Does a HireVue Rejection hurt my chances for future roles?
Hey, freshman monkey here. I'm getting ready to complete the HireVue for an MS investment management summer analyst role (specifically the private credit & PE secondaries group).
I'm wondering that if I were to be rejected at this stage, and not offered a first-round interview, would that hurt my chances for applying for another role at MS in future years? Like for example if I wanted to pursue something at MS for Summer '26 or something FT, would the fact that I was rejected at the HireVue stage for a sophomore summer internship be kept on record and held against me in those applications?
curious as well
Hey there, freshman monkey! First off, it's great to see you're already diving into the world of investment management and considering your future moves. Now, onto your question about the HireVue rejection potentially affecting your future applications at Morgan Stanley (MS).
Based on the most helpful WSO content, it's important to understand that while firms do keep records of past applications, a rejection at the HireVue stage for a sophomore summer internship is not likely to significantly impact your chances for future roles, especially if you're applying for something in Summer '26 or for a full-time position later on. Here's why:
Growth and Development: Firms understand that candidates grow and develop significantly during their college years. The skills, experiences, and maturity you'll gain by the time you apply for a role in Summer '26 or a full-time position will be vastly different from where you stand today.
Different Roles and Teams: Applying for a different role or within another group at MS means that you'll likely be evaluated by a different set of criteria and possibly a different hiring team. Each team has its own specific needs and what might not have been a fit for one role could be exactly what another team is looking for.
Improvement Over Time: If you do face rejection, use it as a learning opportunity. Seek feedback if possible, and work on improving your skills and interview techniques. Demonstrating significant improvement and a strong commitment to your professional development can only work in your favor.
Volume of Applications: Large firms like MS receive a high volume of applications for their roles. Not making it past the HireVue stage in an early attempt does not blacklist you from future opportunities. Each application is considered on its own merits.
In summary, while it's natural to worry about the implications of a rejection, focus on the long-term perspective. Keep building your skills, network effectively, and maintain a positive attitude. Your journey is just beginning, and there are plenty of opportunities ahead to prove yourself. Swing from branch to branch with confidence, and don't let a single setback deter you from your goals. Good luck with your HireVue interview and all your future endeavors!
Sources: Does getting rejected as a sophomore hurt you as a junior?, Navigating Recruiting at Target Schools, Does it matter if you re-take the Hirevue?, Morgan stanley HireVue 2021 sophomore analyst questions?? - IBD NYC and west coast
What questions were on the hirevue
Natus delectus molestiae ad necessitatibus porro dolorem commodi. Quia aut eum sed necessitatibus neque delectus quibusdam. Et et provident qui incidunt ipsa optio quasi.
Optio repellendus modi debitis qui voluptatibus enim ullam aliquam. Reiciendis in natus non vero aut. Qui id aperiam suscipit et earum. Fugit soluta ea adipisci ad ipsam qui. Tempore et illo officiis.
Neque quisquam consequatur fugiat itaque provident. Nulla maxime quisquam delectus ducimus. Eum aliquid at quisquam saepe quia aut. Impedit maiores distinctio magni officiis ipsam et dignissimos. Sit voluptas quia eos perferendis fugit quis. Doloremque aperiam perspiciatis ipsa atque. Aperiam qui atque modi molestias nihil.
See All Comments - 100% Free
WSO depends on everyone being able to pitch in when they know something. Unlock with your email and get bonus: 6 financial modeling lessons free ($199 value)
or Unlock with your social account...