Girl Rejects me because of my Bank
Just yesterday evening, I was doing some cable curls at the Equinox on 53rd when I saw her again. I looked in a mirror across the room and felt that this mild pump was doing some moderate wonders to my 140lbs frame. This senseless confidence conjured up, I approached her.
“Hi, I don’t mean to bother you, but I’ve seen you here often and I just wanted to say I think you’re really…”— I froze for a second as a deluge of Instagram reels and Reddit threads of women talking about their experiences being cold approached flooded my mind. I suddenly didn’t feel it appropriate to call her pretty here, and I wanted to differentiate myself from any other guy approaching her and hype her up a little bit. So, I landed on—“strong...”
Luckily, she took it well, laughed, and thanked me. We exchanged names, and then I asked her:
“So, are you from the city?” in such an arrogant and blasé way that I stunned myself. My face dropped to a more sincere expression, but I doubt she noticed any of it transpire.
”No, I wish. I’m from Philly.”
“Oh, nice city. Rough season though, huh?” I had no idea what sport I was referring to.
She laughed again and nodded sheepishly. I thought I was doing great. Not only because I had made her laugh, but because I had thus far succeeded in keeping my eyes from dropping down her white Alo top.
She asked me where I’m from. “Westchester,” I said, rather proudly and pointing my finger up, as if she could see the three-dimensional rendering of New York I was visualizing in my mind.
I asked her what she does for work. Mostly because I wanted to tell her what I do for work.
“Oh, I’m in marketing. I’m a bit creative, so it’s fun!”
Perfect. A cunning smile formed across my face as I thought of my washed-up, freshly-divorced Director who asks me every day if I’m still single, and when I tell him yes, proceeds to tell me to just go for a marketing girl.
“And what about yo—“ she started. “I’m a banker,” I flaunted. It’s been three years and I’ve yet to close a deal.
“Woww,” she smiled. “My brother works at Goldman. Where do you work?”
Fuck.
“Oh, haha,” I chuckled (yes, I said “haha” out loud.) “I’m at a smaller bank, you probably don’t know it. We’re small, but we’re growing a lot. And, you know, that means a lot more responsibility as a junior.” I cut myself off before prattling about how all these analysts at bigger banks don’t get the same senior-level exposure, and that I, unlike them, am not just a cog in the system. I would have kept going had I not noticed my errant gaze falling down her top. She seemed, or at least pretended, not to notice.
“Hit me!” she says. “I was thinking of doing IB recruiting, I probably know it.” A big grin spanned across her face.
“Oh, well I’m at KeyBanc,” I said slowly.
Her smile dropped and her forehead creased in pure disgust.
“Oh my God,” she started, placing her hand on her chest. “Wasn’t that place just listed F-Tier in the ‘2026 IB PRESTIGE TIER LIST [UNBIASED] on Wall Street Oasis?”
I didn’t even have time to respond before she walked away.
To the sophomore who wrote that list, fuck you.
Did this actually happen? - Sophomore recruiting keybanc
Username checks out
Based on the most helpful WSO content, this story is a hilarious yet exaggerated take on the obsession with prestige in the finance world. While it's clearly written with humor and satire, it does highlight a real issue: the undue weight some people place on the name of the bank rather than the individual’s character or skills.
Here’s the deal: prestige might matter to some, but it’s not the end-all-be-all. If someone judges you solely based on the name of your bank, they’re probably not worth your time. Focus on building genuine connections with people who value you for who you are, not just where you work. And hey, KeyBanc or not, you’re still in IB—plenty of people would kill for that opportunity. Keep your head up, and maybe next time, skip the “haha” out loud!
Hilarious - something similar happened to me.
Should’ve said you were a corporate banker!
Corporate and Investment Banker, thank you very much.
Ipsa distinctio suscipit aperiam sint. Non ratione quia explicabo consequatur provident. Iure minima expedita et minus cupiditate sed.
See All Comments - 100% Free
WSO depends on everyone being able to pitch in when they know something. Unlock with your email and get bonus: 6 financial modeling lessons free ($199 value)
or Unlock with your social account...