How to Secure Higher Carry Award Before Promotion

For those in PE with fund-level carry and up for promotion, have you been able to obtain a carry allocation in the next fund that would normally be awarded to those at the next title up? If so, how were you able to do this? Did you need to do anything proactively on your part or did the Partners on their own award you the higher carry package?

For example, if fundraising is starting for the next fund and the Partners are deciding carry allocations for the team, say you're a Principal roughly a year away from promotion to MD and the firm is planning to promote you (however, it's not clear whether promotion will occur this year or next year). In this example, would the Partners typically give you an MD carry award in the upcoming fund? Or would they just look at everyone's current titles (i.e., Principal for you) and give you a carry allocation based on that?

Recognize every firm may do this differently, I have seen it done in the past where if the Partners knew they were going to promote a Principal, they would give them the higher carry award commensurate with the next title up (in this case MD). Their logic would be that this person is going to spend the majority of their time deploying the fund as an MD and should therefore get the higher carry associated with being an MD even if they're not technically that title today.

I also recognize other Partners may want to take more of the carry for themselves and not be as generous and would therefore give this Principal a Principal level carry package. This would be a bit frustrating given the person would then need to wait another ~5 years for the next fund to get an MD carry package.

This is clearly less of an issue for those with deal-by-deal carry where individuals with carry can get allocated basis points for the investments made each year. As a result, there is no such thing as missing the fund cutoff given whenever promotion happens, these individuals can immediately get a higher carry award in the following year's investments.

Would love advice on how others have navigated this situation as for those with fund-level carry, it can put a lot of pressure on one to secure a potential promotion sooner rather than later so as not to miss a cut off in higher carry award in the next fund.

2 Comments

WSO Monkey Bot

O

6h

Based on the most helpful WSO content, securing a higher carry award before a promotion in private equity can be a nuanced process, and strategies may vary depending on the firm's culture and structure. Here are some key insights and actionable advice:

1. Understand the Firm's Carry Allocation Process

Carry is typically allocated on a per-fund basis, and once a new fund is raised, carry grants are fixed for the life of that fund. This means timing is critical, as missing the allocation for a new fund could delay your ability to secure a higher carry package until the next fundraising cycle.
Some firms may proactively allocate carry based on anticipated promotions, while others strictly adhere to current titles when determining carry awards.

2. Proactively Communicate with Partners

If you are a Principal nearing promotion to MD, it’s essential to have open and transparent discussions with the Partners. Highlight your contributions, future potential, and the fact that you will likely spend the majority of the fund's deployment period as an MD.
Establish expectations early. If the Partners are aware of your impending promotion, they may be more inclined to allocate carry at the MD level in the upcoming fund.

3. Leverage Fundraising Timing

Fundraising periods are critical junctures for carry allocation. If you know a new fund is being raised and you are close to promotion, make your case for a higher carry award during this time. Partners may be more flexible in these discussions, especially if they value your long-term contributions.

4. Demonstrate Value and Build a Case

Showcase your track record of sourcing and executing deals, as well as your ability to contribute to the fund's success. If your firm has a culture of rewarding performance, this can strengthen your argument for a higher carry allocation.
If your firm uses a "global carry pool" model, emphasize your role in driving overall fund performance rather than just individual deals.

5. Consider Firm Culture and Politics

Some firms are more generous with carry allocations, while others may prioritize senior Partners retaining a larger share. Understanding your firm's dynamics can help you tailor your approach.
If internal politics are a factor, align yourself with influential Partners who can advocate for your higher carry award.

6. Plan for Vesting and Timing

Most funds have a vesting schedule for carry, meaning you may forfeit some or all of your carry if you leave before a certain period. Ensure you understand these terms and how they might impact your decision-making.

7. Alternative Structures

If your firm offers deal-by-deal carry, this can provide more flexibility, as carry allocations can be adjusted annually based on your contributions and promotions. If this structure is available, it may alleviate the pressure of securing a higher carry award tied to fund-level allocations.

8. Be Prepared for Pushback

Not all Partners may agree with awarding carry based on anticipated promotions. If you encounter resistance, focus on building a strong case for your future contributions and the value you bring to the firm.

Final Thoughts:

Navigating carry allocation before a promotion requires a combination of strategic communication, timing, and understanding your firm's culture. By proactively engaging with Partners and demonstrating your value, you can increase your chances of securing a higher carry award in the next fund. However, be prepared for variability, as every firm handles these situations differently.

Sources: Confused about carry at PE Fund, No country for old I-bankers (starting a mid-career thread for finance professionals)

Reply

Quote

Report

Other

I'm an AI bot trained on the most helpful WSO content across 17+ years.

kuf135

VC

31m

Et nihil ut omnis voluptatem nesciunt. Asperiores qui atque repellat perferendis harum facere et sed. Ullam eligendi quia hic tempore dolorem praesentium nihil. Debitis eveniet eveniet aut sit accusantium.

Sapiente laboriosam molestias illum voluptatibus. Minima mollitia qui aut ullam et facere. Consectetur deserunt esse minima ut inventore fugit fuga eos. Pariatur enim id distinctio quaerat sit quis est.

Quia maiores est et qui ut eum voluptas. Tenetur quis vero omnis fugit. Voluptas sequi aut aliquid praesentium ex. Earum fugiat eum nihil consequatur praesentium repellendus magni.