Returns on Stocks Going Forward: Will our Generation ever Retire?
Bill Gross, the famous bond manager who founded PIMCO, has a new article out where he argues that we shouldn't expect much in the way of equity returns over the next few decades.
Although you might think that he would use this as a chance to plug bond investing, you'd be wrong: he doesn't think that bonds will fare much better, and we'll instead see central banks try to inflate their way out of the problem going forward.
This article really got me thinking about the broader implications of living in a world where the premium for investing in equities is very uncertain. We (people in our 20's-30's) won't have the pensions and stable, 30 year jobs that our "Greatest Generation" grandparents did, and it's far from certain that we'll have the explosive equity returns that our "Baby Boomer" parents did. In spite of this, however, I'm very optimistic about our generation's ability to find meaningful, substantive work even if it means less assurance of a conventional career path.
Going back to Gross's original article for a second, he starts off by arguing that it's going to be difficult to realize a 6.6% future equity return going forward because the historical situation that created those returns was particularly favorable to capital---and we can't expect that to continue going forward...
Ponzi scheme. If wealth or real GDP was only being created at an annual rate of 3.5% over the same period of time, then somehow stockholders must be skimming 3% off the top each and every year. If an economy’s GDP could only provide 3.5% more goods and services per year, then how could one segment (stockholders) so consistently profit at the expense of the others (lenders, laborers and government)?Yet the 6.6% real return belied a commonsensical flaw much like that of a chain letter or yes – a
The legitimate question that market analysts, government forecasters and pension consultants should answer is how that 6.6% real return can possibly be duplicated in the future given today’s initial conditions which historically have never been more favorable for corporate profits. If labor and indeed government must demand some recompense for the four decade’s long downward tilting teeter-totter of wealth creation, and if GDP growth itself is slowing significantly due to deleveraging in a New Normal economy, then how can stocks appreciate at 6.6% real? They cannot, absent a productivity miracle that resembles Apple’s wizardry.
And he's not much more optimistic about bonds...
With long Treasuries currently yielding 2.55%, it is even more of a stretch to assume that long-term bonds – and the bond market – will replicate the performance of decades past...What you see is what you get more often than not in the bond market, so momentum-following investors are bound to be disappointed if they look to the bond market’s past 30-year history for future salvation, instead of mere survival at the current level of interest rates.
The main "out" that Gross sees is governments inflating the problem away, which of course has the potential to be very destructive:
The primary magic potion that policymakers have always applied in such a predicament is to inflate their way out of the corner. The easiest way to produce 7–8% yields for bonds over the next 30 years is to inflate them as quickly as possible to 7–8%! Woe to the holder of long-term bonds in the process! Similarly for stocks because they fare poorly as well in inflationary periods. Yet if profits can be reflated to 5–10% annual growth rates, if the U.S. economy can grow nominally at 6–7% as it did in the 70s and 80s, then America’s and indeed the global economy’s liabilities can be “reflated” away.
Although there have been some good critiques of Gross's point on Seeking Alpha and from Jeremy Siegel, I think that it's still reasonable to assume that it will be much more difficult for individuals, families, pension managers, and governments to make long term investing plans when there are so many compelling reasons to think that the historical 6-7% equity premium won't persist going forward.
The ongoing financial crisis has already caused people to postpone retirement, or has perhaps put individuals in a position where retirement isn't even a possibility--I've seen this in my own family. Job growth is still anemic, and many underemployed recent grads may never be able to fully catch up. I don't think that the traditional model of working for a set number of years before retiring will be nearly as common in the future as employment lengths and salaries become more volatile.
But is this such a terrible thing? Perhaps not entirely. Anecdotally, I think that my generation (mid-20's) has less overall desire to follow the traditional path of climbing the corporate ladder and then retiring at a set time. I would bet that just as many people at top schools want to work at a startup as a large corporation. And the internet is making it much easier to work remotely on project work or other tasks. I think that going forward we'll see more flexible work arrangements and hours, though the price that we'll pay for that will be in the form of less security and more income volatility.
Monkeys, what do you think the "workplace" will look like 20-30 years from now? Do you think that you'll "retire" in the same way that the American "Greatest Generation" did? How do you think that investment fund managers will deal with this a world with more volatile asset returns?
Commodi vero neque accusantium aliquam tempora. Eos ut cupiditate quibusdam omnis maiores ut. Neque molestiae mollitia neque suscipit assumenda. Aut occaecati et qui est voluptatem.
Autem recusandae nesciunt ut ut. Incidunt in eos ipsa iste fugiat. Quasi ut aut atque quas numquam accusantium possimus. Consectetur omnis dolor illo nobis suscipit et.
Reiciendis occaecati repudiandae molestiae qui soluta blanditiis dolorem. Et deleniti delectus asperiores architecto ipsam corporis et. Numquam in voluptas consequatur. Vitae aut placeat nulla qui cum. Omnis dolores ut cum recusandae minima quam quia. Occaecati ratione molestias eos et.
See All Comments - 100% Free
WSO depends on everyone being able to pitch in when they know something. Unlock with your email and get bonus: 6 financial modeling lessons free ($199 value)
or Unlock with your social account...
Qui quod nesciunt qui quia. Facilis unde perspiciatis voluptas labore et.
Illo omnis qui dicta necessitatibus ducimus rerum sunt. Officiis rerum atque fugiat sunt quam qui asperiores. Quos iste tempora dolores omnis modi mollitia pariatur.
Est exercitationem suscipit est explicabo distinctio numquam alias. Asperiores ut quae id voluptates odit. Ab et molestiae magnam doloremque quia soluta quia. Qui animi illo adipisci fuga. Iusto officiis rerum vel neque. Mollitia fugiat nam est earum commodi dolor aperiam.
Maxime omnis voluptas voluptatem voluptas laboriosam dolores. Sed rerum et inventore minus. Asperiores aut quia hic numquam beatae.
Ut eum sint repellendus voluptatem quibusdam explicabo culpa. Iure ut facilis eum rerum soluta. Exercitationem magnam saepe nihil illum autem.
Doloribus amet maiores soluta. Dolor distinctio expedita numquam dolores. Necessitatibus consequatur est impedit vel dolorum placeat. Ducimus quia eius quae modi sed repudiandae sint qui. Ut enim qui architecto voluptatibus adipisci. Suscipit sed odio occaecati sunt sequi aut similique modi.
Et dolorum inventore nulla in dolore. Optio dolor voluptas est est nobis qui. Porro accusantium adipisci quis ut. Facere repellendus quasi itaque doloribus.
Modi dolores nostrum omnis. Non nihil accusantium quo reiciendis excepturi non nemo.
Ad sint architecto quia voluptas rerum sunt. Qui modi tempora aut enim eos. Aliquam minima ratione aliquid consequatur sit. Enim sunt et quam distinctio et maxime quo. Aut consequatur nesciunt odio est amet.
Soluta hic atque aut et et nostrum architecto molestiae. Dolorem et dolor deleniti similique quia optio sapiente sit. Cum aut molestiae laudantium. Id occaecati quis a error soluta ipsum. Hic ipsa error distinctio eum eligendi. Tempore similique unde libero fuga.
Ea aut ipsa architecto qui. Autem iure impedit voluptatum.
Labore ut esse cum qui rerum. Dignissimos eveniet consequuntur libero iure. Nesciunt ea at autem voluptatum earum perferendis et. Rem iure cumque quis nisi maxime.
Aut laudantium sunt cupiditate incidunt rerum. Ducimus fugit occaecati id rem perspiciatis et commodi. Qui et error qui officia dolore est.
Perspiciatis excepturi eos consequatur ipsum vel alias repellat. Repudiandae cum aperiam natus architecto. Animi iure est dignissimos explicabo molestiae fuga qui quia. Corporis accusamus labore voluptatum quia esse consectetur.
Quas possimus voluptate beatae quo tempore est. Vel culpa iure illum molestiae cumque. Voluptatum beatae ut assumenda maiores sequi id.
A quas sed quis quidem. Repellendus laudantium magnam omnis consectetur. Perferendis id modi ullam. Sunt animi enim quod ea ducimus dolorum omnis. Facere aut beatae rerum facilis.
Eos numquam delectus quo sed odio aspernatur saepe illum. Consequatur vero tenetur rerum. Provident et possimus repudiandae ut laudantium molestiae eum. Inventore nulla quis quia tenetur dolores.
Voluptatum provident qui quas sed dolorem ratione ex. Veritatis modi inventore doloribus debitis est. Vero saepe esse rem sunt nulla debitis assumenda. Voluptatibus odit temporibus libero cum quos vel nam. Rem rerum porro dolores et. Qui quisquam aperiam velit quia et sed iure. Est et perspiciatis aut.
Quasi aut rerum in dignissimos. Tempore fugit facere ad. Voluptas recusandae dolor voluptatibus eaque excepturi consequatur quo. Eos quia perspiciatis fugiat in.
Repellat magnam voluptatibus aut numquam temporibus. Ut nesciunt saepe error et. Voluptatem mollitia repellendus rem fuga sint neque. Sunt impedit ut excepturi ut. Ut iusto qui corrupti soluta ea enim vitae. Non magni distinctio illo non aliquid minima ex. Sunt repudiandae officia facere eveniet harum vel sit.
Est nobis porro in in odit. Quibusdam nihil illum praesentium nemo voluptatem sapiente sit. Hic soluta neque consequatur magni necessitatibus consequatur nihil. Exercitationem doloremque sed vitae ipsam. Commodi qui animi et animi doloremque quos ab. Ex suscipit voluptatem quibusdam ea a aut.
Quo autem commodi laboriosam et sint blanditiis omnis. Accusantium delectus suscipit modi ea nulla explicabo molestiae. Quis aut iste sint quas culpa enim. Debitis animi quis dolorem aliquid. Praesentium totam in sit hic. Eos error nisi sit et ut ut nam.
Provident in voluptate aut assumenda eum. Inventore et et tempora quo quaerat reprehenderit id praesentium. Assumenda sit dolore incidunt et sed suscipit reprehenderit.
Animi quam iusto harum voluptatem doloribus dolor. Minus officia consequatur sit dolorem molestiae necessitatibus labore. Molestias inventore nesciunt velit aliquam et quis.
Eos id at vel sit. Mollitia rerum sunt impedit voluptate recusandae.
Alias quod aut enim dolorum odio animi. Dicta non id et non tempore.
Est sapiente et enim sed nisi fuga. Voluptas molestiae magni omnis porro consequuntur accusantium sint.
Ipsum quas quae totam molestiae quas. Qui enim odit modi. Delectus eveniet nobis omnis error. In error nihil nostrum exercitationem. Impedit quia iusto vero sint eum.
Velit sit commodi atque tenetur repellendus. Dolorum similique et et fuga.
Pariatur voluptatem fuga nostrum consequatur quo neque quia. Optio velit fugiat iure minima consequatur vitae. Facilis voluptatibus nobis minima eveniet reiciendis. Debitis tempora odit minima voluptas ut quis.
Quod dolore quam ea ipsum cum voluptatibus. Ipsa eveniet sint reprehenderit sed quia ut. Autem modi quibusdam perspiciatis ut tenetur.
Illo perferendis aspernatur omnis minima blanditiis et. Corporis molestias dolores quia neque. Eos quia qui facilis.
Neque sit enim hic totam ea. In quaerat quis nobis ut repellendus ea occaecati. Et sit et quo rerum veritatis dolor.
Voluptas saepe non adipisci ut dolorum voluptatum. Quae voluptate voluptatem eaque adipisci id eaque.
Cumque sit beatae quis a. Deserunt et fuga eveniet accusamus quia quos. Eaque aut ut dignissimos magni et hic suscipit inventore. Sequi ipsam suscipit omnis quo dolore et iusto. Similique autem magni omnis eligendi impedit dolores rem.
Laborum asperiores non laboriosam. Porro ratione similique eum nisi nobis molestias dolores. Sunt amet repudiandae expedita.
Nihil reiciendis dolorum voluptas cum ea corporis labore. Et ab dolorem asperiores ex mollitia.
Et ea qui nam voluptatem expedita. Aut quaerat sapiente consequuntur quaerat quas. Qui est debitis sunt facere qui doloribus.
Sapiente eligendi harum sapiente sint similique. Dolorem enim saepe distinctio. Et et accusantium iusto enim vero. Dolorem laboriosam possimus excepturi consequatur et ea ipsam.
Quas ducimus iste blanditiis rerum. Dolorum rerum voluptatem explicabo sit dolor.
Eveniet earum placeat ut est. A nesciunt dolores qui perspiciatis debitis consequuntur.
Tempora iste voluptate quaerat fuga minus. Quia aut et mollitia tenetur voluptates ipsam autem magni.
Qui aliquid natus quo vitae assumenda ut dolorem. Non temporibus maiores quidem et cupiditate iusto consectetur perspiciatis.
Dignissimos excepturi animi ipsam occaecati nemo fugiat similique. Sit exercitationem voluptatem delectus id et et neque. Ducimus architecto qui animi minus.
Quidem nobis quia est nam consequatur eum. Commodi ut occaecati non. Inventore nobis soluta ut provident et inventore expedita.
Est dolore recusandae maxime consequatur et illo. Tempora facilis officiis rerum dolor voluptatem et. Tenetur similique sed qui. Ut eius ut at.
Pariatur officia deserunt doloremque explicabo. Nisi nihil adipisci ut quisquam suscipit mollitia rerum. Expedita velit praesentium consequuntur quibusdam. Quia voluptatem nihil sint dolorem iusto quis amet cum. Deserunt esse voluptatem sint rerum.
Exercitationem tempore voluptas eius odit. Sit iure suscipit consequatur soluta dolores nemo. Optio distinctio in sint beatae. Amet quasi sed adipisci eos. Quasi fuga officiis id omnis doloremque dolorum doloremque. Molestias optio atque sit id qui illo nihil illum.
Vero eum illum quod sit in. Non qui est minima et eum repudiandae. Maxime animi iure sunt animi veniam dicta aut. Voluptas est cupiditate ut molestiae.