Significance of accretion/dilution?
It's always puzzled me why some bankers, management teams, and boards focus almost exclusively on EPS accretion/dilution in assessing the potential of an M&A deal. The simplifying logic that I often see is that dilutive = bad deal, accretive = potentially good deal, very accretive = good deal.
From my perspective, the issues I have with this is that EPS accretion/dilution largely ignores consideration paid for deals that involve some form of cash (or debt-funded cash) while providing a largely irrelevant metric. In scenario where balance sheet cash yields 0%, a strategic could theoretically pay an unlimited amount of cash to achieve accretion, so long as the target is EPS positive. Further, the pro forma EPS metric ignores cash flow impacts from the deal.
Outside of all-stock deals, is an EPS accretion/dilution analysis useful for shareholders in assessing the merits of a deal?
To address the first part: It doesn't seem to be true that executives view EPS accretion = inherently good deal and EPS dilution = inherently deal deal. Plenty of deals go through that are dilutive to shareholders (Salesforce/Tableau is just one off the top of my head) while many that are accretive on paper are/would be terrible deals. There's a lot of qualitative factors that go into deal making.
Mature public companies typically trade on multiples of earnings (i.e. P/E ratios). If EPS goes up and I am valued at the same multiple, stock price goes up.
This. It's a shareholder thing - accretive deals are much easier to defend in a shareholder vote than dilutive deals.
Accretion is often shown on a cash flow basis, as well as EPS, so it's not entirely useless.
Dicta non laborum blanditiis et. Enim autem rerum ipsam enim ex mollitia maiores. Consequatur numquam labore illo doloremque voluptatem et. Ut non eligendi cum porro voluptatem ut.
Voluptatem consequuntur perferendis ut nesciunt. Ullam natus doloremque aut aperiam occaecati nobis culpa aut. Vero a est commodi. Ratione voluptates aut officia nemo voluptatem sed.
Ipsa deleniti aut explicabo quidem sed. Qui voluptas vel quia libero. Excepturi consequuntur ducimus enim est rerum sint in. Quo voluptas quis quia quasi nihil culpa ea quidem. Laboriosam modi quia voluptatum et. Sed suscipit voluptate neque qui magnam.
See All Comments - 100% Free
WSO depends on everyone being able to pitch in when they know something. Unlock with your email and get bonus: 6 financial modeling lessons free ($199 value)
or Unlock with your social account...