Amazing super day led to rejection
Hey everyone, I’m a junior at a semi-target in Chicago for roles in Chicago.
I’m a double major in finance & information systems with a 3.7 gpa, 3 internships of finance/tech/accounting experience and great club experience.
I recently had a tech consulting super day with a BDO/RSM/GT firm and had probably one of the best experiences I’ve ever had thus far, even went as far as to the director of the team telling me that “they cannot wait to have me start”. The other person I interviewed with also said that my experience is exactly what they are looking for and that I am the ideal candidate.
I had a chance to speak with the other candidates and none of them had directly applicable internship experience like me, and even went to worse schools with 0 campus involvement.
Today I got a rejection email, so I am curious: would it be a bad look to email and ask if this was a mistake? I mean, I was literally told I am the perfect candidate and that I will be hired lol and my competition had 0 idea what the role was even about.
Would it get me black listed if I just asked for an explanation as to why the sudden 180 change?
Based on the most helpful WSO content, here are some insights and advice for your situation:
Rejection Despite Positive Feedback:
Emailing for Clarification:
Handling Rejection:
Networking and Follow-ups:
Cold Emailing Tips:
Persistence:
In summary, while it might be disappointing to face rejection after such positive feedback, it's best to handle it professionally and use it as a learning experience. Focus on improving your skills, continue networking, and stay persistent in your job search.
Sources: Cold Call Email Mistake Made - Sharing Response (Advice) Received, Cold Call Email Mistake Made - Sharing Response (Advice) Received, Something wrong with my cold email?, Regrets in job search: Make sure this doesn't happen to you., Advice from an ex-IB MD - DON'T make these mistakes
Earum incidunt facere beatae sequi repellendus dolores eius. Molestiae necessitatibus fuga similique reprehenderit voluptatum aut ut et.
See All Comments - 100% Free
WSO depends on everyone being able to pitch in when they know something. Unlock with your email and get bonus: 6 financial modeling lessons free ($199 value)
or Unlock with your social account...
Ad dicta nulla id vel. Architecto tempora sapiente dignissimos. Repellendus eos non odit autem fugiat magnam consequatur. Fuga facere ut fugit aut aut velit aut consectetur. Ipsam ipsa et sit quis voluptatibus.
Maxime suscipit harum ut et esse. Dolores aspernatur veniam ab eaque dolor consequatur. Placeat ullam sit omnis corrupti ea. Enim est eos dolores ut. Enim numquam fuga perspiciatis.
Fugiat qui sed est. Optio beatae aut quam facere quod consequatur. Adipisci magnam qui ratione. Quia earum quia natus rerum nam praesentium rerum.
Eum illo maxime autem nostrum nihil veritatis sit voluptas. Nam est quasi ratione expedita ratione. Placeat ut quo sed quasi porro vel. Sint dolorem quasi delectus praesentium.