What actually makes a stock pitch land in an interview?
I'm a sophomore recruiting for internships right now, on the equity research side, and stock pitches come up in almost every conversation. I've got a few I've worked on through my school's student managed fund, but I'd rather hear from people who have actually sat on the other side of the table than keep guessing.
For those of you senior in the industry: what separates a pitch that holds your attention from one you tune out two minutes in? Curious how much weight you put on the thesis itself versus how well someone defends it under pushback, whether you care if the name is already widely covered, and how much detail you actually want on the model before it becomes noise. Also interested in what the most common way candidates blow it is — overcomplicating the setup, not having a real variant view, not knowing the downside case, something else entirely.
Happy to hear specifics on what you'd want from someone at my level versus a junior or full-time candidate, since I assume the bar is different. Appreciate any thoughts.