Did I make a career Mistake?
Went through the whole interview and application process this summer as a third year with little experience on the resume. From a non-target school, and mid range GPA, and luckily after tons of interviews and rejections I received 2 offers for completely different locations and positions. One was for IB in NY from a MM Bank in a top group (Think Lev-Fi/FIG/FICC) which i was thrilled with but the second offer was in my hometown where I would be able to stay at home, but in AM (Asset Management). The catch is, this offer was from a top tier bulge bracket (think JPM/GS/MS), and although it wasn't IB, I thought the value of the connections/networking if done right, would be worth it. I ended up choosing the Asset Management role (Honestly thought I'd be a lot happier being in my hometown having people around me) but the thought is lingering that I may have made a mistake and not sure how easy it will be to lateral in a full time IB role if I end up wanting to change paths. Did I make a mistake by not taking the IB position in NY?
Choosing between two strong offers is always a tough call, and it's natural to second-guess your decision. Based on the most helpful WSO content, here's what you need to consider:
Lateral Opportunities from Asset Management to IB:
The Value of Your Current Role:
Challenges of Lateraling into IB:
Did You Make a Mistake?
Ultimately, your career is a marathon, not a sprint. If you're committed to transitioning to IB, it's possible with the right strategy and effort. But if you find fulfillment and growth in AM, you may discover that it aligns better with your long-term goals.
Sources: Asset Management vs Investment Banking 101, Asset Management vs Investment Banking for exit opps into value-based hedge funds, Moving from Asset Management into IB / PE, Lateraling Guide for Investment Banking, https://www.wallstreetoasis.com/forum/private-equity/going-from-mm-investment-bank-to-mega-fund?customgpt=1
MM IB will always be easier to transfer over and lateral, as opposed to switching job functions internally
If you want to do IB FT, then yes, you made a mistake.
Honestly I think you made the right call, or at the minimum a respectable call. Most people that start IB in NY burn out and end up back in their hometown anyway, or in NY in a less than desirable role. The ones that stay in IB or exit to buy side roles might make money but still aren’t the happiest people (although most people aren’t super happy), and you have to ask how many of those people go the distance.
You got the perfect arbitrage opportunity. A top quality firm, AND a high quality role in AM, and prime location in your hometown. That actually sounds like a sustainable path to success. You might not make the most kkey in your first month on the job, but you’re a hell of a lot more likely to still be there in 15 years, and that’s when the real money comes in. If you enjoy what you do and like your team and are good at it, I have no doubt in 5-10 years you’ll have a few promotions, a ton of internal respect, and and an incredible trajectory in a city you love, while most finance people will be figuring things out after burnouts, layoffs, career changes, MBAs, etc etc.
Sustainability and duration are two factors that are incredibly important, and that juniors underweight. Financiers are incredibly wealthy, yes, but ONLY the ones that last the 15 years to become a senior, and they really hyper accumulate wealth in the 15-25 years after that. Only 40% of my analyst class is still even in IB or PE 4 years out, and 4 years out is a joke compared to what it takes to get rich in finance. How many of us 40% will still be around in another 4 years? I’m still here fighting to reach the top, but with every passing year, I feel more grateful to still be around in finance and also more aware of the truth of this world: that 95% of roads in this life lead to average, and the remaining 5% usually involve going against the crowd and doing something unconventional.
Cupiditate placeat tempora molestiae tenetur aperiam eum quos. Voluptate sint ut vitae facere sunt non omnis eligendi. Ut saepe libero et eos ea voluptatum iste maiores. Aspernatur adipisci id aliquid perspiciatis odio quaerat.
Ut aut nisi est nobis molestiae quidem fugiat. Assumenda sed explicabo sequi totam non incidunt. A earum cum autem est corrupti doloremque eius consectetur. Soluta expedita quisquam mollitia aspernatur similique. Eos minima animi cupiditate fugit debitis. Rerum sunt at libero provident beatae nisi esse.
See All Comments - 100% Free
WSO depends on everyone being able to pitch in when they know something. Unlock with your email and get bonus: 6 financial modeling lessons free ($199 value)
or Unlock with your social account...