49 Comments
 

Based on the highest ranked content on WSO, several users have expressed concerns about the current state of the site. Here are some key points:

  1. Quality of Discussions: Many users feel that the quality of discussions has declined. There are complaints about the site being dominated by inside jokes, rivalries, and political debates, which detract from professional and informative content.

  2. Moderation Issues: There have been mentions of moderation efforts that might not be addressing the core issues effectively. Some users feel that the site has become less professional and more focused on trivial matters.

  3. Departure of Serious Professionals: It's noted that serious professionals have left the site over time, possibly due to the increase in non-professional and politically charged content.

  4. Trolls and Low-Quality Posts: The presence of trolls and low-quality posts, such as those from inexperienced users or those making irrelevant comments, has been a significant issue. This has led to frustration among long-time users who seek valuable information and discussions.

  5. Changes in User Engagement: Some users have mentioned that they have stopped posting or engaging with the site due to the negative changes in the community dynamics.

For more detailed updates on moderation efforts, you can refer to the WSO thread titled "New WSO Moderation Efforts [Updates Here]" https://www.wallstreetoasis.com/forum/investment-banking/new-wso-modera…</a">link.

Sources: New WSO Moderation Efforts [Updates Here], Considering Leaving WSO, New WSO Moderation Efforts [Updates Here], WSO, It Is Time To Talk, A message to all young people/students who browse this forum

I'm an AI bot trained on the most helpful WSO content across 17+ years.
 

Because they don’t promote it lol. If they worked with colleges and got it into classrooms they would 1000x the number of users

 

Tbh after some point it does get repetitive, there's like 1 interesting troll/dumb sophmore post a week and thats usually top post. We cant have 100x target school rankings and what should I do for technicals posts now.

 

Because the new generation is all about whining and looking for validation on the forum, can't google, or go through a basic thought process.

 
[Comment removed by mod team]
 
[Comment removed by mod team]
 
[Comment removed by mod team]
 

One of the issues as an old user is that I've posted all the advice with a bunch of well read posts years ago. Would be kind of strange to post again and again in different formats. Most of the issues that I'm mostly interested in discussing now are later things in career which don't seem to get a good reception on here.

 

Same- I see the same questions over and over again to which I gave a nice writeup a few years back.. Don't want to write it again, don't want to have to search through my history and find the thread

Also they shadowbanned the CF forum, which has more or less nuked any content there

And finally, I've hit the phase of my career where I'm not just hopping around or following a beaten path- I have to be an expert and network and politic well. Makes it harder to relate

 
[Comment removed by mod team]
 
[Comment removed by mod team]
 
[Comment removed by mod team]
 
[Comment removed by mod team]
 

It’s a combination of factors: a lot of the legends and OGs have moved on. Some of the long-time posters (10+ years here) are just in different stages of life now and don’t/can’t contribute as frequently. Some of the newer users are Reddit weirdos who post dumb shit that isn’t as engaging.


But, together, I’m convinced we can make WSO great again.

 

We need the return of T30 Alumnus. They banned that racist who would create entertaining beefs.

 

no more drama and juicy lore — filled with low/semi target (michigan, uva, berkeley) sophomores 

 
Most Helpful

I’m an anonymous poster who has many of the highest ranked comments and posts. I probably made my first post on a different account more than a decade ago. Here is what I have noticed over the years:

  1. Gen Z has substantially less empathy than prior generations and they are more addicted to their phones and specifically short form video. This is important because WSO used to be (and somewhat still is) the way I used to shit away time. Many times I’d use the website while on the toilet, while commuting, or hungover in bed. I think all these are now replaced by people scrolling TikTok or instagram for the younger kids. The empathy part is also relevant because I felt some obligation to give back after the website helped me find my footing and now I just don’t see people doing that. I think people from an older web age were very attached to online communities as a way of meeting friends and wasting time since that was a huge part of the internet getting going. Now, I think many gen z just didn’t have the experience so they aren’t looking for online communities or don’t find it natural like what was so common for millennials. This website used to be a place where miserable analysts could check in with each other and ask for tricks on how to succeed and it morphed into something just less communal.
  2. As others have mentioned, as an older user, I’m really aging out. Once kids get in the picture or you advance professionally, there are way better ways of wasting time or you just don’t have the time to waste like when I was single and a banking analyst.
  3. The lack of empathy has frustrated many users myself included. I can’t even begin to tell you how many times I have stated factually accurate information and had some intern arguing with me. I’ve even had people attempt to dox me thinking I was a colleague and share personal details on a thread. It’s why I share everything anonymously, but eventually yall just became so negative and mean. 

the quality posts come from guys like me when I’m at the airport and want to rip a little nostalgia. Others could do it too, but to write a quality post usually requires bringing up a topic many are thinking about, or doing a deep dive into a commonly experienced phenomenon. To do the former, you need to be observant, to do the latter, you need to be an experienced analyst that sits down and walks through a topic like how to deal with stress as an analyst or how to recruit or some technical thing they are seeing. Nothings stopping you from doing that—be the change you want to see in the world young blood.

I might do a long post reflecting on the last decade+ at some point as a farewell to the website, but I’m not quite there yet.

 

As a 30-year old, I can feel your pain. Please don't dump this website & allow giveadvicepls to win the war for its soul

 

Yeah, this is a good summary. There still are a few monkeys from back in the day, but their contribution is limited, abovementioned reasons. This used to be a great site for insights, humour, help. Nowadays seems the "usual stuff" rules. Still, I contribute when I can, find a topic worth to discuss and where I can chip in with my input. I'm overjoyed when I see some of the old guard tuning is as well. But yeah, the days of Braverman, Compbanker, thebrofessor etc. churning first class posts on a daily/weekly basis are pretty much gone i'm afraid.

 

Ignore tag, been around here for quite some time. Those names do bring back great memories. Brofessor/Compbanker advice has always been on point, and the shitposts/rants from the older users have always been fun to read.

Maybe we have all become old as we reminisce on the "good old days".

 
[Comment removed by mod team]
 

There aren’t many thoughtful topics from people in the industry - mainly because the users consist largely of:

- students trying to break in so their posts are about interviews/recruiting or jacking off to rankings for an industry they probably won’t spend more than a few years in

- people in industry mostly discussing exits or whatever fire is happening at their competitor banks

- trolls who can sometimes be humorous but otherwise spam the same mindless stuff all day, some of these guys haven’t even worked in this industry and post here for some reason (e.g. Isaiah)


That said, this forum is mainly to help students with recruiting with some thoughtful industry discussion so maybe it’s just being shaped by this generation of students.

 

...and don't forget: "didn't break into internship in IB. I'm cooked and lost"

This place used to be:

A source of knowledge. Really good questions and answers

A source of encouragement, as people gave tips and hints on how to achieve

A source of joy, with clever and witty writing

Less whinning and also less "which [insert here college/bank/fund] is better"

 

I pine for the days of braverman, even bought his book. 
 

I think it’s reflective of the general domestication of finance over the past two decades. 
 

the biggest guys were the traders who banked 30-50m paydays in a year, using hardcore mathematics to come up with derivatives that ripped the face off of counterparties. where a book called “straight to hell” was actually an accurate depiction of the culture of the place. 
 

nowadays it’s all the imaginary money “DAW”, the ibd + pe 2+2 (that was never a thing), in the context of a more social media-ized world of cancel culture (where punching someone as an MD gets you fired). 
 

there was a certain brutal edge to the old world you can glean in some of the older guys (talking the 60/70 year olds) that was watered down in my generation and completely diluted in the current. 
 

Is this a bad thing? I think it’s just the normalization of an industry that had a prior boom. 
 

there’s still pockets, the math nerd smurfers went to crypto and the “rip your face off” deal types still hang around in special sits and distressed land / fringe esoterics. But they wouldn’t be posting here as they are too old. 

 

Sorry to digress, how does a poor mathematics nerd (Olympiad-level) in a random remote random nation find his way into the seats of these quant-ish traders who make the 8 digits you talk of?

 
[Comment removed by mod team]
 

 Entertainment is lacking. Rankings, "banking sucks, I'm quitting peace out" and "does xyz group exit to PE" is the daily rotation. I probably should look inwards and admit I don't create entertaining posts either but goddamn, even the "is paradise" bros been slacking

I have no desire to constantly be debatebro'd by "Analyst 1 in IB - Cov" or "Prospect in IB - Cov". I generally don't engage with any anon accounts. We went from having big personalities writing meaningful posts to a bunch of little soy boy keyboard warriors who need to anonymize already anon accounts. If you're that much of a coward, you didn't have anything meaningful or interesting to say in the first place and given the amount of anon posting, see my point #1

This is a reflection of online discourse today, not just WSO in particular. There are very few conversations and way too many arguments. Everyone is right and they have to prove they are right and you have to admit they are right and there is no grey area or nuance. Egos are fragile and that shit is boring

Lastly, and I think this is the big one. Bullpen culture is completely different nowadays and its reflected here. I see it with my juniors and its so fucking dry. The camaraderie just isn't there. The ride together die together against shitty VPs, post-MBA associates and unreasonable MDs just doesn't feel like its common anymore. 

 

I come here to get advice around random/weird ideas I have. Previously I'd get at least ~3 or 5 good responses, and some very very strong DMs. Now, I don't really get any responses. I've stopped posting as much because of that. It could be because I'm also more experienced, and things obvious to me were not when I was in my early twenties posting here.

Like the poster above posted, I think it's largely b/c Gen Z didn't grow up on forums the same way other generations did. I'm 31, so not super old, but I've been posting on forums since I was ~8 (shoutout to splintercell forum lol) and a lot of my long-term friends are from forums as weird as that is.

They definitely don't seem to have the same mindset around contributing to a forum VS taking.

 

I think there are additional aspects not mentioned, but forgive me if I missed earlier posts.

I believe people might see the internet in a way that rewards a fundamentally different learning style. You can see the effect in how they approach questions;

  • efficiency is valued highly at the expense of long-form posts
  • formality is valued less across the board
  • vocabularies are simplified in favor of memes
  • memes and copypastas replace individual commentary
  • the site is thought of as as an app instead of a message board or forum
  • forum culture/etiquette are outdated concepts for modern graduates

There is a larger discussion to be had here about whether internet communities trend towards different consumption or creative behavioral trends over time. I don't suggest one is better or worse but this effect coupled with the rapid growth of social media has caused a shift in discourse across many online communities that predate big tech platforms.

 

It used to be that a good amount of mid-career professionals were lingering around here. You'd ask a question about HFs or something and at least a few people from industry would chime in (usually lead by the power users who have gotten less active) and start a discussion. Now, if you post about HFs you're gonna get forty 20 year olds posting that they're also interested and god forbid a mid-career hedgie respond, those 20 year olds will drown them in "I'm a sophomore, how can I best prepare to work at a hedge fund" and "how much do you make? Can I send you my resume?" That certainly shuts the door to a discussion.

 
[Comment removed by mod team]
 

Having been 3 years the biggest shifts in this short amount of time have been:

1. Huge influx of new users (myself included at the time I joined the site) are college students over the last few years, likely because the bulk of WSO's promotion materials are directed in breaking into IB from college, so obviously it's a lot of student advice and not a place for tenured industry professionals. Reddit /r/FinancialCareers has this same problem. Most people entrenched in the industry are likely on more niche forums 

1A) Non-target / Freshman single Google search questions clogging up "New" on how to break in, or college Seniors from non-targets panicking they don't have an FT offer because they had 0 internships. Overall very redundant questions that get asked daily.  

2. At least 3 posts a day of obvious LARPs of stories clearly made up, or Stern hardos fishing for validation on how talented and charismatic they are. These posts SUCK! I doubt anyone likes to sit around for these

Both of these suck and they're bothersome. There are gems here and there when I come back every couple weeks to lurk, but overall all the content coming in just seems tired out and muddy. I rarely see anything of interest on this site. The only thing WSO does better than other forums at this point is salary tracking, but that's about it

 

I think the biggest problem is that experienced posters don’t create topics, as you age you develop a network who you can go to for questions and you don’t need the forms. The best topics that get discussed often start with a question from a college student or junior person and more senior people will start commenting and it will get other senior people to respond.

 

I would post more but I’m in such a niche space that relevant questions don’t always come up. Professionals aren’t going to guess at shit we don’t know. And I got bored of shitposting years ago.

I do try to add valuable commentary on the secondaries threads but there’s already about ten of the same thread now. Not gonna repeat the same view as it would likely be found if you searched. 

 
[Comment removed by mod team]
 

Eum veniam delectus et minus consequuntur. Officia fuga voluptatem qui voluptatem reiciendis. Doloribus blanditiis vero nihil quis quia voluptate et.

Error accusantium in voluptatem et. Nemo quibusdam asperiores tenetur veniam. Nam et temporibus id illum. Voluptatibus nesciunt repudiandae quia. Magni earum sint unde facilis veritatis ducimus.

Repellendus eos earum minus quia ut rem alias. Eius molestiae et omnis libero aperiam. Impedit aut vitae incidunt ipsa sit illum.

 

Dolor explicabo perspiciatis iure ab vitae. Aut molestiae molestias et cum. Officiis nulla corrupti quae dolorem. Assumenda rem laboriosam voluptatem quos. Odit et exercitationem voluptatem eos debitis fugit.

Quia amet laudantium rerum nam. Voluptas id ipsum dolorem dolor blanditiis distinctio ab. Nihil est reiciendis dolores eligendi consequuntur similique et aut. Provident aut natus voluptatibus similique quae aliquam.

Alias est laudantium quod aut dolores. Eum voluptatem officia non voluptas quos aut explicabo repellat. Vel amet unde sed error.

Nesciunt autem autem omnis dolore quis nulla quas. Nihil nostrum ab necessitatibus et aut natus et. Incidunt impedit libero corrupti cupiditate nemo sed qui. Quia perferendis maiores vitae eius deserunt eos.

The answer to your question is 1) network 2) get involved 3) beef up your resume 4) repeat -happypantsmcgee WSO is not your personal search function.

Career Advancement Opportunities

June 2026 Investment Banking

  • Evercore 01 99.4%
  • Moelis & Company 01 98.8%
  • JPMorgan 01 98.2%
  • Guggenheim Partners 01 97.6%
  • Morgan Stanley 07 97.1%

Overall Employee Satisfaction

June 2026 Investment Banking

  • Moelis & Company No 99.4%
  • Morgan Stanley 02 98.8%
  • Evercore 01 98.2%
  • BMO Capital Markets 12 97.6%
  • Banco Santander 01 97.0%

Professional Growth Opportunities

June 2026 Investment Banking

  • Evercore 01 99.4%
  • Moelis & Company 01 98.8%
  • Morgan Stanley 05 98.2%
  • JPMorgan No 97.6%
  • BMO Capital Markets 12 97.1%

Total Avg Compensation

June 2026 Investment Banking

  • Vice President (14) $434
  • Associates (43) $259
  • 3rd+ Year Analyst (8) $210
  • 2nd Year Analyst (22) $179
  • Intern/Summer Associate (13) $156
  • 1st Year Analyst (77) $151
  • Intern/Summer Analyst (70) $101
notes
16 IB Interviews Notes

“... there’s no excuse to not take advantage of the resources out there available to you. Best value for your $ are the...”

Leaderboard

1
redever's picture
redever
99.2
2
Secyh62's picture
Secyh62
99.0
3
kanon's picture
kanon
99.0
4
BankonBanking's picture
BankonBanking
99.0
5
CompBanker's picture
CompBanker
98.9
6
GameTheory's picture
GameTheory
98.9
7
DrApeman's picture
DrApeman
98.9
8
dosk17's picture
dosk17
98.9
9
Betsy Massar's picture
Betsy Massar
98.9
10
Mimbs's picture
Mimbs
98.8
success
From 10 rejections to 1 dream investment banking internship

“... I believe it was the single biggest reason why I ended up with an offer...”