Quant Position or a PhD Offer?
Have secured two offers in a large european country, 23M, International Student, relatively poor home country, Masters in Applied Math from one the best tech schools in the european country.
1) PhD position, employed as a researcher at the university offering 60k EUR gross, a very solid offer for Europe and works out to about 3k/mo net. Rents with 1-2 flatmates can be around 600-800, thus can save about 40% of my net salary with ease. Solid reseach group reputatation, expected duration 4 years.
2) Quant Analyst positon at a large european bank's regional headquarters, on the equity derivatives desk. Pay is about 80k + bonus, putting me in the top 5% of my country's new grads. Works out to 4-4.5k net, so lots of disposable income and about a 50% savings rate is very doable. Role is more quant dev than quant research, basically I'd be buildiing tools for traders, improving internal models, integrating our systems to the global bank's, and automating processes, but still quite removed from PnL.
While I have the technical aptitude to be a good researcher and a quant, I think long term I do not want to be a developer, regardless of my salary. I also do not wish to stay in academia after a PhD. Ultimately, I want to end up in a more strategy/advisory based role, even if it leans technical, perhaps in government advisory or company boards. The European Central Bank as an end-career destination also sounds very interesting.
Factors I've been considering:
1. Salary: Salary is excellent at either place, but of course the quant offer provides a living standard that few people my age would have. But I am not a big spender, and would likely save most of my money. The only thing I can imagine spending on is travel, but the kind of travel I enjoy is also not too expensive (No fancy hotels, business class etc.).
2. Savings: Savings rate is higher in the second offer, but my parents have saved enough in my home countru that I have a solid safety net if I need it, so my savings during ages 24-28 is not the biggest worry.
3. Mobility: The bank has a large presence in UK and Asia, and I would be interested in the possibility of changing countries down the line. I cannot imagine spending the rest of my life only in the country I am in right now, even after I get citizenship here (due in the next year).
4. Flexibility: I've interned as a quant at this bank before, and expected hours are about 8 AM - 6:30 PM with no overtime pay. During big market events, (the US Election for example), the team works from 3 AM onwards, and it would likely be hard to use the generous vacation days offered during these times and remote work out of the EU is impossible. (30 days paid time off). My family is getting sicker in my home country, so the flexibility of a PhD researcher position is attractive in case I need to head home for a week in an emergency.
5. Title/Prestige: My parents are academics, and I am attracted to the Dr. Title. It likely still carries weight in my current country to prove technical legitimacy, perhaps even more if I want to move into strategic roles. The opportunity cost of four years (will graduate at 28) not working is also a factor though.
How should I reasonably go about this decision?
Based on the most helpful WSO content, here’s a breakdown of your situation and factors to consider:
1. Career Alignment with Long-Term Goals
2. Salary and Savings
3. Flexibility and Work-Life Balance
4. Mobility and Future Opportunities
5. Prestige and Title
6. Opportunity Cost
Recommendation
If your long-term goal is to transition into strategy/advisory roles or institutions like the European Central Bank, the PhD seems like the better fit. It aligns with your aspirations, offers flexibility, and provides a prestigious credential that could be valuable in your desired career path.
However, if you’re more inclined toward immediate financial stability, industry experience, and global mobility, the quant role is a strong option. Just be mindful of the potential challenges in pivoting to strategic roles later.
Ultimately, consider which path aligns more closely with your values and long-term vision. If flexibility and alignment with your end goals are priorities, the PhD might be the way to go. If financial independence and immediate industry exposure are more important, the quant role could be the better choice.
Sources: Deciding on quantitive majors/career path?, Ask Me Anything - Buy Side Systematic Quant
At face value a quant position at a large UK/Asian bank that puts you in the top 5% of new grads for your country seems like a no brainer. Does the PhD position have any real world applications? Once you complete this PhD, what can you do with it outside of academia?
Maybe I don't understand the European academic/research market, so I could be wrong and please don't take this the wrong way, but how can someone who has spent their entire adult life in academia, with no real world professional experience, immediately jump to "Strategy" or "advising" roles on company boards or government advisory? I suppose going straight to a government related role makes more sense than a company board. But it still seems a bit odd to me.
If the PhD program is for a very in demand subject, from an elite university with global recognition, and has a history of placing graduates into company boards or government banks, then I could see going that route. But can't you always come back to this PhD program in a couple years if you hate the Quant role? It seems like it would be a lot harder to do the opposite.
Voluptatem velit laboriosam vitae delectus et est ducimus. Vel reprehenderit et cumque atque excepturi maxime sed doloribus. Quia ad harum corrupti.
Aspernatur qui saepe maxime. Beatae impedit consequatur est labore dignissimos. Ullam non suscipit aliquid sit maxime. Veritatis sunt quaerat ipsa reiciendis voluptas voluptate dolorem.
Quo sed fuga maiores fugiat explicabo molestiae eius illo. Repellendus suscipit minima mollitia exercitationem corporis nam deserunt eos. Quos aut voluptas culpa est et tenetur dolores.
Reprehenderit necessitatibus laboriosam distinctio doloremque molestiae ut praesentium. Officiis aliquid consequatur sunt amet saepe omnis. Nisi ea qui consequatur magnam veritatis.
See All Comments - 100% Free
WSO depends on everyone being able to pitch in when they know something. Unlock with your email and get bonus: 6 financial modeling lessons free ($199 value)
or Unlock with your social account...