Career in CMBS / MBS
Does anyone work as a CMBS / MBS trader? Any insight on a career in this vertical would be appreciated? Do you find the work interesting? I come from a traditional real estate acquisitions background but am fairly intrigued by the space. Is there a lot of room for growth? Is comp strong? Is it a small space? Why don't more people head this route? Thoughts on which companies to pursue (aside from the banks) that have large CMBS operations? Thinking Cerberus, KKR? Any and all info is appreciated ?
Hey Analyst 1 in RE - Comm, I'm the WSO Monkey Bot...do any of these help:
More suggestions...
If those topics were completely useless, don't blame me, blame my programmers...
Anything at all fellas ? There must be some MBS folks here
Bump
I’m a 2nd year on a MBS desk at a MM bank. I come from a similar background where I did Single Family Rental portfolio management & acquisitions for a private equity fund. Physical real estate/acquisitions work didn’t do it for me.. too slow paced which is when I started thinking about a lateral. MBS/CMBS allows you to retain your interest in real estate while being in a much faster paced front office seat.
Pay is solid, little bit less than IB, but also half the hours with nice bonus/commission structures depending on your shop. I work from 6:45-5ish typically and love the environment. The work is extremely entertaining and mind provoking unlike some other flow desks. Within securitized products there are so many different verticals you can go down but from your background I think you’d like CMBS sales/trading but I think you’d also find MBS/ABS/CLO’s interesting. If you’re a collateral person who enjoys diving into loans you’ll find a fit somewhere in sec prods.
The securitized product market is very small.. seems like everyone knows each other. My head trader is great friends with traders at many other shops, and that seems to be the case throughout most of the street. I think a lot of people don’t want to go into this sector because it’s becoming more automated, but securitized products are unlike other flow sectors. It’s much harder to click buy on a screen for a domino’s royalty ABS securitization than it is on an Apple Corporate bond.
I think the upside is huge for young talent. The MBS space seems to have skipped a generation. It’s either 50+ year old people on the desk, or 20-30 year old. I haven’t met very many 30s-40s people in sec prods. I could be wrong but that’s my take.
Hope this helps.
I noticed the missing generation as well. My MD says they are the middle mgmt people (VPs, EDs, and some MDs) that got fired during the GFC. Which is also why so many MDs on my spg floor made MD at an age younger than the firm avg
Do you have any insight into agency MBS trading for an in-house mortgage originator vs working for a broker-dealer? Any differences there compared to what you mentioned?
Hey there, OP here. Big thanks for taking the time to share more about your background and the transition you made. As referenced, I currently work at a real estate private credit fund originating bridge, mezz, construction loans, but want to make the transition to CMBS / MBS on the trading side. Do you have any concrete suggestions for next steps I can take? Books / guides to read, how to network in the space, recruiters to go potentially go through, etc? Would really really appreciate any further advice here.
Also, would be helpful to hear how difficult it was to make the transition and what you did to make it possible. It seems as if the nature of the work / material is quite different. I’m not sure that my direct real estate experience will be appreciated by interviewers. Hoping to make this transition and assume it will be a long road to get there so any and all advice helps. Thanks in advance man!
Another question here. When you switched over how did your title hold up? IE analyst to analyst or aso to aso?
Did you ever make the move? Thinking about it as well.
How's the quant skills requirement there?
bumping this again to make the switch. acquisitions is slow but CMBS market seems like its pumping. At least trending from last year it is haha
Re: CMBS - still very much a niche and small slice of the structured products market...especially if we're talking about non-agency / private label. But because of that teams tend to run lean... both buy and sell side, which means more room for outperformance. Analysis also leans more "old school" vs other structured products like agency / non-agency MBS, which have become vastly more quantitative by nature of the underlying loans and how homogeneous they are. Impossible to automate analyzing chunky loans in a seasoned conduit deal with very spotty data
Can be a rewarding career if you (a) love commercial real estate, but don't want to get bogged down by the details / excessive due diligence of equity investing and (b) want to expand asset class horizons (you tend to become a jack of all trades across the major asset classes)
Also worth thinking about what type of shop you want to join if you're talking about buyside.. some shops are more credit-focused (hedge funds, credit arms of large asset managers e.g. KKR, BX) while others are going to be more flow driven (real money aka money managers, LifeCo etc.). Majority of new head count is going to be in these large real money shops by nature of the $s they need to deploy, but personally think being involved down the stack is way more fun (only so much analysis you can do when you're buying on-the-run AAA SASB...)
Dolorem voluptatem dolores vel ad id. Nihil dolores dolorem quibusdam culpa. Ut commodi quasi facilis provident possimus eius. Dolorem dolorum laboriosam vel iusto quos voluptatibus. Perspiciatis quo ab perspiciatis autem amet eligendi veniam sunt. Veritatis earum fugit quisquam similique explicabo. Alias commodi quod impedit rerum.
Repellendus culpa minima non cupiditate inventore est placeat. Numquam assumenda enim enim velit iure cupiditate consequatur maiores. Tempora asperiores quisquam ut similique.
See All Comments - 100% Free
WSO depends on everyone being able to pitch in when they know something. Unlock with your email and get bonus: 6 financial modeling lessons free ($199 value)
or Unlock with your social account...