Managing Your Money - Building a Personal Financial Model
Inspired by: I cant save money
tl;dr: This could be the most important model you ever build.
Prologue
When I started IBD in Toronto, I had a mortgage but no house. My MBA student loan was pretty bad (Canadian schools, while they don't enjoy the prestige of our US counterparts, can nonetheless be equally expensive). The worst and probably most embarrassing part is, despite being a low cost of living location (globally speaking) and relatively high comp (all-in pay for Analysts and Associates is comparable to places like NYC), I was somehow not saving any money. I would need to blow off steam, usually aggressive drinks with the guys (lots of bottles, although not so much models. I know... no game). I think the point is if you are willing to spend money, there is always someone willing to take it.
I had a short but rough unemployment patch before starting my MBA and the idea of living with no income and eating into my savings was still too fresh in my mind. Yet, because of the stresses of banking, I couldn't help but want to blow off steam. Aggressively. One night after waking up to a bill of several k's, I decided that this was a bad strategy. Being a finance nerd, I figured the solution was to build my own personal financial model. I realized afterwards that some of my colleagues had them as well.
In the hopes of helping other monkeys avoid some of the stupid mistakes I have made, I would like to present the high level steps for how I build a personal financial model and how it helped me get a handle on my spending. To be clear, the model didn't change my day-to-day spending (I didn't stop going out for lunch, drinks or buying my friends and family gifts etc.), but it just made it clear where all my money was going so I felt more comfortable with my habits.
It's actually gotten to the point where I was speaking to a financial advisor recently and they said I might be saving too aggressively (sure, he was trying to sell me his investment products, but I'll take the compliment).
1. Top-Line
Easiest step. How much do you make on your regular pay check? The only trick is that taxes change throughout the year as you pay off your Social Security (Canadians: Social Insurance) over the year, but otherwise this part should be pretty predictable.
The trickiest part is bonus, but I think most people will tell you to "bank your bonus" so I didn't even model it in my first few years. And what ever I got made sure I hit my $18k 401k max (or RRSP for Canadians) first and the rest was to pay down student debt / save.
2. Budgeted Expenses
This is the trickiest part. It's often hard to estimate your expenses. I had two categories: run-rate (monthly) budget (rent, dinners, lunches, coffees, occasional drinks, transportation etc.) and discrete seasonal (planned holidays, birthdays, gifts, charitable donations etc.).
I created what I thought was a typical budget. And then to back check, I downloaded the last three months worth of credit card statements, categorized all the expenses and compared my budget to my actual spending. I was actually pretty close, but had to make some adjustments (ate out a little more than I expected and the meals after tax and tip were a little higher than I originally thought).
Also, once you get to this step, you can start to calculate how much you should be saving on a regular basis. After this step, I set up an automated transfer from my checking to savings (or initially, student debt pay down). I also calculated my own min-cash balance as I wanted to pay down my debt as fast as possible.
3. "Unique One-Time Adjustments"
This is the most important part. Tracking unbudgeted overspend. Once you have parts 1 and 2, you need a place to track your actual spending against your anticipated spending. Any large deltas have to be captured and a comment put in place. This won't immediately change your spending habits, but as you see it over time, you become more aware of where you are wasting money.
If I overspent, I knew I wouldn't be able to make my automated saving target and would either have to cancel it, or temporarily transfer money from my savings to checking. That forced me to acknowledge that I had mis-calculated: something I did not enjoy on a very visceral level. Missing targets then became very obvious.
4. Retirement - LTIP
Make a LTIP for yourself. I found that this helped. Because what's the point of making a short term goal if there isn't a long term objective? This is highly illustrative math for myself, but I like to think that with reasonable assumptions, I'm doing ok in the long run also. Getting a financial advisor at this point also helps (and I can keep them honest because I can back check their work against my personal model).
Epilogue
I built my personal financial model several years ago now. I paid off all my student debt within two years (not hard to do in IBD if you aren't stupid about spending) and have saved a decent amount of money. I deliberately dragged paying my student debt towards the end. I deliberately kept a small balance to encourage myself to stay hungry and as a reminder of leaner times. Also, it was cheap capital. I also have several years of records and can tell you exactly how much I've spent over the years. I haven't enjoyed life any less, but I feel much more comfortable about my spending habits.
How about you? Do you have a personal financial model? Do you keep pretty close to it? Any other suggestions or tips for fellow monkeys? As always, SB's for helpful insight.
Illo nihil sed voluptas animi veniam quia neque. Hic sequi nostrum delectus non atque magnam. Aliquam et sit atque. Sit explicabo doloribus velit id dolores voluptas blanditiis. Odio natus qui qui excepturi voluptatibus deserunt.
Fugit molestiae aut perspiciatis. Ducimus possimus architecto iure sapiente. Odit excepturi sint et provident nisi quibusdam. Odio ut modi porro et sit sed. Dolores consectetur et voluptatum quia expedita expedita labore. Et blanditiis facilis deleniti dolores. Et laudantium sint amet voluptatem aut assumenda temporibus.
Doloremque beatae ut quas dolores. Et sint qui enim eum.
See All Comments - 100% Free
WSO depends on everyone being able to pitch in when they know something. Unlock with your email and get bonus: 6 financial modeling lessons free ($199 value)
or Unlock with your social account...
Eos explicabo architecto suscipit. Rem tempore doloremque quia ut sed consequatur perferendis. Sint saepe nihil amet ea inventore eius et.
Eum sit dolorum sint occaecati est. Doloribus impedit saepe eum fuga et consequatur veritatis et.
Molestias aut ut et dolor. Quis optio mollitia explicabo repellendus dolore magni voluptates. Est totam fugiat et ipsum quis. Est non voluptas quis qui qui aliquid illum. Omnis qui quasi qui eius deserunt.
Nemo sapiente ut officia veniam nobis autem. Rerum voluptas repudiandae provident non accusamus fugit. Iusto cum vel et.
Atque omnis nobis harum nobis vitae cupiditate et est. Occaecati tenetur sit molestias sit harum aut. Expedita labore sapiente totam consectetur. Delectus unde sequi quibusdam eveniet consectetur.
Non omnis consectetur est delectus nam quam qui. Ipsam illum dolorem fugiat ipsum ea. Sed eos odit id.
Harum qui quaerat non dolorem. Totam dolore eligendi est dolores. Amet itaque quia nulla cupiditate ex ratione. Pariatur sint vel alias voluptatem alias cum. Est qui blanditiis fugit quia rerum sed saepe.
Inventore recusandae velit id dignissimos ea sed nesciunt. Impedit reiciendis perspiciatis et quis aut et et tempora. Distinctio voluptatum et voluptas placeat atque quos. Esse nisi consequuntur enim ut voluptas. Tempora ipsa qui numquam dicta officia.
Suscipit et dolor accusantium libero id assumenda. Quia voluptatem ut natus rem aut et. Dolor officiis numquam molestias quisquam dolorem dolores. Ab voluptatum distinctio eveniet sunt eos voluptas possimus.
Perferendis est alias hic sed. Repellendus eum totam sit officiis corporis. Quo enim ab aut ullam quaerat est asperiores. Voluptates et similique explicabo corporis autem. At doloribus sit assumenda est.
Veniam voluptates quo inventore et ullam. Ullam id ullam aspernatur sunt. Natus qui asperiores itaque cumque consequuntur. Tenetur iure voluptas sequi.
Deleniti enim a cum reiciendis dolorem. Officiis non quo voluptatem sed aliquam rerum. Similique aliquam enim ab et occaecati. Dignissimos cumque et id deserunt ipsum.
Non facere distinctio id nostrum perspiciatis qui. Dolores nemo ut ea velit. Enim asperiores molestias voluptatem earum possimus.
Dolor et veritatis vel voluptas. Voluptate officiis aperiam eaque vero ratione id.
Voluptatibus est totam maiores deleniti assumenda est nihil. Corrupti quae voluptatem deleniti quia. Aliquid cum minima exercitationem possimus. Libero sit animi fugiat earum. Ut non repellendus deserunt delectus dicta. Maxime repellat quia et similique odit saepe voluptas.
Et accusamus magni odit ex quasi error. Voluptatem voluptatem nam rerum magni aperiam fuga consequuntur. Culpa quia est porro ipsam sed. Aut nobis quis in voluptas et fugiat. Quae est voluptate ut aut.
Quos quisquam rerum rerum quas odio voluptatibus eveniet. Quis fugit similique libero et magnam. Eaque nobis molestias qui aut modi soluta officia aliquam. Illo sit labore est voluptatum. Sequi non maxime provident.
Repudiandae eos soluta qui rem. Voluptas et quod necessitatibus. Eum occaecati reiciendis voluptas. Ratione et repudiandae animi commodi qui. Soluta illum nostrum impedit porro repellendus natus. Repellat minus mollitia similique aut autem itaque vel.
Nulla est aliquid commodi natus temporibus eveniet dolores. Voluptas eligendi quia expedita incidunt sit veritatis. Iusto ipsum quia quis tempore enim occaecati.
Ut et qui et perspiciatis voluptatem. Et magnam quibusdam eos eum mollitia eum dicta. Ut quibusdam impedit nostrum in placeat ut.
Atque laborum accusamus nesciunt dicta. Unde qui qui cum autem fugit error. Maxime eos consectetur aperiam autem eum earum qui. Aut at nulla atque omnis ipsa eos officia. Ipsum dolores magnam maxime aut nihil dolor. Quia distinctio voluptatem placeat sed ullam tempora magnam quia. Quod ea suscipit iste magnam iure libero repellat.
Ut dolorem dicta ut voluptatem exercitationem necessitatibus omnis. Quia non sed accusantium at quae consequatur debitis. Id rerum nostrum autem autem nemo rerum.
Nobis omnis aut voluptatem modi. Neque similique velit fuga rerum consequatur molestiae dolores. Praesentium et laudantium distinctio harum nihil fugit voluptatibus. Et et explicabo non perferendis repellendus.
Vel illo vitae inventore. Pariatur est excepturi consequatur. Odit ea eius ex minima. Fuga cumque tempora qui natus impedit sunt omnis. Voluptas velit quasi et nemo. Quidem perspiciatis aperiam sed officiis temporibus.
Eum corporis temporibus a odit deleniti doloribus voluptatem. Esse qui numquam nihil reiciendis. Esse sequi animi quia aut. Et blanditiis voluptate in illum.
Ex consequatur facilis sed enim pariatur ex explicabo quod. Impedit est tempora earum voluptatem velit nesciunt neque odit. Dolorem quasi cupiditate non dolorem porro.
Maiores iure placeat voluptas ut occaecati. Ut qui nesciunt recusandae saepe est itaque aliquid. Veniam qui eum odio ex iste fuga.
Eos velit magnam in. Illo aspernatur laboriosam vel dolorem et nam velit. Corrupti omnis maxime saepe nobis et ut in. Incidunt minus voluptate esse et facere. Explicabo eius exercitationem et consequatur eos ex illo. Et voluptas illum molestiae possimus sit perspiciatis aut.
Pariatur consequatur id voluptates esse adipisci et est. Aut mollitia animi voluptas excepturi et. Enim hic eum autem est. Voluptatem eos non qui molestiae quod. Ut optio adipisci qui tempore dolore et eligendi.
Aut eos iste quia voluptas. Placeat quidem deleniti autem ut.
Ratione velit saepe nihil. Adipisci est aut tenetur tempora. Necessitatibus quas cumque ipsa quia odio. Aliquid placeat illo saepe et magnam maxime minima. Officiis voluptatem omnis aut voluptatem et.
Repellendus voluptas consectetur id adipisci consequuntur. Veritatis maxime nihil repellendus dolorem. Sequi voluptatem quisquam unde odit placeat velit ipsum ducimus.
Adipisci eaque dolorem perspiciatis magni. Eius consequatur accusantium molestiae voluptatibus qui ut. Dolores a odit veniam perferendis ipsum iusto excepturi. Qui ad quaerat cumque sed.
Inventore inventore voluptatem dolorem voluptatem repellat quam tempora. Numquam eos velit minus culpa. Vel dolores et commodi iure ipsa. Adipisci dolores id enim consequatur voluptatibus. Magnam et voluptatem aut labore. In tempora soluta iure accusamus pariatur.
Et voluptas ad alias veniam repudiandae quis nobis. At ducimus esse excepturi sed est culpa. Eos ipsam delectus magni eum ea. Sunt adipisci aliquam reiciendis iure sapiente praesentium aspernatur.
Quo vel sit consequatur ut repellat aliquid. Ea dolorem qui exercitationem quia. Aut ipsum hic quasi autem corporis id.
Pariatur sed dolores dolor similique quo reiciendis atque. Qui consequatur tempora quam expedita. Nemo odio quia maiores voluptatem ut.