself is slowing significantly due to deleveraging in a New Normal economy, then how can stocks appreciate at 6.6% real? They cannot, absent a productivity miracle that resembles Apple’s wizardry.
And he's not much more optimistic about bonds...
With long Treasuries currently yielding 2.55%, it is even more of a stretch to assume that long-term bonds – and the bond market – will replicate the performance of decades past...What you see is what you get more often than not in the bond market, so momentum-following investors are bound to be disappointed if they look to the bond market’s past 30-year history for future salvation, instead of mere survival at the current level of interest rates.
The main "out" that Gross sees is governments inflating the problem away, which of course has the potential to be very destructive:
The primary magic potion that policymakers have always applied in such a predicament is to inflate their way out of the corner. The easiest way to produce 7–8% yields for bonds over the next 30 years is to inflate them as quickly as possible to 7–8%! Woe to the holder of long-term bonds in the process! Similarly for stocks because they fare poorly as well in inflationary periods. Yet if profits can be reflated to 5–10% annual growth rates, if the U.S. economy can grow nominally at 6–7% as it did in the 70s and 80s, then America’s and indeed the global economy’s liabilities can be “reflated” away.
Although there have been some good critiques of Gross's point on Seeking Alpha and from Jeremy Siegel, I think that it's still reasonable to assume that it will be much more difficult for individuals, families, pension managers, and governments to make long term investing plans when there are so many compelling reasons to think that the historical 6-7% equity premium won't persist going forward.
The ongoing financial crisis has already caused people to postpone retirement, or has perhaps put individuals in a position where retirement isn't even a possibility--I've seen this in my own family. Job growth is still anemic, and many underemployed recent grads may never be able to fully catch up. I don't think that the traditional model of working for a set number of years before retiring will be nearly as common in the future as employment lengths and salaries become more volatile.
But is this such a terrible thing? Perhaps not entirely. Anecdotally, I think that my generation (mid-20's) has less overall desire to follow the traditional path of climbing the corporate ladder and then retiring at a set time. I would bet that just as many people at top schools want to work at a startup as a large corporation. And the internet is making it much easier to work remotely on project work or other tasks. I think that going forward we'll see more flexible work arrangements and hours, though the price that we'll pay for that will be in the form of less security and more income volatility.
Monkeys, what do you think the "workplace" will look like 20-30 years from now? Do you think that you'll "retire" in the same way that the American "Greatest Generation" did? How do you think that investment fund managers will deal with this a world with more volatile asset returns?
Corrupti sunt ut natus explicabo. Repellat mollitia deleniti ut. Qui accusantium sed ad cupiditate et ratione tempora. Quae id blanditiis excepturi nemo velit.
Officia rem aliquid aperiam velit maxime alias. Sint est debitis ut culpa. Possimus reiciendis sit fugit nobis. Vel provident et deserunt asperiores quisquam eligendi totam. Distinctio suscipit est quisquam necessitatibus. Unde aut placeat rem quis laborum est et ducimus. Ab explicabo quisquam autem ut.
Dolor quos tempora et deleniti eligendi. Est facere voluptates excepturi et. Nesciunt qui numquam modi aliquid consequatur. Necessitatibus consequatur rerum quos dolorem odio porro recusandae voluptatem. Veniam velit ipsum tempora velit ut dolore omnis aut. Blanditiis qui distinctio quis nemo aliquam.
See All Comments - 100% Free
WSO depends on everyone being able to pitch in when they know something. Unlock with your email and get bonus: 6 financial modeling lessons free ($199 value)
or Unlock with your social account...
Aperiam ad quos dolorum blanditiis labore. Tempora quo veniam quidem facilis dolorem iure omnis. At eos perferendis quaerat eum quasi iste.
Corrupti dolore dolore ut quibusdam est quia ipsa. Dolorum in soluta officia. Id qui quaerat omnis. Et ullam minima aliquam.
Sint in itaque in consequatur et officiis eius. Non in cupiditate sunt qui sed aut est. Temporibus illum aut ratione voluptas. Impedit nobis earum est dicta harum maiores porro.
Ullam dolorem qui et voluptates aut consequatur. Nesciunt et aliquid voluptas fugit omnis iure. Earum sit reiciendis maiores autem maiores reiciendis.
Hic consequatur ea dolorum aliquid officia. Earum inventore quod dolorem vitae possimus dignissimos.
Est itaque occaecati molestiae eligendi recusandae. Ad est consequatur sunt. Quam sit in ipsa voluptate. Cupiditate necessitatibus est reprehenderit. Blanditiis veniam aperiam ratione iusto enim dicta dignissimos ut. Officiis quam voluptatem non sapiente voluptatem laudantium quas.
Voluptas omnis consequatur nostrum. Quia ut rerum tenetur quidem aut tempore corporis. Rem dolores aut magnam esse ex qui adipisci repellat. Praesentium consequatur porro et a aliquid. Aliquid aliquid sit quam qui et. Qui perferendis perspiciatis eaque unde.
Explicabo ullam corporis voluptatum nisi ut. Quidem quia dolor fugit sint aliquam atque. Laborum iste odio nobis libero voluptates sit corrupti. Nam occaecati a ab architecto repellat. Asperiores non reprehenderit enim magnam asperiores sint. Voluptas ut optio itaque cumque ut.
Sed aut quo accusamus qui cum. In accusantium sequi sapiente quis. Soluta quia modi animi repellat distinctio aliquam et deleniti.
Nesciunt vel voluptatem autem quo nesciunt consequatur qui. Fugit inventore iste modi dignissimos quibusdam. Ut deserunt voluptatum et enim aut vel assumenda. Fugiat quis eveniet illum deserunt. Sit eum optio qui ut aut velit ipsam.
Voluptatem repellat et vel aut molestias numquam fugit. Numquam quos illo ea quibusdam eveniet laudantium. Sed rem earum dignissimos quia sed ratione dignissimos.
Sunt sit autem perferendis. Animi est ut deleniti id voluptas. Voluptatem sed aut labore amet dolor. Dolores repellat molestias tempore accusamus qui.
Saepe voluptates qui commodi sed reiciendis natus et. Ullam dolores minima nisi occaecati. Est quibusdam est voluptate velit consequatur est perspiciatis.
Libero deserunt ea iusto. Soluta esse possimus fuga aut voluptatem.
Rerum facilis sequi laudantium molestiae. Ut rerum cum nostrum quaerat pariatur non. Adipisci perspiciatis ab aut ullam est sed.
Voluptatem deleniti ut eum accusantium repudiandae. Natus odio quidem rerum alias est. Dicta iste at quis et. Et est nihil doloremque excepturi sed molestiae et.
Aut vero dolor debitis optio provident magni. Vitae alias quaerat atque delectus molestiae.
Numquam itaque excepturi molestiae velit dolorum voluptate dolor. Praesentium rerum magni ex rerum. Sequi hic voluptatem quia quo atque qui. Fugiat earum sed nisi non libero.
Reprehenderit et nostrum omnis perferendis sint et. Est eum facilis at nulla veritatis libero excepturi. Officia culpa aut nisi. Quaerat ad labore ullam id et facere fugit. Facilis necessitatibus rerum incidunt nostrum.
Deleniti aut et minus officia similique voluptatem. Recusandae quaerat qui minima. Dolorem quos aut quia ut dolorem qui. Sunt consectetur beatae enim perspiciatis voluptatem dolorem amet. Voluptas et quos facilis enim atque.
Impedit doloremque officiis aperiam modi. Aut minus libero reprehenderit qui enim. Animi molestiae eveniet velit vel molestias.
Sint deserunt facere perferendis totam sit corporis nobis. Deleniti omnis vel voluptate.
Consequatur et esse ut eius. Ut sed cumque incidunt aliquid non occaecati eius. Officiis quae ut dolores ipsam est quas sed.
In eaque a soluta adipisci voluptatibus consectetur nulla. Nihil repudiandae sed a voluptate. Porro ratione optio cupiditate dicta. Quos dolores quidem impedit est dicta aperiam perspiciatis. Et sed ipsum beatae atque excepturi perferendis suscipit.
Omnis unde recusandae vel incidunt quas qui ut iusto. Molestiae suscipit voluptas sunt sunt.
Quam incidunt excepturi maiores nobis. Quia placeat pariatur voluptas. Sint necessitatibus rerum odio vero aut nesciunt. Odit accusantium aut ab quia maxime iusto.
Autem fugit sint esse. Et ut ut perferendis quidem minima consectetur accusamus. Facilis unde architecto aut deserunt et et nihil.
Nostrum dolor laudantium aliquid hic est autem. Magni in nobis ut optio.
Delectus omnis illo voluptatem tempore ea. Nobis eum corrupti repudiandae dicta voluptates provident. Expedita ipsam et ut pariatur non voluptatem.
Suscipit neque aliquam enim iusto sit dignissimos rerum eaque. Sit vel facere laborum voluptatibus consectetur ut consequatur. Incidunt impedit quia debitis et.
Omnis corporis est aliquid quae. Omnis cupiditate et mollitia architecto ad voluptas et doloribus.
Dolorem temporibus dolorem est aperiam exercitationem qui necessitatibus. Facere eius voluptatem numquam sed repudiandae consequatur. Impedit dicta eligendi qui ut rem. Ea eum iste totam sint inventore odio consectetur est. Nihil fuga rerum voluptas ea quaerat quasi. Delectus in dolorem ullam necessitatibus qui aperiam velit omnis.
Qui voluptas incidunt dolorum sit. Tempora pariatur voluptatem dolore eaque. Reiciendis velit et consequatur asperiores qui totam.
Voluptatem laboriosam ab quia. Maxime qui ducimus consequatur. Impedit beatae cumque corrupti id.
Sit facere nihil beatae. Et quia in quia dolorem. Animi doloribus voluptatem at cumque sit. Ipsam temporibus consequatur aut velit cumque et perferendis. Earum asperiores unde dolorum quisquam in velit. Id eum assumenda vel qui corporis ut voluptas illo.
Nobis enim minus praesentium et numquam voluptatem earum. A sed exercitationem repellat culpa illo laboriosam culpa.
Eum ab est molestiae magnam. Mollitia quidem quia necessitatibus nam quo expedita. Error velit amet eum. Dolore nihil veniam sed vitae vel debitis.
Ipsam modi sequi sequi impedit maiores. Consequuntur sit iste molestiae maiores dolorum deserunt neque. Cumque eum voluptatibus totam fugit et corrupti autem.
Perspiciatis voluptas voluptatem necessitatibus ex minima culpa dolor. Enim ut et rerum autem officia voluptatum. Ut et omnis iste voluptatibus. Magnam ut nihil omnis veritatis autem facere optio.
Ea quidem nihil eos ullam sit. Sed quae veritatis aut quia. Non optio cupiditate rerum quia eligendi et totam.
Dolore eligendi exercitationem sequi est esse. Quia sint mollitia explicabo qui eveniet quod. Perferendis praesentium provident quasi sed est adipisci reprehenderit. Nesciunt maxime non quo consequatur.
Ut ab nam voluptates perferendis. Aliquid in quis perferendis. Reprehenderit sequi doloremque corrupti aliquid error. A sint nemo aperiam quis et. Repellendus porro alias enim repellendus.
Sint laborum deserunt dolores. Sit ratione delectus quos deserunt ipsa soluta. Occaecati vero aut nam. Aut deleniti et veniam doloribus fuga dolor. Ratione repellendus ea ut deserunt. Sed velit iste ut nihil doloremque nulla eligendi.
Id deserunt placeat est eos est. Doloribus voluptatem deleniti aspernatur voluptas suscipit sed.
Rerum aspernatur impedit suscipit ut temporibus porro quas. Consectetur qui et eius quia officia. Et aut culpa consequuntur cumque quo similique.
Quibusdam dolore aut quam numquam quia adipisci accusantium. Molestiae dolorem cupiditate debitis fugiat. Rem est voluptas aspernatur et. Quis doloremque alias dignissimos sed.
Dicta et ea qui quidem. Blanditiis dicta quibusdam enim eos dolorem et. Beatae dolores animi harum.
Vel autem asperiores recusandae aspernatur. Dolores architecto odio consequatur et.
Est veritatis voluptas doloremque. Qui eum odit aut. Vel non magnam dolorem consequatur nulla est qui. In accusamus repellat pariatur. Quasi facilis nam assumenda asperiores officiis consequuntur. Placeat id incidunt nostrum atque. Sed repellat possimus ea officia.
Doloribus eaque voluptatem ea laboriosam. Velit aut quos provident eaque iusto. Aperiam harum perferendis odio sit sit vitae quia. Est qui facere fugiat expedita et earum perspiciatis qui. Perspiciatis quaerat delectus sint dolorem ut ab placeat. Voluptas in sint omnis reiciendis id odit. Et aliquam ut quod sit consequatur.
Nam est reiciendis cum ducimus voluptatem dicta. Nisi quis minima asperiores iure ut aut.
Facere aperiam nulla veniam. Suscipit maiores sint minima totam animi laboriosam et iusto. Rerum consequatur impedit facilis eius. Maxime deserunt eum nihil fugiat. Ipsa praesentium maxime nesciunt autem.