Macro Monkey Says
He Said, He Said
In the Soviet Union, Aldus Huxley’s Brave New World, and of course, the Federal Reserve, dissenting from the majority opinion isn’t exactly a normal thing to do.
See, the Fed, like Mustafa Mond and Stalin, like to keep this air of “we’re so smart that everyone agrees we’re so smart and no one disagrees with our decisions. Unlike the other two, FOMC legend Thomas Hoenig broke up that party real quick.
Back in the days of the GFC, Hoenig was the OG economist to call the Fed’s rate policy “too low for too long” in the post-financial meltdown world. His dissents took the Fed out of the world of utopian order and into a place where debate actually occurred.
Since then, publicly recorded dissents by FOMC members are seen as much less boat-rocking than they once were. Today, it’s gotten to the point where open, but not yet what we could exactly call “explicit,” beef occurs between Fed officials.
Usually, it’s Boston and New York that have major beef, but this time, it’s NYC and Chicago. Fed Presidents John Williams (NY) and Austan Goolsbee (Chi-town) have issued seemingly at-odds statements in recent days with regard to May’s FOMC meeting. To hike or not to hike remains the question, and here, economists are about as certain as Hamlet was when he had a similar question.
Now, this wouldn’t be all too weird, except for the fact that the FOMC, and especially the committee’s voting members as both of the above name-drops are, is basically an economist’s version of a frat, but with fewer kegs and more shirts. With arguably its most powerful policy tool being the confidence (or lack thereof) the Fed can institute in markets and the public, the Central Bank has historically sought to show unity in its decision-making to maximally reduce financial FUD.
Not anymore. Goolsbee this week seemed to try and coin his own term of “prudence and patience” for the Fed’s next rate decision, but in Fedspeak, that roughly translates to “please oh god Daddy JPow stop hiking my rates.” Meanwhile, Williams called a 25-bps hike “a good starting point” for the committee’s policy debates. Doesn’t get much more heated than that at the nation’s top economic board.
At the same time, non-voting member Susan Collins, President of the Boston Fed, broke tradition by apparently siding with Williams of NYC. In her remarks, Collins stated that “modest additional policy tightening” is her current base case for the rest of 2023.
I don’t know if FOMC members disagreeing is weirder or not than people from Boston and NYC agreeing, but we can confirm that neither one is exactly making businesses, consumers, markets, and the overlords of the simulation we have to live in feel more confident these days.
According to the market, however, JPow and the gang have a two-thirds chance of raising rates by 25 bps on May 3rd. Powell himself has already come out and said that the bank failure of last month could basically be equivalent to a 25-bps hike. I hope someone is checking his math on that one, but as long as it means my stocks might start to go up again, I’ll take it.
Fortunately, you don’t have to just “think” about what the Fed is gonna do; you can degenerately gamble on it too. Good luck.
|
Vero repellendus aut hic est. Dignissimos temporibus odit voluptatem maiores. Illo earum provident eum sit ut perspiciatis animi voluptatem. Odio qui nostrum saepe. Ut ut porro ut sint et temporibus itaque. Quia adipisci similique possimus nam ipsa itaque. Praesentium iure minima fugiat nihil nemo.
Quaerat ut quas est et. Voluptas et placeat aut sed maiores. Quasi est eaque eos ipsa vel. Minima sint earum aut molestiae odit aspernatur.
Delectus ad numquam iste corporis et mollitia. Reprehenderit dicta vel dignissimos sit omnis exercitationem. Earum ut voluptatem enim iure sit expedita.
Nihil nihil voluptatem laudantium nihil hic. Consequatur a explicabo doloribus possimus voluptas veniam est quasi. Dolore sapiente aut autem minus aliquid et amet. Quo aliquid sit et qui soluta.
See All Comments - 100% Free
WSO depends on everyone being able to pitch in when they know something. Unlock with your email and get bonus: 6 financial modeling lessons free ($199 value)
or Unlock with your social account...