Natural Gas vs. Coal Plants
Hey Guys, For my internship I'm working on a research project examining natural gas vs. coal power plants. For anyone here working with energy I've noticed that heating value added for natural gas is measured in btu/ft^3 and heating value added for coal is measured in btu/ton. When I make the conversion from btu/ft^3 to btu/ton using some assumptions about specific gravity I get that natural gas has a much higher heating value added per ton. Does this make sense? Is it valid to make this calculation since I'm essentially comparing two substances in different states? Do you guys know of any good research done on coal vs. natural gas power plant efficiencies, cost, output, etc.
Thanks! gcjohns
It's not valid to do a weight-based comparison here because natural gas does not occur in solid form underground, costs far more to extract per "ton" and uses different equipment to burn it. Essentially, the only "common denominator" between the two are that both are carbon-based sources of energy when burned.
It really depends on what side you're looking at it from (whether from a cost-benefit analysis, or from an environmental side), but I would examine it like this:
Long story short, your normalizing factor should be btu - not weight.
Yes natural gas has a much higher heating value than coal. However, for purposes of power plants instead of worrying about specific gravity and btu / ton or btu / ft^3, you should just focus on heat rate, which is the number of btus required to generate a kWh of electricity. The heat rate for combined cycle natural gas is in the 6,800 btu / kwh - 7,200 btu / kWh range, while coal usually comes in around 10,000 btu / kWh. Peaker (simple cycle) gas plants have a higher heat rate, closer to that of coal.
Best general (free) source for this kind of information is the EIA (http://www.eia.gov/). They have a ton of data and a lot of introductory material. If you have access to Wall Street research you can check any initiating coverage report for utilities and you'll probably also find some of this info.
Great thanks! I'll check those sites out and rework somethings. I really appreciate it.
Placeat quia iure quasi impedit cumque neque et. Quia eveniet dicta omnis ipsam iste quod corrupti. Dolorum illum deleniti ut perferendis rerum inventore. Possimus est est deleniti molestias itaque ab. Qui fugiat laudantium natus aperiam suscipit sunt eos. Sunt illum tempora ut iusto. Sunt molestiae fugit nostrum minima corporis ab.
Inventore alias nam itaque accusamus quis sed veritatis. Veniam fugiat quibusdam est veritatis magni inventore. Quasi animi architecto quae veniam aut eius assumenda. Et et suscipit dolorem est. Sunt aut modi magni.
See All Comments - 100% Free
WSO depends on everyone being able to pitch in when they know something. Unlock with your email and get bonus: 6 financial modeling lessons free ($199 value)
or Unlock with your social account...