Weird to Ask Your Manager Why You Didn't Get a Return Offer?

Title mostly says it all and ignore the prospect in consulting. I did my SA stint at a small boutique IB over the summer and didn't end up receiving a return offer. Is it weird to ask your manager during the SA why you didn't get the return? I want to genuinely learn from this experience and see what I can do to improve going forward.Any input is appreciated.

6,459 WSO Academy Investment Banking Session Reviews: 4.82/5

Nov 2026 Cohort

5.00/5

Investment Banking Mock Coffee Chat

“Ernest was extremely helpful and candid throughout our conversation. He gave me a clear, honest picture of why he moved into investment banking and how Evercore’s structure works, including the shift from a generalist program to the pod system and how specialized groups like RESA recruit directly. His explanation of why Evercore’s integrated coverage and product model creates more well-rounded bankers was especially insightful, and his example of co-advising alongside Morgan Stanley with a much leaner team showed me how much responsibility juniors get early on. His recruiting advice was practical and specific. He pointed me to technical resources, including Evercore’s own technical page, the 400 guide, Peak Frameworks, and shortcuts for converting IRR to MOIC. He emphasized building an anecdotal “why Evercore” answer from real conversations, focusing deeply on one industry, and tailoring my questions to the seniority of the person I’m speaking with. I left with a concrete plan for preparing for recruiting and would gladly speak with him again.”

Class of '29 Sep 2026 Cohort

5.00/5

Investment Banking Mock Coffee Chat

“Constantin is extremely nice and helpful! We talked about some genergal questions I had about recruiting and networking, and then dived into more specific problems I had. He has not only very knowledgable, but also very helpful, sharing also personal ancedotes to tell me what my next steps should be. ”

See All 11,834 WSO Academy Reviews

1 Comments

IB

Intern in IB - Gen

5y

Voluptatem adipisci molestiae explicabo minus soluta rerum et. Voluptatibus et laudantium vitae consequuntur et et nihil. Qui sequi nihil accusamus aperiam qui est quos quo. Quia repellat et non accusamus non.

Corrupti aut inventore est. Debitis ex enim corporis excepturi.

Reply

Quote

Report

Other

Authored by: Certified Corporate Strategy Professional - 2nd Year AnalystCertified Corporate Strategy Pro

Trending Content - Investment Banking Forum

+321	I Snuck Into UBS Office And Took A Shit On The Floor	28	1d
+279	Predicted 1Q 2027 Story - UBS IB blames Outlook Outage for Down Quarter	41	1h
+256	Houston 2026 Oil & Gas Investment Banking Rankings	67	4h
+244	Why leave restructuring for M&A?	31	4h
+232	Best Power/Renewables/Energy Teams?	39	20h
+184	Actual EB List	27	1d
+182	Incoming TPH Analysts Larping as PWP on LinkedIn	27	12h
+33	Embarrassed getting off at UBS train stop	5	33s
+24	I built a game to help me practice fundamentals like DCF, merger models and LBOs. Roast it?	6	13h
+22	What’s the current state of IBD at BofA?	28	2h

Career Resources

1	redever	99.2
2	kanon	99.0
3	BankonBanking	99.0
4	Secyh62	99.0
5	CompBanker	98.9
6	GameTheory	98.9
7	dosk17	98.9
8	DrApeman	98.9
9	Betsy Massar	98.9
10	Mimbs	98.8

Elite Career Bootcamp. Top Job Offer Guaranteed.

Elite Career Bootcamp. Top Job Offer Guaranteed.

Weird to Ask Your Manager Why You Didn't Get a Return Offer?

Score Breakdown

Feedback

Score Breakdown

Feedback

Elite Career Bootcamp. Top Job Offer Guaranteed.

Elite Career Bootcamp. Top Job Offer Guaranteed.

Weird to Ask Your Manager Why You Didn't Get a Return Offer?

See All Comments - 100% Free

Trending Content - Investment Banking Forum