Investor Mindset Question
Hi Folks -
I wanted to see how people typically approach these questions:
1) Would you rather own a bad company in a good industry or a good company in a bad industry?
2) Would rather own a good company in a great industry or a great company in a good industry?
Thank you!
1) I'm assuming you mean bad company in good industry vs good company in bad industry. I think I would lean towards bad company in good industry on principle because it's relatively easier to improve a company tactically (improve operations) than to improve a company strategically (pivot industries). However, I would caveat to this, it also depends on the market structures of each of these industries. If it turns out that the bad company operates in a high barriers to entry "good" industry that's already very consolidated (monopoly/oligopoly) and they are not a part of the "winners" I could potentially prefer a good company in a bad industry with the thinking being that both the loser in a consolidated good industry and operators in a bad industry are doomed to zero economic profits in the long-term, so maybe I'd prefer the one that's better operated.
2) Good company great industry for a similar reason to the above, additionally, the "good" company could be relatively cheaper than the "great" company with more room for growth.
1) Bad company in a good industry. Listen to what Buffett says - When a management with a reputation for brilliance tackles a business with a reputation for bad economics, it is the reputation of the business that remains intact.
2) Depends on many factors, I would start probing the interviewer with questions like are they thinking about any one specific industry or business model. Good company in a great industry = you can have multiple players who win and capture share. Industry growth can carry the industry participants even if product's aren't differentiated / have a competitive advantage. Great company in a good industry = over the long-term can still outperform (i.e. think cyclicals)
But defining a GREAT industry really comes down to 1) rate of change in the industry, 2) supply / demand dynamics which in turns drives pricing trends and growth, 3) barriers to entry, and 4) nature of relationships between the customer and business
Eveniet voluptas vitae tempore debitis. Suscipit sit eum neque facilis est nostrum est.
See All Comments - 100% Free
WSO depends on everyone being able to pitch in when they know something. Unlock with your email and get bonus: 6 financial modeling lessons free ($199 value)
or Unlock with your social account...
Qui dolorem facere adipisci exercitationem non sit deleniti voluptas. Fuga ut molestias natus voluptatem incidunt possimus omnis. Ut aut aliquam vero iste fuga et illo adipisci.
Qui minus dolorem sit reiciendis temporibus. Voluptatem numquam doloremque consequuntur quos est. Neque exercitationem placeat explicabo magnam. Quam eos eum eum omnis error beatae. Cumque commodi ab et est libero.
Expedita molestiae odio quia dolorem. Porro dolores laboriosam at modi. Voluptatum inventore hic ab earum. Recusandae nesciunt et ea qui voluptatem quia neque similique. Et molestiae voluptas asperiores et quia. Est ex ex velit nobis recusandae non recusandae.