How do YOU manage networking requests?
Pure curiosity as the current sophomores are ramping up networking and I have been receiving a bunch of emails. I dont find it annoying or anything, I just think it can be a bit of an unfortunate, transparent process sometimes and dont pay it much thought. Probably partially because I didnt intern in the biz/do all this.
- Do you talk to everyone who reaches out? Do you decide based on resume? Depends on mood?
- Do you ask them any serious questions? How do you gauge interest?
- Do you refer them to other people at the bank if they ask?
- Who do you give a referral to? Just the ones that impress? What if they are 'with it' but come off as too try hard?
- Do you get annoyed when they send you random WSJ articles three weeks later?
I tried to talk to kids if they put real effort into them, things like mentioned a common interest or were alumni in the same clubs.
Those kids probably have better convos too considering they took interest in me beyond copy and pasting from an LLM.
Def didn’t respond to chat gpt bullshit and you shouldn’t either.
Ai time
I'm a sophomore who is sending you WSJ articles lol
I have enough personal connections reaching out for cringey intros (LP's kid is a sophomore at a semi-target, "wants to chat about the recruiting process" etc) that there's zero time for strangers.
U not connected gng - stay in ya lane
I don’t respond to non-Americans of any country
Honestly, I don’t respond unless there email is timed to perfection and the stars align. 80% of the calls I’ve taken have been a complete waste of time, even at my “target / semi target” school
Honestly I take requests from
a) students who are obviously very well prepared, well read into the role. The only critical question I ask is why my firm and my role to see if they research. I’m usually open to providing a referral to these candidates
b) students who appear to be so unbelievably lost or lack experience, who probably struck out on clubs but are making a real effort to figure it out on their own. I was in their situation my sophomore year and I happened to have a friend from HS who really helped me learn everything to interview for top roles. I try to pass on this advice to these folks since the advice is valuable to them and they’re usually gracious for your time rather than some lame hardo
how do you know if students even fall into these two buckets? From resume/experience alone?
Most prepared students will add an anecdote either about my profile or the company. If it’s clearly just a copy+paste template with no originality I usually ignore
Most “lost” students will try to be a little too personal in their initial message, or clearly one that they came up with and not a “club or AI template” or anything like that. Another indicator is if they picked up local internships to their hometown to try to get any kind of experience.
Obviously people are much more than their resumes, but I typically feel it’s pretty easy to tell what state a student is at since I’m familiar with all of these types of people from undergrad.
I’ll talk to any kid from my school, and I’ll occasionally talk to other non targets I can as long as their email, resume, and LinkedIn are good.
youre a good person
It is pretty simple for me.
(1) I will always make time for anyone from KU/UW-Madison/Stevenson/Menominee. I may only be available to talk to them at 8pm on a Sunday, but I will find a way to make myself available.
(2) I will try to make time for referrals during the business day. I won't bend over backwards to make time to talk with them, but I will try to make it work.
(3) If they have a non-standard or unique background (ie - they are coming from an engineering background, they were a Team USA judoka but otherwise have no discernable thing of note, etc), I will try to find an open window that works.
(4) Basically, for anyone else that doesn't have a relevant last name I will send across whatever windows I have open and tell them that's their options and to deal with those availabilities.
Have heard mixed things on this, but should we attach a resume or not?
People say to leave it out because it seems transactional and may get filtered by Gmail. While others say to keep it because it helps differentiates people.
Thoughts?
Keep because the analysts are trying to find something to talk to you about too sometimes. Otherwise we don’t know anything about you realistically.
Got it, thanks. Would it be better to attach your LinkedIn in your email signature as a kind of subtle way of sending it instead of saying it directly and attaching a pdf?
Just attach it. We know you're looking for a job and were in your shoes before.
Thanks
Bump. Also curious to know whether I should attach resume or hyperlink my LinkedIn in my signature.
Entirely by feel based on my mood, how busy I am, how much unsolicited advice I think I can give, and my 20 second analysis of the person behind the email.
Just the reality. Probably good to put the truth out there too so when you get ignored you realize 9/10 it’s not even your fault.
I’ve archived so many emails to my “personal” drive only to immediately forget about them. It is what it is.
I'll try to go out of my way to help someone usually if they're from a similar background/region as me i.e. first-gen or east/south-east asian-american, grew up outside of the usual hardo hotspots (extra points for midwest, extra extra for anyone from minnesota/wisconsin lol) and seem like they aren't being spoonfed referrals by some other campus club already. When I went through the recruiting process, I felt like way too many resources went to the same type of kids every year so I feel like it's atleast a bit my duty to help bring up those who really have no other support in this process.
bump
bump
lol
🤔
Great question. For me, it's mostly about how they approach me. Personalized, concise emails that show they've actually read my background get a reply. Generic copy-paste blasts get ignored. I don't mind if they ask for a referral, but only after we've had a real conversation and I sense genuine interest. As for the random WSJ articles three weeks later—yes, it's slightly annoying if it feels forced, but I usually just reply with a brief 'thanks for sharing.' The ones who impress me are those who ask thoughtful questions about the actual work, not just 'what's the culture like.
Agree lol
Bump!
bumppp
bump
Bump
would y'all be more likely respond if im a 10/10...?
I usually reply to people who put in some effort. Generic messages get ignored. Referrals happen after a real chat, and random articles later just get a quick “thanks.”
I’ll just spend 15 minutes a night on a resume / email that catches my eye lol ik what it’s like to recruit plus I spend all day at a desk I might as well
bump
Pariatur culpa odit eius. Omnis rerum ex necessitatibus cumque dolorum quis. Eos suscipit ut a officiis voluptas. Consequuntur et consequatur nobis. Pariatur unde occaecati dolor aut blanditiis.
Repellendus accusamus et omnis quia. Libero et corporis aut vero excepturi. Qui placeat sed sunt alias quas. Fuga eligendi dolorum sit tempora. Rerum cum excepturi voluptatibus delectus error.
See All Comments - 100% Free
WSO depends on everyone being able to pitch in when they know something. Unlock with your email and get bonus: 6 financial modeling lessons free ($199 value)
or Unlock with your social account...
Dolorem quos nihil adipisci sit. Reprehenderit rerum modi est quisquam.
Quia est ea dignissimos quam eligendi est. Molestiae id itaque veniam est inventore ipsam reiciendis. Tempora est perspiciatis totam quas voluptates libero. Consequuntur mollitia magnam eius aut accusantium sed. Quod quia id beatae soluta et. Inventore sit rerum non quis velit et. Ea consequuntur sunt eos officia.